Acquisitions and Dispositions

Madison Law Firm PLLC represents investors, owners, operators, and developers acquiring and disposing of commercial and investment property in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx — single buildings, development sites, and portfolios.

New York commercial transactions move on a negotiated contract of sale — not a standard form a broker fills in. The contract sets the deposit, the diligence window, the conditions to closing, who bears the transfer taxes, and what happens if title, zoning, or a tenant estoppel comes back wrong. By the time an investor notices a problem, the contract has usually already decided who pays for it.

Commercial property also carries obligations the buyer inherits: existing leases and the rent roll, rent-stabilized units and their registration history, open building violations, environmental conditions, and tax-benefit regulatory agreements. Each has to be read before the deposit goes hard.

We work from the investor's business plan backward — the hold period, the financing, the exit, whether the contract may be assigned, and whether the deal will be syndicated — and build the documents to fit it.

Our capabilities include:

  • Acquisitions of multifamily, mixed-use, retail, office & industrial property
  • Dispositions and seller-side contract drafting
  • Letters of intent and purchase & sale agreements
  • Legal due diligence: title, zoning, leases, rent regulation
  • Entity and LLC-interest acquisitions
  • Contract assignments and closing-entity structuring
  • Acquisition financing, 1031 exchanges, and closings

The acquisition, step by step

  1. Letter of intent

    Price, deposit, diligence period, closing date, and the deal points that will shape the contract — agreed before lawyers draft. We review LOIs before they are signed.

  2. Contract of sale

    The purchase and sale agreement fixes the deposit, the diligence window and termination rights, representations and their survival, closing conditions, assignment rights, and default remedies.

  3. Due diligence

    Title and survey, zoning and certificate of occupancy, open violations, leases and estoppels, rent-regulation history, environmental reports, service contracts, and property tax status — tracked against the contract's deadlines.

  4. Financing

    Loan commitment, lender diligence, entity documents, and mortgage recording tax planning, coordinated so the loan closes with the deed.

  5. Closing

    Deed, transfer-tax returns, assignments of leases and contracts, tenant notices, title insurance, and the closing statement — then recording and post-closing items.

Due diligence we run

Title & survey

  • Title report and exceptions
  • Liens, judgments, and UCC filings
  • Survey and encroachments
  • Easements, restrictive declarations, and air-rights agreements

Building & zoning

  • Zoning district and available floor area
  • Certificate of occupancy
  • DOB and HPD violations
  • Landmark and special-district status

Income & tenancies

  • Rent roll against leases
  • Tenant estoppel certificates
  • Rent-stabilization and DHCR registration history
  • Security deposits and arrears

Taxes & contracts

  • Real estate taxes and abatements (421-a, J-51, 485-x)
  • Transfer-tax exposure
  • Service, management, and brokerage contracts
  • Environmental Phase I / E-designations

Deal structures

  • Direct (fee) purchase

    The buyer takes title by deed, usually in a newly formed single-purpose LLC. Title insurance and transfer taxes follow the deed.

  • Entity (LLC interest) purchase

    The buyer acquires the company that owns the property. New York State and City transfer taxes can still apply to a transfer of a controlling interest, and diligence must cover the entity's history and liabilities.

  • Assignment of the contract

    Where the contract permits, a purchaser may assign it before closing — to an affiliate, a newly formed closing entity, or a third party. Seller consent, the original purchaser's continuing liability, and the transfer-tax treatment of any assignment consideration should be addressed when the contract is negotiated.

  • Joint venture or syndication

    Equity is raised from partners or passive investors through an operating agreement or a private offering, with federal and New York securities filings where required.

Key considerations in New York

  • Transfer taxes are part of the price

    For commercial property, New York City's Real Property Transfer Tax runs to 2.625% on transfers over $500,000, and the State transfer tax rises to 0.65% on commercial conveyances of $2 million or more. Allocation between buyer and seller is negotiated in the contract.

  • Entity transfers can be taxed too

    Selling the LLC that owns the building, rather than the building itself, does not avoid transfer tax: New York State and City both tax transfers of a controlling interest in an entity that owns real property.

  • Rent regulation drives value

    For multifamily and mixed-use buildings, rent-stabilization status, DHCR registration history, and post-2019 HSTPA limits on rent increases determine what the rent roll is actually worth.

  • Assignment rights must be negotiated

    Whether a buyer can assign the contract, close in a new entity, or bring in investors before closing depends on the contract language. Many seller forms restrict it. That clause is worth negotiating early.

