Staten Island Commercial Real Estate

Madison Law Firm PLLC represents investors, developers, and owners buying, selling, financing, and building on Staten Island — mixed-use and retail property, small multifamily, and development sites from the North Shore to the South Shore.

At a glance

Deeds and mortgages recordedRichmond County Clerk, 130 Stuyvesant Place — not a City Register office, unlike the other four boroughs.
City transfer tax (RPTT)1–3 family homes, condo and co-op units: 1% up to $500,000, 1.425% above. All other property: 1.425% up to $500,000, 2.625% above.
State transfer tax0.4%, plus an additional 0.25% in New York City on residential sales of $3 million or more and other sales of $2 million or more.
Mortgage recording tax2.05% under $500,000; 2.175% for 1–3 family homes and condo units at $500,000+; 2.8% on all other mortgages of $500,000+.
Assessment appealsNYC Tax Commission: applications due March 1 for tax classes 2, 3 and 4, and March 15 for class 1. The deadlines cannot be extended.
Landlord-tenant courtCivil Court of the City of New York, Richmond County, 927 Castleton Avenue.
ZoningNYC Zoning Resolution, with the whole borough a Lower Density Growth Management Area since 2004.
Rent lawsRent stabilization covers many older buildings of six or more units; Good Cause Eviction covers many unregulated units since April 20, 2024.

Local offices

Deeds and mortgages recorded at
Richmond County Clerk
130 Stuyvesant Place, Staten Island, NY 10301 · Website

Court
Civil Court of the City of New York, Richmond County (Landlord-Tenant)
927 Castleton Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10310 · Website

Court
Supreme Court, Richmond County
26 Central Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10301 · Website

Staten Island is the most suburban of the five boroughs, and its zoning reflects it. Since 2004 the whole borough has been a Lower Density Growth Management Area, which requires more parking, larger yards, and more open space for new development in lower-density districts than the same zoning would require elsewhere in the city.

Large parts of the borough are also mapped with special districts — the Special Natural Area District, the Special South Richmond Development District, and the Special Hillsides Preservation District — that protect steep slopes, wetlands, and trees and can require City Planning review before a site is developed. On the North Shore, the 2019 Bay Street Corridor rezoning opened areas near the St. George ferry terminal to mixed-use residential development.

On Staten Island, the site plan drives the price. The yards, parking, natural features, and special-district approvals a parcel requires decide how much can be built, so they belong in diligence before the deposit goes hard.

Our capabilities include:

  • Acquisitions & dispositions
  • Contracts of sale & due diligence
  • Development sites & special-district review
  • Retail and mixed-use leasing
  • Financing & 1031 exchanges
  • Syndications & joint ventures

Key considerations in New York

  • Lower density growth management Area

    Adopted in 2004 for the entire borough. New development in lower-density residential districts generally needs more parking, larger yards, and more open space than the underlying zoning would otherwise require.

  • Special districts

    The Special Natural Area, South Richmond Development, and Hillsides Preservation districts regulate building on sites with steep slopes, rock outcrops, wetlands, and mature trees, and can require City Planning authorization.

  • New York City transfer taxes

    Staten Island is part of New York City, so city and state transfer taxes and the city mortgage recording tax apply, including the higher rates on larger transactions.

  • Bay street corridor

    The 2019 Bay Street Corridor rezoning permits mixed-use residential development near the St. George ferry terminal, through Tompkinsville and Stapleton.

What we handle

Our Staten Island work centers on the transactions clients bring us most.

Acquisitions

Staten Island mixed-use, retail, and small multifamily property.

  • Contracts of sale & riders
  • Title, zoning & certificate-of-occupancy review
  • Entity & closing structure
  • Financing coordination
  • Closings & 1031 exchanges

Development

Development sites under the borough’s special zoning rules.

  • Site acquisition & assemblage
  • LDGMA & special-district analysis
  • Coordination with land-use consultants
  • Construction loans & GC contracts
  • Condominium offering plans

Leasing

Retail, medical office, and industrial space.

  • Retail & office leases
  • Industrial & flex space
  • Guaranties & SNDAs
  • Renewals & expansions
  • Landlord & tenant side

How we work

  1. Scoping Call

    We learn the deal, the timeline, and your role in the capital stack — then give you a clear scope and fee quote before work begins.

  2. Structure

    Entity, ownership, tax, and financing structure set before signatures, so the paperwork follows the business plan rather than the other way around.

  3. Documents

    We draft or negotiate the contract, assignment, operating agreement, or offering documents — and read the other side's drafts line by line.

  4. Diligence & Filings

    Title, zoning, environmental, leases, and the regulatory filings the transaction requires — tracked against your hard dates.

  5. Close & After

    We run the closing, record the documents, and stay on for post-closing items, investor reporting questions, and the next deal.

