Real Estate Syndications

Madison Law Firm PLLC structures real estate syndications for sponsors buying and building in New York City — from a first deal with friends-and-family investors to a repeat program — and handles the federal and New York filings that come with raising money.

When a sponsor pools money from passive investors to buy or build real estate, the investors' interests are generally securities. That brings in federal securities law — usually an exemption under Regulation D — and, in New York, the Martin Act, which gives the Attorney General broad authority over real estate securities offered in or from the State.

New York regulates real estate syndications specifically. General Business Law § 352-e requires an offering statement to be filed with the Attorney General's Real Estate Finance Bureau unless an exemption applies, and issuers of real estate securities relying on Rule 506 file a notice on New York's Form 99 with that Bureau rather than the general electronic notice used for other offerings.

The documents are also the business deal. The operating agreement decides the preferred return, the promote, capital calls, fees, decision rights, removal of the manager, and what investors receive at a refinance or sale. Investors read them closely — and so do lenders.

Our capabilities include:

  • Deal & entity structure — GP / LP and co-GP
  • Private placement memoranda (PPM)
  • Operating agreements, waterfalls & promotes
  • Subscription agreements & investor questionnaires
  • Regulation D Rule 506(b) and 506(c)
  • SEC Form D & New York Form 99 filings
  • Joint ventures with institutional capital

Key considerations in New York

  • 506(b) or 506(c)

    Rule 506(b) prohibits general solicitation but allows up to 35 non-accredited, sophisticated investors. Rule 506(c) permits public advertising, but every purchaser must be accredited and the sponsor must take reasonable steps to verify it.

  • Form D within 15 days

    Federal Form D is filed with the SEC within 15 days after the first sale. New York's real-estate notice filing is handled with the Attorney General's Real Estate Finance Bureau.

  • Proceeds are held in trust

    New York law requires syndication proceeds to be held in trust until actually used for the purposes of the offering — a rule that should be reflected in the escrow and closing mechanics.

  • Condo rights change the filing

    If investors in a development syndication receive rights to buy condominium units, the Attorney General's position is that a condominium offering plan must be filed — a no-action letter will not substitute.

What we handle

We represent sponsors, and on request we review offerings for investors considering a commitment.

Structure

Designing the vehicle before the first investor call.

  • Single-asset vs. multi-asset vehicles
  • GP / LP, co-GP & JV structures
  • Preferred return & promote waterfalls
  • Fees: acquisition, asset management, disposition
  • Capital calls & dilution
  • Key-person & removal provisions

Offering Documents

Disclosure that fits the deal and the investor base.

  • Private placement memorandum
  • Operating / LP agreement
  • Subscription agreement
  • Accredited-investor questionnaires & verification
  • Risk factors for NYC rent-regulated assets
  • Investor updates & amendments

Filings & Compliance

Federal and New York requirements on the right timeline.

  • SEC Form D
  • New York Form 99 (Real Estate Finance Bureau)
  • GBL § 352-e exemption analysis
  • Blue-sky notices in investors' states
  • Bad-actor (Rule 506(d)) diligence
  • Finder & placement-agent compensation review

How we work

  1. Scoping Call

    We learn the deal, the timeline, and your role in the capital stack — then give you a clear scope and fee quote before work begins.

  2. Structure

    Entity, ownership, tax, and financing structure set before signatures, so the paperwork follows the business plan rather than the other way around.

  3. Documents

    We draft or negotiate the contract, assignment, operating agreement, or offering documents — and read the other side's drafts line by line.

  4. Diligence & Filings

    Title, zoning, environmental, leases, and the regulatory filings the transaction requires — tracked against your hard dates.

  5. Close & After

    We run the closing, record the documents, and stay on for post-closing items, investor reporting questions, and the next deal.

Key terms

Sponsor / general partner (GP)
The party that finds, structures, and manages the investment, usually acting as managing member of the investment entity and receiving fees and a promote.
Limited partner (LP) / passive investor
An investor who contributes capital but does not control day-to-day decisions. Their rights are set by the operating or partnership agreement.
Operating agreement
The governing contract of an LLC investment vehicle. It sets capital contributions, distributions, voting rights, transfer limits, and sponsor removal provisions.
Preferred return
A priority return, often stated as an annual percentage on contributed capital, that investors receive before the sponsor participates in profits. It is a distribution priority, not a guaranteed payment.
Waterfall
The order in which cash is distributed: commonly return of capital, then preferred return, then a split of remaining profits between investors and the sponsor, sometimes in tiers.
Promote (carried interest)
The sponsor’s share of profits above its proportional capital share, earned once investors reach stated return hurdles.
GP catch-up
A waterfall tier that sends a larger share of distributions to the sponsor after the preferred return is paid, until the sponsor reaches its target profit share.
Accredited investor
An investor meeting SEC tests in Rule 501(a), including for individuals net worth over $1 million excluding a primary residence, or income over $200,000 ($300,000 with a spouse or partner) in each of the last two years, or holding certain professional licenses.
Rule 506(b)
A Regulation D exemption that prohibits general solicitation but permits up to 35 non-accredited investors who are financially sophisticated, with added disclosure requirements for them.
Rule 506(c)
A Regulation D exemption that permits general solicitation if every purchaser is accredited and the issuer takes reasonable steps to verify their status.
Form D
The notice filed with the SEC within 15 days after the first sale in a Regulation D offering. It is a notice, not a registration.
Form 99
New York’s notification filing with the Attorney General for issuers relying on Rule 506, among other federal exemptions.
Martin Act
New York’s securities law, General Business Law Article 23-A. It contains offering-filing requirements for real estate securities in § 352-e and broad antifraud powers for the Attorney General.
Private placement memorandum (PPM)
The disclosure document describing the property, business plan, risks, fees, and conflicts of interest. It supports compliance with antifraud rules.
Subscription agreement
The contract in which an investor commits capital, makes representations about accreditation and suitability, and joins the operating agreement.
Capital call
A sponsor’s demand for additional contributions under the operating agreement. The agreement sets what happens if an investor does not fund, such as dilution or loss of rights.
Bad actor disqualification
Under Rule 506(d), certain disciplinary history or convictions of the issuer, its managers, or certain promoters can bar reliance on Rule 506.
Key person provision
A clause giving investors rights, such as removal or consent rights, if named principals of the sponsor stop managing the investment.

