Nonprofit and Religious Property Sales Selling property owned by a nonprofit or religious corporation.
A nonprofit cannot sell its building the way a private owner can. The board, sometimes the members or the denomination, and the Attorney General or a court all have a role.
We represent nonprofit corporations, congregations, and religious corporations, and the buyers, developers, and lenders who deal with them, in sales, long-term leases, mortgages, and development transactions.
New York requires approval for major real estate transactions by charitable and religious organizations. A not-for-profit corporation that sells, leases, exchanges, or otherwise disposes of all or substantially all of its assets needs approval under Not-for-Profit Corporation Law §§ 510 through 511-a. A religious corporation needs approval under Religious Corporations Law § 12 to sell, mortgage, or lease its real property for a term of more than five years, whether or not the property is substantially all of its assets. Since the Nonprofit Revitalization Act of 2013, most of these transactions can be approved by the Attorney General instead of a court, but court approval is still required in some cases, including when the corporation is or would become insolvent, and the Attorney General can direct an applicant to court for complex or contested transactions.
The approval standard has two parts. The consideration and terms must be fair and reasonable to the organization, and the transaction must promote its purposes or the interests of its members. The Attorney General’s Charities Bureau expects an independent appraisal, generally dated within 12 months and based on at least three comparable sales, a board vote of at least two-thirds of the entire board (or a majority if the board has 21 or more directors), member approval where members have voting rights, and a specific, itemized plan for the proceeds. Certain denominations, including Protestant Episcopal and Roman Catholic corporations, must proceed in court, and where a denomination’s rules require the consent of a diocese, synod, presbytery, or other governing body, that consent should be obtained and submitted with the petition.
Houses of worship increasingly sell or lease development rights or part of their sites to developers while keeping a sanctuary in the new building. Those deals combine a contract or ground lease, a zoning lot development agreement or transfer of development rights, a condominium structure for the religious space, and construction terms protecting the congregation during the work. Landmark designation can constrain them sharply: in St. Bartholomew’s Church v. City of New York, the federal court of appeals upheld the denial of a church’s plan to replace its landmarked community house with an office tower. Buyers should also check deeds for reverter clauses or denominational trust provisions, and expect property that was tax-exempt in the organization’s hands to become taxable once owned by a non-exempt buyer.
Our capabilities include:
- Attorney General and court approval petitions
- Board and member resolutions and governance review
- Denominational consents and church governance issues
- Appraisals, fairness analysis, and use-of-proceeds plans
- Air rights, ground lease, and joint development transactions
- Landmark and zoning constraints on religious and nonprofit sites
- Title issues, reverters, and deed restrictions
- Representation of buyers, developers, and lenders
Which approval applies
| Not-for-profit corporation | Approval needed to sell, lease, or otherwise dispose of all or substantially all assets (N-PCL §§ 510–511-a) |
|---|---|
| Religious corporation | Approval needed to sell or mortgage real property, or to lease it for more than five years (RCL § 12) |
| Attorney General approval | Available in most cases as an alternative to a court petition |
| Court approval required | When the corporation is or would become insolvent, for certain nominal-consideration transfers to other nonprofits, to confirm a transaction closed without approval, and for certain denominations |
| Board vote | At least two-thirds of the entire board, or a majority if the board has 21 or more directors, unless the bylaws require more |
| Member vote | Where members have voting rights, two-thirds of those present at a meeting, with affirmative votes at least equal to the quorum |
Selling with Attorney General approval
Confirm authority and consents
Review the certificate of incorporation, bylaws, deeds, and denominational rules, and identify every vote and consent required.
Obtain an appraisal
Engage an independent certified or licensed appraiser; a broker’s opinion is not sufficient.
Sign a conditional contract
Make the contract or lease contingent on approval, with no damages or specific performance if approval is denied.
Adopt resolutions
Have the board and, if required, the members approve the specific terms and the itemized use of proceeds.
Petition and respond
File the verified petition with supporting documents and answer the Charities Bureau’s questions.
Close and report
Close after approval and send the Attorney General the required closing notice and statement.
Issues specific to houses of worship
Denominational trust and consent
Some denominations hold property interests or require consents; New York courts have enforced denominational trust provisions in some cases.
Reverters and restrictions
Older deeds may contain reverter clauses or use restrictions; some restrictions can be extinguished in court if they no longer provide an actual and substantial benefit, but each requires title review.
Landmarks
Designated religious buildings need Landmarks Preservation Commission approval for exterior changes and demolition, and hardship relief is difficult to obtain.
Development rights
Unused floor area can be sold through a zoning lot merger or, for landmarks, transferred under the Zoning Resolution, subject to approval requirements.
Tax consequences
Portions of a site leased to or owned by non-exempt users generally lose the real property tax exemption, which should be reflected in the economics.
Key terms
- Religious corporation
- An entity incorporated under the Religious Corporations Law to hold property and conduct the temporal affairs of a congregation.
- Not-for-profit corporation
- A corporation formed under the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law for charitable or other nonprofit purposes.
- RCL § 12
- The Religious Corporations Law section requiring approval for sales, mortgages, and leases over five years of religious corporations’ real property.
- N-PCL § 510
- The section requiring approval for a nonprofit’s disposition of all or substantially all of its assets.
- N-PCL § 511-a
- The section allowing Attorney General approval of a disposition instead of court approval.
- Nonprofit Revitalization Act
- The 2013 New York law, largely effective in 2014, that modernized nonprofit governance and expanded Attorney General approval of asset dispositions.
- Charities Bureau
- The Attorney General’s office that reviews nonprofit and religious corporation petitions.
- Verified petition
- The sworn application for approval, with the contract, appraisal, resolutions, and financial information.
- Fair and reasonable
- The first prong of the approval standard, applied to the price and terms.
- Use of proceeds
- The required itemized description of how the organization will spend the sale proceeds.
- Denominational consent
- Approval from a diocese, synod, presbytery, or other governing body required by a denomination’s rules.
- Reverter
- A deed provision returning property to the grantor or its successors if a condition, such as religious use, ends.
- Zoning lot merger
- The combination of adjacent lots into one zoning lot, allowing unused floor area to be used on another part of the merged lot.
- Ground lease
- A long-term lease of land under which the tenant builds and owns improvements, requiring approval when a religious corporation is landlord for more than five years.
Questions we hear most
Does our church need court approval to sell its building?
Can a nonprofit sign a contract before approval is granted?
Can a congregation sell its air rights and keep its sanctuary?
How long does Attorney General approval take?
Does a mortgage by a religious corporation need approval?
Does a nonprofit need approval to sell a building that is not most of its assets?
What if a transaction closed without approval?
Can insiders buy property from the nonprofit?
What should a developer check before contracting with a church?
Do proceeds have to be escrowed?
Get in touch
Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.