Property Tax Appeals Property tax appeals and tax certiorari.

An overstated assessment costs an owner every year it goes unchallenged. Filing deadlines are fixed, and most are early in the year.

We represent owners challenging real property tax assessments in New York City before the Tax Commission and in Supreme Court, and in Long Island and Westchester before local boards and the courts.

In New York City, the Department of Finance mails the Notice of Property Value on or about January 15. An owner who disagrees files an application with the New York City Tax Commission: by March 1 for Class 2, 3, and 4 properties, and by March 15 for Class 1 homes. If the Tax Commission does not resolve the case, the owner may commence a tax certiorari proceeding under Real Property Tax Law Article 7 in Supreme Court, generally before October 25 of the tax year.

Income-producing property needs its numbers in order. Owners of income-producing property generally file the annual Real Property Income and Expense statement (RPIE) with the Department of Finance, and Tax Commission applications for those properties require an income and expense schedule. An accountant’s certification is required where the assessed value is $5 million or more.

Outside the city, the calendar is set by each assessing unit. In most towns, complaints are due on Grievance Day, typically the fourth Tuesday in May; in Nassau County, complaints go to the Assessment Review Commission, generally by March 1. Owners of one-to-three family homes may then use Small Claims Assessment Review, and other owners may bring an Article 7 proceeding.

Our capabilities include:

  • Assessment review and value analysis
  • Tax Commission applications and hearings
  • Income and expense schedules and RPIE coordination
  • Article 7 tax certiorari proceedings
  • Small Claims Assessment Review for homeowners
  • Exemption and abatement review

New York City calendar

Notice of Property ValueMailed on or about January 15
Tax Commission: Classes 2, 3, and 4File by March 1
Tax Commission: Class 1File by March 15
Revised notice of valueFile within 20 calendar days of the revised notice
Article 7 proceeding in Supreme CourtGenerally commenced before October 25
SCAR for qualifying 1–3 family homesGenerally filed by October 25

Long Island and Westchester

  • Nassau County

    Complaints are filed with the Assessment Review Commission, generally by March 1.

  • Suffolk County and most towns

    Complaints are filed with the local Board of Assessment Review by Grievance Day, in most communities the fourth Tuesday in May.

  • Westchester

    Cities and towns set their own grievance dates, so the calendar is municipality by municipality.

  • After the local board

    Small Claims Assessment Review or an Article 7 proceeding generally must be started within 30 days after the final assessment roll is filed or notice of it is given, whichever is later.

Key terms

Tax certiorari
A court proceeding under Real Property Tax Law Article 7 to review a property tax assessment.
Notice of Property Value
The Department of Finance’s annual notice of a property’s market and assessed values, mailed in January.
Tax Commission
The New York City agency that hears and decides applications to correct assessments.
Market value
The Department of Finance’s estimate of what the property is worth.
Assessed value
The value on which tax is computed, derived from market value under the rules for each tax class.
Transitional assessed value
For many Class 2 and 4 properties, an assessed value that phases in market value changes over five years.
Tax class
The category that sets assessment rules: Class 1 (most 1–3 family homes), Class 2 (other residential, including co-ops and condos), Class 3 (utility), Class 4 (commercial).
RPIE
The Real Property Income and Expense statement most owners of income-producing property must file each year.
Form TC201 and TC203
Tax Commission income and expense schedules; TC203 is used for cooperatives and condominiums.
Form TC309
The accountant’s certification required where the assessed value is $5 million or more.
Grievance Day
The day local assessment complaints are due outside New York City, in most communities the fourth Tuesday in May.
Assessment Review Commission
Nassau County’s body for assessment complaints.
SCAR
Small Claims Assessment Review, a simplified appeal for qualifying one-to-three family homes.
Equalization rate
Outside New York City, the state ratio used to compare an assessment to full market value.

Questions we hear most

When should I start an appeal in New York City?

As soon as the Notice of Property Value arrives in January. Tax Commission applications are due March 1 for Class 2, 3, and 4 properties and March 15 for Class 1.

Do I need an income and expense statement?

For income-producing property, generally yes. Tax Commission applications require one, and the Department of Finance separately requires most owners of income-producing property with an assessed value over $40,000 to file an annual RPIE.

Can a co-op or condo board appeal?

Yes. The board typically appeals the assessment for the whole building or for the condominium units, and any reduction benefits the shareholders or unit owners.

What if the Tax Commission does not reduce my assessment?

You may commence a tax certiorari proceeding in Supreme Court under Real Property Tax Law Article 7, generally before October 25 of the tax year.

What evidence supports a reduction?

For income-producing property, actual income and expenses and market capitalization rates; for homes, comparable sales and the property’s condition. Errors in the property description, such as square footage or unit count, also matter.

Does filing an appeal risk an increase?

A Tax Commission application asks for a reduction. The underlying Department of Finance values can change from year to year regardless of whether you appeal.

Do I have to file every year?

Each tax year is a separate assessment, so owners who want review must file each year. Many owners file annually as a matter of course.

What happens to a refund after a co-op wins?

The building receives the reduction or refund, and the board decides how to apply it under the governing documents, often crediting shareholders.

What are the penalties for not filing an RPIE?

The Department of Finance can impose fines, and failing to file for three consecutive years can bring a larger penalty tied to the assessed value. Late or missing RPIE filings can also complicate a Tax Commission appeal.

Is SCAR available in New York City?

Yes, for exclusively residential, owner-occupied one-, two-, and three-family homes, generally filed by October 25 after the Tax Commission process.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content