Surprise Billing Arbitration Out-of-network reimbursement counsel for physicians.

We represent out-of-network surgeons, anesthesiologists, and specialists in New York Independent Dispute Resolution and federal No Surprises Act arbitration — and in court when an insurer will not pay an award.

Madison Law Firm PLLC is a New York City law firm that represents physicians and medical practices in disputes with commercial insurers over out-of-network reimbursement.

Out-of-network specialists in New York routinely accept insurer payments well below what their services are worth — often because the claim seems too small to fight or the process too slow to be worth the effort.

New York’s surprise bill law and the federal No Surprises Act give providers a binding arbitration process to contest those payments. Which framework applies depends on the patient’s plan, and the evidence an arbitrator sees depends on how the submission is built.

We handle the process end to end — identifying eligible claims, preparing the record, negotiating with the payer, prosecuting the arbitration, and enforcing the award — so your billing team can stay focused on the practice.

Our capabilities include:

  • New York Independent Dispute Resolution (DFS) filings
  • Federal No Surprises Act IDR, including batched claims
  • Open negotiation with commercial payers
  • Accounts receivable review and claim triage
  • Award enforcement and CPLR Article 75 proceedings
  • Breach-of-contract and ERISA claims for older or self-funded-plan underpayments
  • In-network contract underpayment disputes

Areas of focus

  • New York IDR Arbitration

    We represent out-of-network physicians in surprise bill and emergency services disputes with New York-regulated health plans, in the IDR process administered by the Department of Financial Services.

    Learn more
  • No Surprises Act Arbitration

    For self-funded employer plans and other coverage outside New York’s reach, the federal independent dispute resolution process decides out-of-network payment. Its deadlines are short and strictly applied.

    Learn more
  • ERISA Provider Appeals

    Most employer health plans are governed by ERISA. When a plan denies or underpays a claim, the internal appeal is often the only record a court will ever see.

    Learn more
  • IDR Award Enforcement

    Winning a determination is not the same as being paid. When a plan delays or refuses, we pursue payment through regulators and, where the law allows, the courts.

    Learn more
  • Underpayment Litigation

    Some underpaid claims are too old, or the wrong type, for arbitration. Many can still be pursued in court.

    Learn more
  • Payer Audit and Recoupment Defense

    A records request from a health plan can turn into a demand to repay years of claims. How the practice responds in the first weeks shapes the outcome.

    Learn more
  • Managed Care Contracting and Disputes

    A participating provider agreement sets a practice’s rates, its audit exposure, and its rights if the plan wants out. The terms worth negotiating are easiest to change before signing.

    Learn more
  • Out-of-Network Documentation (AOB and Notices)

    When a payment dispute reaches arbitration or a courtroom, the case often turns on paperwork collected at the front desk months earlier. Getting it right at intake is far cheaper than reconstructing it later.

    Learn more

Two laws, one strategy

Whether New York law or the federal No Surprises Act governs a claim depends on the patient’s plan. We identify the right forum for each claim before anything is filed.

New York IDRFederal No Surprises Act IDR
Applies toFully insured health plans regulated by New York, plus the Empire Plan and Student Employee Health Plan since August 26, 2026; Medicaid managed care is excludedSelf-funded (ERISA) employer plans and other plans outside New York’s reach
Administered byNew York Department of Financial ServicesCenters for Medicare & Medicaid Services, through certified IDR entities
What the arbitrator weighsFactors including the 80th percentile of usual and customary charges in the same geographic area, the provider’s training and experience, and case complexityThe qualifying payment amount together with the other statutory factors, without a presumption in favor of the QPA
FormatThe entity selects either the provider’s bill or the plan’s paymentEach side submits a final offer; the entity selects one
TimingDecision generally within 45 business days after the entity has all needed information (disputes submitted on or after August 26, 2026)30 business days of open negotiation, 4 business days to initiate, decision generally within 30 business days of entity selection

Who we represent

  • Plastic and reconstructive surgeons

    On-call and emergency procedures at in-network hospitals are among the most common sources of New York surprise bill disputes.

  • Anesthesiologists

    Patients choose their surgeon, not their anesthesiologist, so out-of-network anesthesia at in-network facilities is a recurring source of claims.

  • Assistant surgeons

    Patients rarely know an assistant surgeon’s network status, and the surprise bill laws expressly reach these services.

  • Emergency medicine physicians

    Emergency services are protected under both New York and federal law regardless of network status; physicians may not balance-bill but can pursue arbitration.

  • Neurosurgeons and spine surgeons

    Complex procedures at in-network facilities often produce high-value out-of-network claims.

  • Thoracic and cardiac surgeons

    Non-emergency procedures at in-network hospitals and ambulatory surgery centers fall within the federal process.

