Environmental due diligence and brownfields.

Environmental liability can attach to an owner who did nothing to cause the contamination. Diligence before closing is the main way to limit that exposure.

We represent buyers, sellers, developers, and lenders in environmental due diligence, brownfield redevelopment, and the allocation of environmental risk in New York real estate transactions.

Under the federal Superfund law, CERCLA, the current owner of contaminated property can be held liable for cleanup costs regardless of fault. A buyer can preserve defenses, including the bona fide prospective purchaser defense, by conducting all appropriate inquiries before acquiring the property and by meeting continuing obligations after closing. In practice, all appropriate inquiries means a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment that follows the EPA’s rule, which recognizes the ASTM E1527-21 standard, prepared by a qualified environmental professional within the time limits the rule sets.

New York adds its own layers. The Navigation Law imposes strict liability for petroleum discharges, and owners of property with leaking tanks can be responsible for cleanup. The State’s Brownfield Cleanup Program offers liability protection and, for qualifying sites, tax credits for remediation and redevelopment; sites must generally be admitted by December 31, 2032. In New York City, lots with an E-designation for hazardous materials, air quality, or noise need approval from the Mayor’s Office of Environmental Remediation before the Department of Buildings will issue certain permits or certificates of occupancy.

Diligence findings drive the contract. Depending on what a Phase I or Phase II shows, the parties may negotiate a price reduction, a cleanup obligation, an escrow, a seller indemnity, or pollution legal liability insurance. Lenders often require their own environmental review and an environmental indemnity from the borrower and its principals.

Our capabilities include:

  • Phase I and Phase II review and scoping
  • CERCLA all appropriate inquiries and purchaser defenses
  • Brownfield Cleanup Program applications and agreements
  • NYC E-designations and Office of Environmental Remediation approvals
  • Petroleum spills and Navigation Law claims
  • Environmental indemnities and contract provisions
  • Pollution legal liability insurance
  • Vapor intrusion and emerging contaminant issues

Environmental diligence at a glance

Phase I ESARecords review, site visit, interviews, and historical use research under ASTM E1527-21 to identify recognized environmental conditions
Phase II ESASampling of soil, groundwater, or soil vapor to confirm or rule out contamination
TimingThe Phase I must be completed within one year before acquisition, with key components updated within 180 days
User responsibilitiesThe buyer must provide known information, such as environmental liens and any special knowledge of the property, and consider any price reduction tied to contamination
Continuing obligationsAfter closing, the owner must take reasonable steps to stop releases, cooperate, and comply with land use restrictions

New York and New York City programs

  • Brownfield Cleanup Program

    A DEC program offering cleanup oversight, liability limitations, and tax credits for eligible sites; admission is generally available through December 31, 2032.

  • NYC E-designations

    Zoning map designations for hazardous materials, air quality, or noise that require Office of Environmental Remediation sign-off before certain building permits or certificates of occupancy.

  • NYC Voluntary Cleanup Program

    A City program, administered by the Office of Environmental Remediation, for lightly to moderately contaminated sites.

  • Navigation Law

    Strict liability for petroleum discharges, with a right for those who did not cause a discharge to seek cleanup costs from those who did.

  • Spill reporting

    Petroleum and hazardous substance spills must be reported promptly to DEC’s spill hotline.

Environmental diligence in a purchase

  1. Order the Phase I early

    Engage a qualified environmental professional and give the consultant access, records, and the seller’s questionnaire responses.

  2. Review the findings

    Identify recognized environmental conditions, historical uses, tanks, and any E-designation or regulatory listing.

  3. Decide on a Phase II

    Where the Phase I warrants it, negotiate access and indemnities for sampling, and plan for reporting obligations if contamination is found.

  4. Allocate the risk

    Negotiate price, cleanup obligations, escrows, indemnities, and insurance based on what the reports show.

  5. Plan after closing

    Meet continuing obligations, record any required restrictions, and coordinate with DEC or the Office of Environmental Remediation.