Frequently asked questions

Is a real estate syndication a securities offering?

Generally, yes. When passive investors put money into a venture managed by a sponsor, their interests are usually securities. Most private real estate syndications rely on an exemption under Regulation D, typically Rule 506(b) or 506(c).

What filings does New York require for a real estate syndication?

New York regulates real estate securities under the Martin Act. General Business Law § 352-e requires an offering statement filed with the Attorney General unless an exemption applies, and issuers of real estate securities relying on Rule 506 file a Form 99 notice with the Attorney General's Real Estate Finance Bureau. Which path applies depends on the offering.

What is the difference between Rule 506(b) and 506(c)?

Rule 506(b) does not allow general solicitation or advertising but permits up to 35 non-accredited investors who are financially sophisticated. Rule 506(c) allows advertising, including online, but every investor must be accredited and the sponsor must take reasonable steps to verify that status.

Do I need a private placement memorandum?

A PPM is not always legally required — for example, in a 506(b) offering sold only to accredited investors — but it is the sponsor's best protection against claims that investors were not told about a risk. We recommend one in most syndications.

What is a waterfall and a promote?

The waterfall is the order in which cash flow and sale proceeds are paid out — typically returning investor capital and a preferred return first. The promote is the sponsor's share of profits above those hurdles. Both are set in the operating agreement and should match what the offering materials describe.

Can I pay a finder for bringing in investors?

Be careful. Paying transaction-based compensation to someone who is not a registered broker-dealer can create problems for the offering. We review any finder or placement arrangement before it is signed.

Who counts as an accredited investor?

For individuals, the tests generally include net worth over $1 million excluding a primary residence, or income over $200,000 individually or $300,000 jointly in each of the past two years with a reasonable expectation of the same this year. Holders of certain securities licenses also qualify. Entities have separate tests.

Can I advertise my deal online or on social media?

Only if the offering relies on Rule 506(c), all purchasers are accredited, and you take reasonable steps to verify that. Under Rule 506(b), general solicitation is prohibited, and posting about a live offering can jeopardize the exemption. The decision should be made before any marketing starts.

Can friends and family who are not accredited invest?

Under Rule 506(b), up to 35 non-accredited investors can participate if each is financially sophisticated, alone or with a representative. Non-accredited investors must receive specified disclosure, including financial statement information. Many sponsors limit offerings to accredited investors for that reason.

What happens if an investor does not fund a capital call?

That depends on the operating agreement. Common remedies include dilution of the defaulting investor’s interest, loans from other members at a premium return, or loss of voting rights. These provisions should be clear before the first dollar is raised.

Does the Martin Act still apply if my offering is exempt from SEC registration?

Yes. A federal exemption does not displace New York’s notice filings or the Attorney General’s antifraud authority under the Martin Act. Offerings with New York investors should account for both federal and New York requirements.

What fees can a sponsor charge investors?

Common fees include acquisition, asset management, construction management, financing, and disposition fees, in addition to the promote. Fees must be disclosed accurately in the offering documents and set out in the operating agreement. Investors and their counsel commonly negotiate them.

How much control do investors have over the investment?

Passive investors typically have limited voting rights over major decisions such as a sale, refinancing, admission of new members, or amendments to the agreement. The specific rights depend on the operating agreement. Broad investor control can affect the securities and tax analysis, so it should be designed deliberately.

Can investors remove the sponsor?

Only if the operating agreement allows it, usually for cause such as fraud, gross negligence, or a material uncured breach, and sometimes after a key person event. Removal provisions typically address what happens to the sponsor’s promote. These terms are frequently negotiated by larger investors.

How are investors taxed in a syndication?

Most syndications use an LLC taxed as a partnership, so income, losses, and depreciation pass through to investors on Schedule K-1. Each investor reports their share on their own return. Investors should consult their own tax advisors about their situation.

Can investors sell their interests before the property is sold?

Interests in a private offering are restricted securities and generally cannot be freely resold. The operating agreement also usually requires sponsor consent for transfers. Liquidity typically comes from a sale or refinancing of the property.

What is the bad actor rule, and does it affect my offering?

Rule 506(d) bars reliance on Rule 506 if the issuer or covered persons, such as managers, large owners, or paid solicitors, have certain securities-related convictions, orders, or sanctions. Sponsors should run bad actor diligence on everyone covered before launching. Some events before September 23, 2013 require disclosure rather than disqualification.
Contact

Get in touch

Whether you are under contract, evaluating a building, or planning a development or raise, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content