Holding Real Estate in LLCs and Entities Holding real estate in LLCs and other entities.

The choice of ownership vehicle affects liability, taxes, financing, and what has to be disclosed. It is easiest to get right before the deed is recorded.

We represent investors, families, and operators in forming and documenting entities to own New York real estate, and in transferring interests in them.

Most investment property in New York is held in a single-asset limited liability company, one LLC for each property, so that liabilities from one building do not reach the others. The operating agreement does the real work: who manages, how capital is called, how cash is distributed, how decisions are made, and what happens on death, divorce, deadlock, or a sale. Co-owners who hold title directly as tenants in common should have a written tenancy in common agreement covering the same questions, including limits on partition.

Formation has filing obligations. Under LLC Law § 206, a New York LLC must publish notice of its formation in two newspapers for six consecutive weeks and file a certificate of publication within 120 days; an LLC that does not comply has its authority to carry on business suspended until it does. When an LLC buys or sells a building with one to four dwelling units, Tax Law § 1409(a) requires the transfer tax return to list the names and addresses of the LLC’s members, managers, and other authorized persons, tracing through entity members to natural persons.

Federal and state transparency rules narrowed in 2025 and 2026. FinCEN’s final rule of August 11, 2026 confirmed that companies formed in the United States and U.S. persons are exempt from Corporate Transparency Act reporting. New York’s LLC Transparency Act took effect January 1, 2026, and because the Governor vetoed amendments to extend it to domestic LLCs, it currently reaches only LLCs formed outside the United States that are authorized to do business in New York; those formed before 2026 must report by December 31, 2026.

Our capabilities include:

  • Single-asset LLC formation and publication
  • Operating agreements and joint venture agreements
  • Tenancy in common agreements
  • Transfers of entity interests and transfer tax analysis
  • Lender single-purpose entity requirements
  • LLC disclosure for one-to-four family transfers
  • Transparency Act and beneficial ownership reporting analysis
  • Restructuring title among family members and partners

Choosing how to hold title

Individual or joint ownershipSimplest; no entity liability shield; co-op apartments are typically held this way or in trust
Tenancy in commonEach co-owner holds an undivided share; a TIC agreement governs management, sale, and partition
Single-asset LLCThe usual vehicle for investment property; liability is generally confined to the LLC’s assets
Revocable trustUsed for estate planning and probate avoidance; provides no liability shield during the grantor’s life
Multi-tier structuresInvestor, managing member, and property-level entities in syndications and joint ventures

Transfer tax on entity interests

  • New York State

    Tax Law Article 31 taxes the transfer or acquisition of a controlling interest — 50% or more — in an entity that owns New York real property, in proportion to the interest transferred.

  • New York City

    The Real Property Transfer Tax similarly reaches transfers of a controlling interest in entities owning City property.

  • Aggregation

    Transfers by or to related parties, or in a series of related transactions, can be added together to reach the 50% threshold.

  • Mere change of identity

    A conveyance that changes only the form of ownership, without a change in beneficial ownership, is generally exempt from the State tax, as when an owner deeds property to an LLC the owner wholly owns.

Key terms

Single-asset entity
An entity formed to own one property, so that the property’s liabilities stay with it.
Single-purpose entity (SPE)
A borrower that a lender requires to own only the mortgaged property and to follow separateness covenants.
Operating agreement
The contract among an LLC’s members governing management, capital, distributions, transfers, and exits.
Managing member
The member who runs the LLC’s affairs, often the sponsor in a joint venture.
Capital call
A demand on members to contribute additional funds, with consequences for members who do not.
Tenancy in common
Co-ownership in which each owner holds an undivided share that can be sold or inherited separately.
Partition
A court proceeding to divide or sell co-owned property; co-owners may agree to limit the right.
LLC Law § 206
The publication requirement for newly formed New York LLCs.
Controlling interest
For transfer tax purposes, 50% or more of the ownership of an entity that owns real property.
Mere change of identity
A conveyance that changes only the form of ownership without changing beneficial ownership, generally exempt from the State transfer tax.
Tax Law § 1409(a)
The rule requiring disclosure of an LLC’s members, managers, and authorized persons on transfers of one-to-four family property.
Corporate Transparency Act
The federal beneficial ownership reporting law; under FinCEN’s 2026 final rule, domestic companies and U.S. persons are exempt.
LLC Transparency Act
New York’s beneficial ownership law, effective January 1, 2026, currently applying to LLCs formed outside the United States and authorized to do business in New York.
Bad-boy guaranty
A guaranty that makes a sponsor personally liable on a non-recourse loan if specified acts, such as fraud or a voluntary bankruptcy, occur.

Questions we hear most

Will an LLC protect me from personal liability?

Generally, an LLC’s members are not personally liable for its debts, but the protection depends on keeping the LLC separate: its own bank account, its own contracts, and adequate insurance. Personal guaranties given to lenders and tenants are not affected by the LLC.

Can I deed my house to an LLC?

You can, but consider the mortgage, which may be accelerated on transfer; the owner’s title policy, which may not continue to the LLC; property tax exemptions such as STAR, which an LLC generally cannot claim; and the loss of personal residence tax benefits.

Do I have to publish my LLC’s formation?

Yes. LLC Law § 206 requires publication in two newspapers for six weeks and filing of a certificate of publication within 120 days. Failure suspends the LLC’s authority to carry on business, which can complicate litigation and closings until cured.

Does a New York LLC have to report its owners?

As of November 4, 2026, a domestic LLC does not file beneficial ownership reports with FinCEN or with the New York Department of State. LLCs formed outside the United States and authorized to do business in New York generally do, and disclosure is still required on transfer tax returns for one-to-four family transfers.

Should each property be in its own LLC?

For investment property, usually. Separate LLCs keep a claim at one building from reaching the others, and lenders often require it. The cost is more filings, tax returns, and accounts.

Does transferring an interest in my LLC trigger transfer tax?

It can. A transfer or acquisition of a controlling interest, 50% or more, in an entity that owns New York property is taxable under the State transfer tax and the City’s Real Property Transfer Tax, and smaller transfers can be aggregated.

What should a tenancy in common agreement cover?

Management and expenses, how decisions are made, rights of first refusal, buyout mechanics, what happens on death or default, and any agreed limit on partition. Without one, a co-owner’s main remedy in a dispute is often a partition action.

What do lenders require of a borrowing entity?

Typically an SPE that owns only the mortgaged property, separateness covenants, limits on transfers of interests and changes of control, and a sponsor guaranty of specified recourse events.

Is the LLC Transparency Act information public?

As enacted, the Department of State keeps beneficial ownership information confidential, with limited disclosure to government agencies. The current filing obligation applies only to LLCs formed outside the United States.

Can I hold a co-op apartment in an LLC?

Usually not without the board’s consent, and many co-ops do not permit entity ownership. Trust ownership is more commonly accepted, subject to the board’s requirements.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content