Key terms

CERCLA
The federal Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, or Superfund law.
Bona fide prospective purchaser (BFPP)
A buyer that conducts all appropriate inquiries and meets continuing obligations, and can avoid CERCLA liability as an owner.
Innocent landowner defense
A CERCLA defense for an owner that did not know and had no reason to know of contamination after all appropriate inquiries.
All appropriate inquiries (AAI)
The EPA standard, at 40 C.F.R. Part 312, for pre-acquisition environmental investigation.
ASTM E1527-21
The current ASTM standard practice for Phase I Environmental Site Assessments, recognized by the EPA as satisfying AAI.
Phase I ESA
A non-invasive environmental assessment based on records, a site visit, and interviews.
Phase II ESA
An investigation involving sampling of soil, groundwater, or soil vapor.
Recognized environmental condition (REC)
The presence or likely presence of hazardous substances or petroleum at a property due to a release or threat of release.
Environmental professional
A person meeting the AAI rule’s qualifications to conduct a Phase I.
Brownfield Cleanup Program (BCP)
New York State’s DEC program for voluntary cleanup and redevelopment of contaminated sites, with liability protections and tax credits.
Certificate of Completion
The DEC document issued when a BCP cleanup is complete, which triggers liability protection and tax credit eligibility.
E-designation
A New York City zoning designation for potential hazardous materials, air quality, or noise concerns on a lot.
Office of Environmental Remediation (OER)
The New York City office that administers E-designations and the City’s Voluntary Cleanup Program.
Navigation Law
The New York statute imposing strict liability for petroleum discharges.
Vapor intrusion
The migration of contaminant vapors from soil or groundwater into buildings.
Pollution legal liability insurance
Insurance covering cleanup costs and third-party claims arising from pre-existing or new pollution conditions.

Questions we hear most

Do I need a Phase I to buy commercial property?

It is not legally required, but it is the basis for the CERCLA purchaser defenses and is usually required by lenders. Skipping it can leave a buyer liable for contamination it did not cause.

How long is a Phase I good for?

Under the EPA’s all appropriate inquiries rule, a Phase I generally must be completed within one year before the acquisition, and certain components, such as the site visit and records searches, must be updated within 180 days.

What is an E-designation?

An E-designation is a New York City zoning map designation placed on a lot to flag potential hazardous materials, air quality, or noise concerns. Before certain permits or a certificate of occupancy can issue, the Office of Environmental Remediation must approve the required investigation or remediation.

Are Brownfield Cleanup Program tax credits still available?

Yes, for eligible sites. The program was extended in 2022, and sites must generally be admitted by December 31, 2032 to qualify.

Can a seller’s environmental indemnity replace diligence?

Not fully. An indemnity is only as good as the indemnitor’s finances and survival period, and it does not preserve CERCLA defenses. Diligence and indemnities work together.

Does New York’s Navigation Law make a buyer liable for an old oil tank?

It can. The Navigation Law imposes strict liability on dischargers, and courts have held owners responsible for leaks on their property. A buyer that did not cause the discharge may have claims against those who did.

What does pollution legal liability insurance cover?

Depending on the policy, cleanup costs for unknown pre-existing conditions, third-party bodily injury and property damage claims, and legal defense. Policy terms, exclusions, and known-conditions schedules vary widely.

What are BCP tax credits?

The program offers a site preparation credit and a tangible property credit for qualifying sites, calculated under the Tax Law and tied to the Certificate of Completion. Eligibility and amounts depend on the site, its location, and its use.

Does a lender’s Phase I protect the buyer?

Not necessarily. CERCLA defenses depend on the buyer’s own all appropriate inquiries, so the buyer should be a named user of the Phase I or obtain a reliance letter.

Are emerging contaminants like PFAS part of diligence?

Increasingly, yes. They are not always within a standard Phase I scope, so buyers of sites with relevant historical uses should consider asking the consultant to evaluate them.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content