Broker Representation

We represent real estate brokers, salespersons, and brokerages in New York — the agreements that create the right to a commission, the disputes when it isn't paid, the compliance rules that govern how brokers work, and Department of State licensing matters.

Whether a broker gets paid usually turns on two things: the written agreement and the license. Under Real Property Law § 442-d, no one may sue to recover brokerage compensation without alleging and proving a valid broker or salesperson license on the date the claim arose. And the agreement — what event earns the fee, who owes it, and what happens if the deal doesn't close — decides most disputes before they start.

The rules on sharing compensation are strict. A broker may share a commission only with its own associated licensees, other licensed brokers, or brokers regularly in the business outside New York (RPL § 442); salespersons may be paid only through their sponsoring broker (§ 442-a); and after-the-fact referral fees are prohibited (§ 442-l).

Rental brokerage changed in 2025. New York City's FARE Act (Local Law 119 of 2024), in effect since June 11, 2025, bars a landlord's broker from charging the tenant, and prohibits requiring a tenant to hire a broker to rent an apartment. It is enforced by the City and through a private right of action.

Our capabilities include:

  • Exclusive listing & buyer/tenant agency agreements
  • Commission agreements & fee letters
  • Commission collection & litigation
  • Co-brokerage & referral arrangements
  • Agency disclosure (RPL § 443) compliance
  • FARE Act rental-fee compliance
  • Department of State complaints & hearings

Key considerations in New York

  • No license, no lawsuit

    RPL § 442-d bars an action for brokerage compensation unless the claimant alleges and proves it was licensed when the cause of action arose.

  • Penalties track the commission

    Under RPL § 442-e, violations of the brokerage article are misdemeanors, and an aggrieved person may recover a penalty of one to four times the compensation received.

  • Agency disclosure is mandatory

    For residential sales and rentals of one-to-four family homes, condos, and co-ops, RPL § 443 requires the statutory agency disclosure form at specific points, with signed acknowledgments kept for three years.

  • Brokers can record their claim

    Under RPL § 294-b, a licensed broker who produced a ready, willing, and able buyer may record an affidavit of entitlement to commission. It is not a lien and is discharged one year after filing; for one-to-four family homes, condo units, and co-op apartments, the statute provides for the disputed commission to be deposited with the recording officer at closing.

What we handle

For individual agents, teams, and brokerages.

Agreements

Getting the right to be paid in writing.

  • Exclusive right-to-sell & exclusive agency
  • Buyer & tenant representation agreements
  • Commission letters for commercial deals
  • Co-brokerage & split agreements
  • Referral agreements
  • Independent-contractor & team agreements

Commission Disputes

Collecting what was earned.

  • Demand letters & negotiation
  • Commission litigation
  • Procuring-cause disputes
  • Disputes between brokerages
  • Affidavits of entitlement (RPL § 294-b)
  • Defense of commission claims

Compliance & Licensing

Staying out of trouble with regulators.

  • Department of State complaints & hearings
  • Agency disclosure procedures
  • FARE Act listing & fee practices
  • Fair housing & standardized operating procedures
  • Advertising review
  • Commission-sharing compliance

How we work

  1. Scoping Call

    We learn the deal, the timeline, and your role in the capital stack — then give you a clear scope and fee quote before work begins.

  2. Structure

    Entity, ownership, tax, and financing structure set before signatures, so the paperwork follows the business plan rather than the other way around.

  3. Documents

    We draft or negotiate the contract, assignment, operating agreement, or offering documents — and read the other side's drafts line by line.

  4. Diligence & Filings

    Title, zoning, environmental, leases, and the regulatory filings the transaction requires — tracked against your hard dates.

  5. Close & After

    We run the closing, record the documents, and stay on for post-closing items, investor reporting questions, and the next deal.

Key terms

Real estate broker license
Under Real Property Law § 440-a, a person or entity must be licensed by the Department of State to negotiate real estate transactions for others for a fee.
RPL § 442-d
The statute barring a lawsuit to collect brokerage compensation unless the claimant shows it was a licensed broker or salesperson when the claim arose.
Commission-splitting rule (RPL § 442)
A broker may generally share a commission only with its own licensed salespersons, other licensed brokers, or brokers licensed in another state, and not with unlicensed persons for work requiring a license.
Salesperson compensation (RPL § 442-a)
A licensed salesperson may be paid only by the broker who sponsors their license, not directly by a buyer or seller.
Procuring cause
The broker whose efforts directly brought about the transaction. Absent a contract term saying otherwise, New York generally requires a broker to be the procuring cause to earn a commission.
Ready, willing, and able
The traditional standard for earning a commission: producing a buyer willing to purchase on the seller’s terms. Many listing agreements instead condition payment on closing.
Co-brokerage
An arrangement in which a listing broker shares a commission with a broker representing the other side, usually under a written co-brokerage agreement.
Exclusive right to sell
A listing agreement under which the broker earns a commission if the property sells during the term, even if the owner finds the buyer.
Exclusive agency
A listing agreement under which the broker is the only agent, but the owner may sell directly to a buyer it finds without owing a commission.
Open listing
A non-exclusive arrangement in which any broker who procures a buyer earns a commission, and the owner may sell directly.
Tail provision
A listing-agreement clause entitling the broker to a commission if, within a set period after the agreement ends, the owner sells to a buyer the broker introduced.
Dual agency and designated sales agents (RPL § 443)
In residential transactions, a brokerage may represent both buyer and seller only with advance informed consent, and may appoint separate designated sales agents to advise each side.
After-the-fact referral fee (RPL § 442-l)
Brokers may not demand or accept a referral fee for a referral made after a signed listing, accepted offer, or signed buyer agency agreement, absent reasonable cause.
FARE Act
A New York City law in effect since June 11, 2025 that generally requires a landlord who hires a rental broker to pay that broker’s fee, rather than shifting it to the tenant.
Department of State, Division of Licensing Services
The agency that licenses brokers and salespersons, investigates complaints, and can fine, suspend, or revoke licenses.

