Real estate joint ventures.

A joint venture agreement is written when the partners agree on everything. It is read when they no longer do.

We represent operating partners, capital partners, and family investors in forming, negotiating, restructuring, and resolving disputes over real estate joint ventures.

Most real estate joint ventures pair an operating partner, who finds the deal and runs the property, with a capital partner, who supplies most of the equity. The venture is usually a limited liability company, and the operating agreement sets the economics and the control: how capital is contributed and called, how cash flows through the distribution waterfall, which decisions require both partners, and how either partner can leave. New York’s LLC Law gives members wide freedom to set those terms by contract, and courts generally enforce operating agreements as written.

The exit provisions matter most. Buy-sell provisions, forced-sale rights, removal rights, and transfer restrictions decide who controls the asset when the partners disagree about a refinancing, a capital need, or the timing of a sale. A buy-sell clause that looks balanced on paper can favor the partner with ready access to cash. Lender consent requirements, loan guaranties signed by the operating partner, and tax consequences should be tested against each exit route before the agreement is signed.

When a venture breaks down, the operating agreement is the first place to look and often the last. Claims commonly involve capital call defaults and dilution, removal of a managing member for cause, disputes over the promote, and deadlock. A New York court may dissolve an LLC under LLC Law § 702 only where it is not reasonably practicable to carry on the business in conformity with the articles or operating agreement, a demanding standard, so most JV disputes are resolved through the contractual remedies the partners negotiated.

Our capabilities include:

  • JV and LLC operating agreements for operating and capital partners
  • Capital contribution, capital call, and default provisions
  • Distribution waterfalls, preferred returns, and promotes
  • Major decision lists and budget approval rights
  • Buy-sell, forced-sale, and removal provisions
  • Loan guaranty allocation and reimbursement agreements
  • Transfer restrictions, rights of first offer, and tag-along and drag-along rights
  • Partner disputes, deadlock, and negotiated exits

Key terms in a JV operating agreement

Capital contributionsInitial equity split, often with the capital partner contributing most of the cash
Capital callsWhen additional capital may be called, by whom, and what happens if a partner does not fund
WaterfallThe order of distributions: return of capital, a preferred return, then splits that shift toward the operating partner
PromoteThe operating partner’s share of profits above its capital share, earned as return hurdles are met
Major decisionsActions requiring both partners’ approval, such as sales, refinancings, budgets, and major leases
RemovalThe capital partner’s right to remove the managing member, usually for defined cause
ExitBuy-sell, forced-sale, and transfer provisions that let a partner leave or end the venture

Common exit and deadlock mechanisms

  • Buy-sell (Texas shootout)

    One partner names a price for the whole property; the other must either buy at that price or sell its interest at that price.

  • Forced sale

    After a lockout period, a partner may require the property to be marketed and sold, often with the other partner holding a right of first offer.

  • Right of first offer or refusal

    A partner wishing to sell its interest or the property must first offer it to, or give a matching right to, the other partner.

  • Tag-along and drag-along

    A minority partner may join a sale by the majority, or the majority may require the minority to join a sale on the same terms.

  • Removal for cause

    The capital partner may remove the operating partner for defined events such as fraud, gross negligence, or material uncured default, often with a reduced or forfeited promote.

  • Escalation and mediation

    Deadlocks on major decisions are elevated to principals and then to mediation or arbitration before an exit right is triggered.

When a capital call is not funded

  1. Read the call provisions

    Confirm that the call was properly made: the purpose, the notice period, and whether the manager had authority to make it.

  2. Identify the remedies

    Agreements typically allow the funding partner to treat the shortfall as a member loan at a default rate, or as additional capital with dilution of the defaulting partner.

  3. Check the lender documents

    Member loans and changes in ownership percentages may require lender consent or be limited by the loan agreement.

  4. Consider removal and buy-sell consequences

    A funding default may be an event of cause, suspend voting rights, or block the defaulting partner from triggering a buy-sell.