  • Radiologists and pathologists

    Ancillary and diagnostic services are expressly covered, and high-volume groups benefit from batched federal claims.

  • Neonatologists, hospitalists, and intensivists

    Physicians called in to treat patients at in-network facilities, without the patient choosing them, are covered under both frameworks.

  • Orthopedic and hand surgeons

    Trauma call and urgent fracture, tendon, and hand repairs at in-network hospitals often involve surgeons the patient did not choose.

  • General, trauma, and vascular surgeons

    Emergency and on-call surgery is a leading source of out-of-network claims, and emergency services are protected regardless of network status.

  • Otolaryngologists and facial plastic surgeons

    On-call head, neck, and facial trauma and reconstruction at in-network facilities generate claims under both frameworks.

  • Obstetricians and gynecologists

    Laborists and on-call obstetricians who deliver or operate at in-network hospitals are often out of network for the patient’s plan.

  • Interventional cardiologists and cardiologists

    Emergency catheterizations and consultations at in-network hospitals are covered as emergency or facility-based services.

  • Gastroenterologists and urologists

    Urgent endoscopy, stone, and obstruction procedures performed at in-network hospitals can qualify for arbitration.

  • Pediatric surgeons and pediatric subspecialists

    Children admitted through in-network emergency departments are frequently treated by subspecialists outside the family’s network.

  • Intraoperative neuromonitoring groups

    Monitoring professionals are assigned to the case by the facility or surgeon, not chosen by the patient, which places their claims squarely within the surprise billing laws.

  • Laboratories and diagnostic services

    Under the federal law, diagnostic services, including laboratory and radiology services, are ancillary services that cannot be removed from patient protections by notice and consent.

  • Ambulatory surgery centers and physician groups

    We work with multi-specialty groups, management companies, and facilities to review claims across their payer mix and file in the right forum.

  • Any other out-of-network provider

    If you treated a patient out of network and the plan underpaid, the claim may qualify, whatever your specialty. Physicians, groups, facilities, and other licensed providers can send us their claims for a no-cost review.

Request a claims review

How we work

  1. Accounts receivable review

    We review your out-of-network claims at no charge, identify those eligible under New York or federal law, and outline a strategy for your specialty and payer mix.

  2. Claim preparation

    We assemble benchmark data for your service codes, document your credentials and usual charges, and gather EOBs and correspondence into the record the arbitrator will see.

  3. Negotiation and arbitration

    We conduct open negotiation with the payer and, if it fails, file through the DFS or federal IDR portal and manage every deadline and communication.

  4. Award and enforcement

    When an award issues, we track payment and, if an insurer delays or refuses, pursue enforcement with CMS or in court.

Claims you have written off may still be recoverable

Claims your billing department marked uncollectable may still be recoverable. At intake we sort every claim into the forum most likely to produce a recovery:

  • Recent fully insured claims

    New York Independent Dispute Resolution through DFS.

  • Older fully insured claims

    A breach-of-contract action, which generally carries a six-year limitations period under CPLR § 213(2), or Article 75 proceedings to confirm and enforce awards.

  • Self-funded employer plans

    Federal No Surprises Act arbitration and, where appropriate, claims under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B).

Key terms

Out-of-network provider
A physician or practice that has no participation agreement with the patient’s health plan.
Surprise bill
Under New York law, generally a bill for services by an out-of-network physician at an in-network hospital or surgery center where the patient did not knowingly choose that physician, or certain unauthorized referrals.
Balance billing
Billing the patient for the difference between the provider’s charge and the plan’s payment; the surprise billing laws prohibit it in covered situations.
IDRE
An independent dispute resolution entity, the reviewer that decides payment disputes under New York or federal law.
Fully insured plan
A plan in which an insurer bears the financial risk; those issued in New York are generally subject to the New York IDR process.
Self-funded plan
An employer plan that bears its own claims risk, usually governed by ERISA and generally subject to the federal No Surprises Act process.
EOB
An explanation of benefits, the plan’s statement of what it allowed and paid on a claim, which is central evidence in any dispute.
FAIR Health
The independent nonprofit whose charge database New York uses to measure usual and customary cost.
UCR
Usual, customary, and reasonable cost; under New York law, the 80th percentile of charges for the service in the same geographic area.
QPA
The qualifying payment amount, generally the plan’s median contracted rate for the service in the area, which federal IDR entities consider along with other factors.
Open negotiation
The 30-business-day negotiation period that must precede federal IDR.
Baseball arbitration
A format in which the reviewer must choose one side’s number and cannot split the difference.
Assignment of benefits
A patient’s transfer of the right to plan payment to the provider, required for New York surprise bill disputes and for many contract claims.
Award enforcement
The steps taken to collect a determination a plan has not paid, including demands, regulatory complaints, and court proceedings where available.
Contingency fee
A fee measured as a percentage of the recovery, agreed in a written engagement letter.

