Distressed Real Estate and Workouts Distressed real estate and loan workouts.

When a property cannot carry its debt, the parties’ options narrow quickly. A workout negotiated early usually preserves more value than a contested foreclosure.

We represent lenders, borrowers, guarantors, mezzanine lenders, and investors in distressed commercial and multifamily real estate in New York.

Most workouts begin with a pre-negotiation letter, which lets lender and borrower talk without waiving rights or creating an informal modification, followed by a forbearance or modification agreement. Common terms include extended maturities, interest rate changes, cash management, additional collateral or paydowns, guarantor releases and, for lenders, an acknowledgment of the debt and a release of claims. Where the property must change hands, the options include a consensual sale, a deed in lieu of foreclosure, a note sale, or foreclosure.

Mortgage and mezzanine remedies run on different tracks. A mortgage foreclosure in New York is generally a judicial proceeding under Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law Article 13, and courts may appoint a receiver to collect rents and manage the property while it is pending. A mezzanine loan is secured by a pledge of the ownership interests in the borrower and is enforced through a sale under Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code, which must be commercially reasonable and can be completed far faster. Intercreditor agreements govern how senior and mezzanine lenders deal with each other.

The rules have changed in recent years. The Foreclosure Abuse Prevention Act of 2022 limited lenders’ ability to reset the six-year statute of limitations once a mortgage debt has been accelerated, and the Court of Appeals upheld its application to pending cases in 2025. Bankruptcy, guaranties, and tax consequences such as transfer taxes on a deed in lieu and cancellation-of-debt income shape every workout.

Our capabilities include:

  • Pre-negotiation letters, forbearance, and loan modifications
  • Deeds in lieu of foreclosure and consensual transfers
  • Commercial mortgage foreclosures and receiverships
  • Mezzanine UCC foreclosures and intercreditor disputes
  • Note purchases, sales, and loan diligence
  • Guaranty enforcement and defense
  • Coordination with bankruptcy counsel on stay relief and plan issues
  • Distressed acquisitions and recapitalizations

Paths through a distressed loan

ForbearanceThe lender agrees not to exercise remedies for a period while the borrower meets agreed conditions.
ModificationThe loan terms change — maturity, rate, amortization, or covenants — usually in exchange for new consideration.
Discounted payoffThe lender accepts less than the full balance in exchange for prompt repayment.
Deed in lieuThe borrower conveys the property to the lender or its designee in satisfaction of all or part of the debt.
Note saleThe lender sells the loan to an investor, who steps into the lender’s rights.
ForeclosureA judicial mortgage foreclosure or, for mezzanine debt, a UCC sale of the pledged interests.

Issues in a deed in lieu

  • Junior liens

    A deed does not eliminate junior liens; the lender usually needs title clear of them or proceeds by foreclosure instead.

  • Merger

    The agreement should provide that the mortgage does not merge into the deed, preserving the lender’s position against intervening liens.

  • Transfer taxes

    State and, in New York City, City transfer taxes may be due on the conveyance, generally measured by the debt satisfied or the property’s value.

  • Releases

    The scope of releases for the borrower and guarantors, and the carve-outs from them, is often the main negotiation.

  • Leases and operations

    Tenant notices, property management, service contracts, licenses, and permits must move with the property.

Key terms

Pre-negotiation letter
An agreement setting ground rules for workout talks, typically preserving each side’s rights.
Forbearance agreement
An agreement by the lender to refrain from exercising remedies for a period, on conditions.
Loan modification
A written change to the loan’s terms, such as maturity, rate, or covenants.
Discounted payoff
Repayment of a loan for less than the balance owed, by agreement.
Deed in lieu of foreclosure
A voluntary conveyance of the property to the lender in satisfaction of the debt.
Anti-merger clause
A provision that keeps the mortgage alive after a deed in lieu, protecting the lender against intervening liens.
Note sale
The sale of a loan, with its rights and remedies, to a new holder.
Receiver
A court-appointed officer who collects rents and manages the property during a foreclosure.
Mezzanine loan
A loan to the owner of the property-owning entity, secured by a pledge of the ownership interests.
Pledge agreement
The agreement granting the mezzanine lender a security interest in the ownership interests.
Intercreditor agreement
The agreement between senior and mezzanine lenders governing notice, cure, purchase, and transfer rights.
UCC Article 9 sale
A sale of personal property collateral, such as pledged equity, after default.
Commercially reasonable
The standard every aspect of a UCC disposition must meet, including method, manner, time, and place.
Nonrecourse carve-out guaranty
A guaranty, often called a bad-boy guaranty, that makes a guarantor liable if specified acts occur.
Deficiency judgment
A judgment for the shortfall between the debt and the value of the property after a foreclosure sale.
Foreclosure Abuse Prevention Act
The 2022 New York law limiting the reset of the statute of limitations on mortgage foreclosures.

Questions we hear most

Should a borrower sign a pre-negotiation letter?

Usually, after reviewing it. It allows candid discussions, but it often confirms the debt, limits claims that the talks created a new agreement, and may include waivers the borrower should negotiate.

How long does a commercial foreclosure take in New York?

Judicial foreclosures can take a long time, depending on the court, the defenses raised, and whether the borrower files for bankruptcy. That timeline is one reason lenders consider receiverships, note sales, and negotiated transfers.

What is a UCC foreclosure on a mezzanine loan?

It is a sale of the pledged ownership interests in the property-owning entity under Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code. Every aspect of the sale must be commercially reasonable, and borrowers sometimes seek to enjoin sales they believe are not.

What does a bankruptcy filing do to a foreclosure?

It triggers the automatic stay, which halts the foreclosure and most collection efforts. In a single asset real estate case, the debtor generally must file a plan with a reasonable possibility of confirmation or begin making interest payments within 90 days after the filing, unless the court extends the time, or the lender may obtain relief from the stay.

Can a lender obtain a receiver without notice?

Many New York mortgages include a clause, recognized under Real Property Law § 254, consenting to the appointment of a receiver on default without notice and without regard to the adequacy of the security. The court still decides whether to appoint one and on what terms.

What is a deficiency judgment?

After a foreclosure sale, the lender may seek a judgment for the shortfall, but generally must move within 90 days after the sale is completed, and the court credits the property’s fair market value if it is higher than the sale price.

What is a bad-boy guaranty?

A guaranty of a nonrecourse loan that makes the guarantor liable for losses, or for the full debt, if specified acts occur, such as a voluntary bankruptcy filing, an unauthorized transfer, or fraud. These guaranties often drive workout negotiations.

What should a note buyer review?

The original note and the chain of endorsements and assignments, the loan documents, default notices, pending litigation, the borrower’s potential defenses, the servicing history, and any intercreditor agreement.

Does the Foreclosure Abuse Prevention Act apply to commercial loans?

Generally yes. Its statute of limitations changes are not limited to residential mortgages, so the history of any acceleration and discontinued actions should be reviewed before a lender sues or a borrower defends.

Do residential foreclosure rules apply to my building?

Some protections, such as the mandatory settlement conference under CPLR 3408, apply to home loans on owner-occupied one-to-four family homes. Commercial and multifamily investment loans generally proceed without them.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content