  5. Document the outcome

    Record amended capital accounts and percentages in writing, with a clear reservation of rights where the call is disputed.

Key terms

Joint venture
A business arrangement in which two or more parties combine capital and operating know-how to own or develop property, usually through an LLC.
Operating partner
The partner that sources the deal and manages the property, often called the sponsor or managing member.
Capital partner
The partner that contributes most of the equity, often an institution, family office, or fund.
Operating agreement
The contract that governs an LLC, including management, economics, and transfers.
Capital call
A request that members contribute additional capital under the operating agreement.
Dilution
A reduction in a member’s percentage interest, often a remedy when that member fails to fund a capital call.
Member loan
An advance by one member to cover another’s unfunded share, typically repaid with interest before other distributions.
Distribution waterfall
The order in which cash is distributed among members.
Preferred return
A priority return on contributed capital paid before the operating partner shares in profits.
Promote
The operating partner’s disproportionate share of profits once return hurdles are met.
Internal rate of return (IRR)
An annualized return measure used to set waterfall hurdles.
Major decision
An action that requires the approval of both partners or a specified majority.
Buy-sell provision
A clause allowing one partner to set a price at which the other must buy or sell; also called a Texas shootout.
Carve-out guaranty
A guaranty of a non-recourse loan that makes the guarantor liable for losses or the full debt upon specified bad acts.
Deadlock
A stalemate between partners with equal or blocking votes on a decision the venture needs to make.
Judicial dissolution
A court order dissolving an LLC under LLC Law § 702, available only when it is not reasonably practicable to carry on the business under the operating agreement.

Questions we hear most

What is a promote?

A promote, or carried interest, is the share of profits the operating partner receives above its share of the capital contributed. It is usually earned in tiers as the investors reach agreed return hurdles, such as an internal rate of return or a multiple of invested capital.

How does a Texas shootout work?

One partner names a value for the property. The other partner must then choose to buy the first partner’s interest at that value or sell its own interest at that value, so the partner naming the price has a reason to name a fair one.

Can a capital partner remove the managing member?

Only as the operating agreement allows. Most agreements permit removal for defined cause, such as fraud, willful misconduct, or a material uncured default, and set out what happens to the removed partner’s promote.

Who signs the loan guaranties in a joint venture?

Lenders usually require a creditworthy principal of the operating partner to sign the carve-out and environmental guaranties. The partners should agree in a separate contribution or reimbursement agreement how liability under those guaranties is shared.

Should a joint venture use a New York or Delaware LLC?

Either can work. Many institutional ventures use Delaware LLCs because their LLC law and case law are familiar to investors, while the property-owning entity is often formed or qualified in New York. Each New York or foreign LLC doing business here has its own filing and publication obligations.

Can an operating agreement limit fiduciary duties?

To a degree. New York’s LLC Law permits operating agreements to limit a manager’s or member’s liability, but not for conduct such as bad faith, intentional misconduct, knowing violations of law, or improper personal benefit. Delaware gives parties more room, so the governing law matters.

What happens to the promote if the operating partner is removed?

That depends on the agreement. Many agreements reduce or forfeit an unearned promote on removal for cause, and some convert the removed partner’s interest into a passive interest. These terms are negotiated heavily and should be clear.

Can a partner sell its interest to a third party?

Usually only with consent or after offering it to the other partner first. Transfer restrictions, lender consent requirements, and the transfer tax on transfers of controlling interests in entities that own real property all have to be considered.

How are JV disputes usually resolved?

Most are resolved through the agreement’s own mechanisms: removal, buy-sell, forced sale, or a negotiated buyout. Litigation or arbitration typically focuses on whether those mechanisms were properly triggered and on accounting and fiduciary claims.

What should a capital partner check before investing?

The sponsor’s track record and litigation history, the loan documents and guaranties, the budget and business plan, and how the agreement handles cost overruns, capital calls, and removal. The economics only work if the control provisions are enforceable.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content