What we handle

We represent the buy side and the sell side, sponsors and investors, owners and lenders' counterparties.

Acquisitions

Contract negotiation, diligence, and closing for income-producing and value-add property.

  • Contract of sale & rider negotiation
  • Rent roll, lease & estoppel review
  • Title, survey, zoning & violation searches
  • Rent-stabilization & DHCR history
  • Phase I environmental coordination
  • Closing & recording

Dispositions

Seller-side counsel that protects the price and limits post-closing exposure.

  • Seller contract drafting
  • Diligence data-room preparation
  • Representation & survival limits
  • Transfer-tax allocation
  • 1031 relinquished-property coordination
  • Payoffs, releases & closing statements

Investment Structures

The entity and capital structure behind the property.

  • Single-purpose LLC formation
  • Joint venture & operating agreements
  • Syndications & private placements
  • Contract assignments & closing entities
  • Acquisition & construction financing
  • Ground leases

Key terms

Letter of intent (LOI)
A short summary of the price, deposit, diligence period, and closing timeline that the parties sign before negotiating a full contract. It is usually non-binding, except for terms such as confidentiality or exclusivity that are expressly made binding.
Due diligence period
The window after signing in which the buyer investigates title, leases, physical condition, zoning, and environmental issues. Many commercial contracts let the buyer terminate for any reason during this period.
Hard deposit
The point at which the buyer’s deposit becomes non-refundable except for specific seller defaults. Deposits typically go hard when the diligence period ends.
Asset sale vs. entity sale
In an asset sale the deed to the property is conveyed; in an entity sale the buyer acquires the membership or partnership interests of the owner. The choice affects liabilities, lender consents, and title insurance.
Rent roll
The seller’s schedule of tenants, rents, terms, and deposits. Buyers test it against the actual leases, estoppel certificates, and, for regulated apartments, the DHCR registration record.
DHCR registration history
The rent-registration record that New York’s Division of Housing and Community Renewal keeps for rent-stabilized apartments. It is the starting point for confirming legal regulated rents.
Certificate of occupancy
The Department of Buildings document stating a building’s lawful use and occupancy. A mismatch between the C of O and actual use can limit financing, insurance, and rent collection.
Building violations search
A review of open Department of Buildings, HPD, and OATH/ECB violations and penalties. Violations generally run with the property, so the contract should address cures, credits, or escrows.
Phase I environmental site assessment
A records-and-site review of a property’s environmental history, used to identify recognized environmental conditions. If concerns appear, a Phase II involves sampling soil, groundwater, or soil vapor.
Bargain and sale deed with covenants
The deed form most often used in New York commercial and residential sales. Under the statutory form in Real Property Law § 258, the seller covenants only that it has not encumbered the property, not that title is perfect.
Assignment and assumption of leases
The closing document that transfers the landlord’s rights under existing leases to the buyer, who assumes the landlord’s obligations going forward.
Security deposit transfer
When a rental building is sold, General Obligations Law § 7-105 requires tenant security deposits to be turned over to the buyer, with notice to the tenants. Buyers usually require a credit or transfer at closing.
ACRIS
New York City’s online system for recording deeds and mortgages and filing transfer-tax returns in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx. Staten Island documents are recorded with the Richmond County Clerk.
Transfer-tax returns (RPT and TP-584)
The New York City Real Property Transfer Tax return and the New York State TP-584 that must be filed with each recorded deed. Both report consideration and compute the tax due.
FIRPTA withholding
Under Internal Revenue Code § 1445, a buyer from a foreign seller generally must withhold 15 percent of the amount realized and remit it to the IRS, unless an exception or withholding certificate applies.
Nonresident estimated tax (IT-2663)
A seller who is not a New York resident generally must pay estimated New York personal income tax on the gain at closing, using Form IT-2663, before the deed can be recorded.

Frequently asked questions

What does a commercial real estate attorney do in a New York City acquisition?

We negotiate the contract of sale, run legal due diligence (title, survey, zoning, building violations, leases, estoppels, and rent-regulation history), coordinate with the lender and title company, structure the buying entity, and manage the closing. On the sell side we draft the contract, prepare the diligence materials, and limit post-closing liability.

How long does a commercial closing take in NYC?

It depends on the deal. A typical financed acquisition runs 45 to 90 days from signed contract, driven mainly by the diligence period and the lender's timeline. Development sites and deals that need tenant estoppels, lender consents, or board approvals can take longer.