Frequently asked questions

Can a broker sue for a commission without a license?

No. Real Property Law § 442-d requires a claimant to allege and prove that it held a New York broker or salesperson license on the date the cause of action arose. Unlicensed persons cannot recover brokerage compensation in New York courts.

Who can a broker split a commission with?

Under RPL § 442, a broker may share compensation with its own associated licensees, other licensed brokers, brokers regularly engaged in the business outside New York, and certain entities owned entirely by the broker's associated licensees — not with unlicensed people. Salespersons may be paid only by their sponsoring broker.

Can a landlord's broker charge a tenant a fee in New York City?

Not since June 11, 2025. The FARE Act (Local Law 119 of 2024) prohibits a landlord's agent, including a listing agent, from charging the tenant, and bars conditioning a rental on the tenant hiring a broker. A tenant may still choose to hire and pay its own broker.

When does a broker earn a commission?

That depends first on the written agreement. Absent different terms, New York courts generally look to whether the broker produced a buyer ready, willing, and able to purchase on the seller's terms, and whether the broker was the procuring cause. Clear agreements avoid most of these disputes.

What happens if the Department of State opens a complaint against me?

The Department of State may investigate and, after notice and a hearing, revoke or suspend a license or impose fines. We respond to complaints, represent licensees at hearings, and work to resolve matters before they escalate.

Do you represent buyers and sellers in disputes with brokers?

Yes. We review brokerage agreements before they are signed and represent principals when a broker claims a commission they dispute.

Does a commission agreement have to be in writing?

New York’s statute of frauds requires written agreements for many finder and business-opportunity fees, but General Obligations Law § 5-701 excepts licensed real estate brokers. An oral commission agreement with a licensed broker may therefore be enforceable. A written agreement is still the best evidence of the rate, the trigger for payment, and the term.

What is a tail provision, and will it apply after my listing ends?

A tail clause entitles the broker to a commission if, within a set period after the listing expires, the owner sells to a buyer the broker introduced. Its scope often depends on whether the broker must provide a list of introduced buyers. Owners should review the tail before signing a new listing with another broker.

What if two brokers claim the same commission?

Disputes often turn on which broker was the procuring cause, the terms of each agreement, and co-brokerage arrangements. Sellers may face exposure to both claims if they signed conflicting agreements. These disputes are best addressed before closing, when funds can be escrowed by agreement.

Can I pay a referral fee to someone who is not licensed?

Generally no, if the payment is for work that requires a license. Real Property Law § 442 restricts commission-sharing to licensed salespersons, licensed brokers, and out-of-state brokers. A principal to the transaction may receive a rebate in some circumstances, but not as compensation for brokering.

Do the agency disclosure rules apply to commercial transactions?

No. Real Property Law § 443 applies only to residential transactions involving one-to-four family dwellings and condominium or cooperative apartments. Commercial brokers still owe fiduciary duties to their clients under general agency law.

Can a broker represent both the buyer and the seller?

In residential deals, a brokerage can act as a dual agent only with the advance informed written consent of both parties, and it may assign designated sales agents to each side. In commercial deals, dual representation should still be disclosed and agreed to in writing. Each side gives up some advocacy in a dual-agency arrangement.

Can a salesperson sue a buyer or seller directly for a commission?

Generally no. Under Real Property Law § 442-a, a salesperson may be paid only by their sponsoring broker, so the broker is the proper party to pursue the commission. A salesperson’s claim for their share is usually against the broker under their agreement.

Do I need a license to sell my own property or find deals for my own fund?

A license is generally not required to sell your own property or to act for yourself as a principal, because a broker is someone acting for another for a fee. Arranging transactions for others for compensation is different. Sponsors who pay or receive fees for finding deals should review the licensing rules.

What should a commercial listing agreement include?

Generally the commission rate and when it is earned, the term and any tail, whether the listing is exclusive, co-brokerage terms, exclusions for buyers the owner already knows, and termination rights. Clear terms reduce the chance of later disputes. We negotiate listing agreements for owners and brokers.

Can a broker lose a commission for misconduct?

A broker who breaches fiduciary duties to its principal, such as by undisclosed self-dealing, may face forfeiture of compensation and Department of State discipline. Each situation depends on its facts. Brokers facing these allegations should get advice before responding.
Contact

Get in touch

Whether you are under contract, evaluating a building, or planning a development or raise, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content