Key terms

Richmond County Clerk
Unlike the other boroughs, Staten Island deeds and mortgages are recorded with the Richmond County Clerk, which serves as the City Register for the borough.
Staten Island Bluebelt
A Department of Environmental Protection stormwater system using streams, ponds, and wetlands. Development near Bluebelt areas may face drainage and easement requirements.
Mapped street
A street shown on the City Map, whether or not built. Building in the bed of a mapped street generally requires Board of Standards and Appeals approval under General City Law § 35.
Private road
A road not maintained by the City. Many Staten Island lots front on private roads, raising access, maintenance, and permitting questions.
Freshwater and tidal wetlands
Wetlands regulated by the State Department of Environmental Conservation. Work within regulated wetlands or their adjacent areas generally requires a DEC permit.
Flood zone and Appendix G
Properties in FEMA flood zones, including along the East and South Shores, must meet flood-resistant construction standards in Appendix G of the New York City Building Code.
Lower-density residential districts
Districts such as R1, R2, R3, and R4 that govern most of Staten Island’s housing and limit building type, height, and density.
Detached and semi-detached restrictions
Many Staten Island districts allow only detached or semi-detached homes, which limits the number and type of buildings on a lot.
Subdivision
Dividing one tax lot into several. Subdivisions generally need Department of Finance tax lot apportionment and compliance with zoning for each new lot.
New York City Real Property Transfer Tax
The City tax on sales, which applies on Staten Island as in the other boroughs, alongside the State transfer tax.
New York City mansion tax
The State tax on residential purchases of $1 million or more, which in New York City rises on a progressive scale for higher prices.
Tax class 1
The New York City property-tax class for most one-to-three family homes, which has its own assessment caps and appeal deadlines.
Certificate of occupancy
The Department of Buildings document stating a building’s lawful use. Many older Staten Island homes have no C of O or one that does not match current use.
Good Cause Eviction Law
A State law that applies in New York City, including Staten Island, to covered unregulated apartments, subject to exemptions such as for small landlords.

Frequently asked questions

Do you handle real estate transactions on Staten Island?

Yes. We represent buyers, sellers, investors, and developers in Staten Island acquisitions, dispositions, development, financing, and leasing.

What is a Lower Density Growth Management Area?

It is a zoning designation, applied to all of Staten Island since 2004, that requires new development in lower-density residential districts to provide more off-street parking, larger yards, and more open space than the same zoning district would require elsewhere in the city.

Does a Special Natural Area District affect what I can build?

It can. On sites with protected natural features — steep slopes, rock outcrops, wetlands, and certain trees — development often requires City Planning Commission authorization or certification, and the approved site plan can limit where and how much you build. We build that review into the contract’s diligence period.

Do New York City transfer taxes apply on Staten Island?

Yes. Staten Island is part of New York City, so the city real property transfer tax, the state transfer tax, and the mortgage recording tax at New York City rates all apply.

Where are Staten Island property records recorded?

Staten Island documents are recorded with the Richmond County Clerk, not through the City Register offices that serve the other boroughs. Title searches and closing logistics account for that difference.

Can I build on a lot that fronts a private road?

Often yes, but access, utility connections, and permitting can be more complicated. The Department of Buildings may require proof of access, and the road’s maintenance responsibilities should be documented. Title insurance coverage for access should also be reviewed.

What if my lot is in the bed of a mapped street?

Building in the bed of a mapped but unbuilt street generally requires Board of Standards and Appeals approval under General City Law § 35. This can affect timing and feasibility. It should be identified before you buy.

Do wetlands affect what I can build on Staten Island?

Yes. Work in DEC-regulated freshwater or tidal wetlands or their adjacent areas generally requires a permit, which may restrict building location or size. A wetlands review should be part of diligence on undeveloped land.

Can I subdivide my Staten Island lot?

Possibly, if each resulting lot meets the zoning requirements for size, frontage, yards, and building type. Lower-density and special district rules on Staten Island can limit subdivision. A zoning analysis should come before any contract that depends on it.

Does flood zone status matter for a Staten Island property?

Yes. Lenders generally require flood insurance in high-risk zones, and new construction or substantial improvements must meet flood-resistant standards. Flood maps and elevation should be reviewed early.

Does the mansion tax apply to Staten Island purchases?

Yes. The State mansion tax applies to residential purchases of $1 million or more throughout New York City, at rates that increase at higher price levels. The buyer generally pays it.

Is there a certificate of occupancy for my Staten Island house?

Older homes may have no certificate of occupancy, or one that does not match current use. Buyers and lenders often require either a C of O or a letter of no objection confirming lawful use. The issue should be resolved before closing.

Does the Bluebelt affect my property?

If your lot is near a Bluebelt stream or wetland, the Department of Environmental Protection may have easements or drainage requirements. These can affect where you build. A survey and title review should reveal recorded easements.

Do you handle Staten Island commercial leases and sales?

Yes. We represent buyers, sellers, landlords, and tenants of Staten Island commercial property, including retail, office, and industrial buildings.

Do I need a lawyer to buy a house on Staten Island?

New York law does not require one, but in New York it is customary for buyer and seller each to have an attorney. The seller’s attorney usually drafts the contract, and the buyer’s attorney negotiates it, reviews title and the municipal record, and coordinates the closing.

Where are Staten Island landlord-tenant cases heard?

In the Civil Court of the City of New York, Richmond County, at 927 Castleton Avenue. That is where both residential and commercial summary proceedings for Staten Island property are filed.

What closing taxes apply when selling a Staten Island house?

For a one- to three-family house, the City transfer tax is 1% up to $500,000 and 1.425% above, and the State tax is 0.4%; the seller generally pays both. A buyer paying $1 million or more also owes the State mansion tax.

When is the deadline to appeal a Staten Island property tax assessment?

For one- to three-family homes in tax class 1, the New York City Tax Commission deadline is March 15. For apartment and commercial property in classes 2 and 4, it is March 1.
Contact

Get in touch

Whether you are under contract, evaluating a building, or planning a development or raise, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content