Who pays New York City and State transfer taxes on a commercial sale?

By statute the transfer taxes are the seller's obligation, but the contract can shift them, and in some deals the buyer agrees to pay. The allocation, and any gross-up when the buyer pays, should be settled in the contract, not at the closing table.

Can I buy a building in an LLC?

Yes, and most commercial buyers do. A single-purpose LLC can limit liability and is typically required by lenders. The operating agreement matters as much as the formation — especially when there are partners or outside investors.

Do you represent buyers in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx?

Yes. Our commercial practice is focused on those four boroughs, and each has its own pages on this site describing the rezonings and deal patterns we see there.

Can a purchaser assign a contract of sale before closing?

Only if the contract allows it. New York contracts are generally assignable unless they say otherwise, but many seller forms prohibit assignment without consent or limit it to affiliates, and an assignment does not by itself release the original purchaser. We address assignment rights when the contract is negotiated and handle the assignment, any seller release, and the transfer-tax filings when it happens.

Is consideration paid for a contract assignment subject to transfer tax?

Generally, yes. New York State's transfer tax defines consideration to include payment for a contract to purchase real property, and New York City has ruled that amounts paid under an assignment agreement are part of the taxable consideration. The cost should be modeled and allocated in writing.

Should I sign a letter of intent before the contract?

An LOI can be useful for agreeing on major business terms before both sides spend money on a full contract. It should say clearly which terms are non-binding and which, such as confidentiality or exclusivity, are binding. We review LOIs before signing so they do not create obligations the client did not intend.

What should due diligence cover for a New York City building?

Generally title and survey, leases and estoppels, the certificate of occupancy, open violations, zoning, environmental reports, building systems, and, for apartments, rent-regulation status. The scope depends on the property type and the business plan. The contract should give the buyer enough time and access to complete it.

When does my deposit become non-refundable?

It depends on the contract. In many commercial deals, the deposit becomes non-refundable when the diligence period expires unless the buyer terminates in writing before then. After that, the buyer typically can recover the deposit only for seller default or failure of a stated closing condition.

Should I buy the property itself or the entity that owns it?

Buying the entity can preserve existing contracts, permits, or financing, but the buyer also takes on the entity’s historical liabilities. An entity purchase calls for broader representations, indemnities, and often a non-imputation endorsement on the title policy. Tax and lender consequences should be reviewed before choosing.

What if the seller’s rent roll turns out to be wrong?

The contract should include representations about the rent roll and leases, require tenant estoppel certificates, and set out remedies if material discrepancies appear. Without those provisions, a buyer’s options after closing may be limited. That is why the leases themselves should be reviewed during diligence.

Do open building violations transfer to the buyer?

Generally, yes. Department of Buildings and HPD violations attach to the property rather than the owner. Contracts typically address whether the seller must cure them, pay outstanding penalties, or give the buyer a credit.

How are tenant security deposits handled when a building is sold?

The seller transfers the deposits, or gives the buyer a credit for them, at closing, and tenants are notified of the transfer. New York law places responsibility for the deposits on the new owner once they are turned over. The deposit schedule should be confirmed against the leases and estoppels.

As a seller, what should I prepare before putting a building on the market?

Typically current leases and amendments, a rent roll, operating statements, service contracts, certificates of occupancy, permits, violation history, and any environmental or engineering reports. Organizing these early can shorten diligence and reduce renegotiation. We also review existing loan documents for prepayment or transfer terms.

I live outside New York. What taxes are due when I sell New York property?

Nonresident individuals generally must pay estimated New York income tax on the gain at closing with Form IT-2663, in addition to State and, where applicable, City transfer taxes. Foreign sellers may also face federal FIRPTA withholding. Your accountant should confirm the amounts; we coordinate the filings at closing.

Do I need title insurance on a commercial purchase?

Title insurance is not legally required, but lenders require a loan policy, and most buyers purchase an owner’s policy. It protects against covered defects in title that existed at closing. We review the title report and negotiate endorsements suited to the property.

Does an off-market sale change the legal process?

The contract, diligence, title, and closing steps are generally the same. The main difference is that pricing and terms are negotiated without a competitive process, so diligence protections in the contract become more important. Broker commission arrangements should still be confirmed in writing.
Contact

Get in touch

Whether you are under contract, evaluating a building, or planning a development or raise, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content