Questions we hear most

Do I have to stop accepting insurance to use this process?

No. Independent dispute resolution applies to claims you were paid as an out-of-network provider. It does not affect your in-network contracts, and you can be in-network with some carriers while pursuing arbitration against others.

What if I’m in-network with the insurer?

Arbitration under these laws is generally for out-of-network services. If you are in-network and the carrier has underpaid under your contract, that is a contract dispute, usually pursued through the contract’s dispute process or in court. We advise on both.

My claims are more than a year old. Are they still eligible?

It depends on the plan type and claim history. New York’s process has no short statutory filing window, but claims are most workable while records and EOBs are readily available. Older fully insured claims may support a breach-of-contract action, which generally has a six-year limitations period under CPLR § 213(2), subject to plan terms and a valid assignment of benefits. Federal claims move on much shorter deadlines, so timing matters.

What is FAIR Health and why does it matter?

FAIR Health is an independent nonprofit that maintains a large database of private insurance claims. New York’s arbitration criteria include the 80th percentile of usual and customary charges for the same service in the same geographic area, which is typically measured with FAIR Health data. It is one of several factors the arbitrator weighs.

Which plans are not covered?

Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, and VA benefits are outside both the New York and federal surprise billing processes, and New York removed Medicaid managed care plans from its process for disputes filed on or after May 28, 2026. These laws apply to commercial coverage. Since August 26, 2026, New York’s process also covers the Empire Plan and the Student Employee Health Plan, under a separate payment standard.

What is the difference between fully insured and self-funded plans?

A fully insured plan is one where the employer buys coverage from a carrier that bears the risk; these plans are regulated by New York and fall under the state process. A self-funded (ERISA) plan is one where the employer bears the risk and uses a carrier only to administer claims; these plans fall under the federal No Surprises Act. The difference determines the forum, the deadlines, and the benchmark.

What happens if we win and the insurer does not pay?

Awards are binding. For federal awards we can raise non-payment with CMS and pursue enforcement in court; New York awards can be enforced in court as well. We do not consider a matter closed until payment is received.

How long does the process take?

In the New York process, for disputes submitted on or after August 26, 2026, the dispute resolution entity generally decides within 45 business days after receiving all the information it needs. In the federal process, a 30-business-day open negotiation period comes first, and the entity generally decides within 30 business days of its selection. Many matters settle during negotiation.

Can multiple claims be submitted together?

Yes. The federal process allows qualifying claims to be batched — for example, by payer, service code, and time period — which matters for high-volume practices such as anesthesiology, radiology, and pathology groups.

What does it cost?

We handle surprise billing arbitration on a contingency basis: our fee is a percentage of the amount recovered above the insurer’s initial payment. Fee terms, including how any costs are handled, are set out in a written engagement letter before we begin. The initial accounts receivable review is complimentary.

How do I know whether a claim falls under New York or federal law?

Start with the patient’s plan: fully insured plans issued in New York generally go to the New York process, while self-funded employer plans generally go to the federal process. The insurance card, EOB, and plan documents often indicate the funding type, but not always. We confirm the plan type before filing.

What information does my billing team need to send for a review?

Generally, claim-level data for out-of-network commercial claims: dates of service, CPT codes, billed charges, allowed and paid amounts, payer and plan information, and EOBs. Assignment of benefits forms and any payer correspondence are also useful. We will send a list tailored to your practice.

Can I balance-bill the patient while the dispute is pending?

Not for claims covered by the surprise billing laws. Patients in covered situations generally owe only their in-network cost-sharing, and the dispute is between the provider and the plan. Billing the patient in those situations can create regulatory problems.

Does filing arbitration damage my relationship with the insurer?

The processes are created by statute and used routinely by providers. Filing does not affect the patient’s coverage or any in-network contracts with other plans. Many disputes settle during negotiation.

Is the arbitrator’s decision public?

The federal government publishes aggregate data about the federal IDR process, and New York publishes information about its program. Individual submissions are not generally made public, though data about determinations may be reported in aggregate.

Do you represent hospitals or facilities?

Our practice focuses on physicians and physician groups. Facilities have their own rights under the federal No Surprises Act. Tell us about your organization and we will let you know whether we can help.

Do I need to be in New York to use your services?

We are a New York firm and the New York IDR process applies to New York-regulated plans. Federal IDR is available nationwide, and we can discuss whether we can assist with claims outside New York consistent with licensing rules.

How involved does my practice need to be?

After the initial data exchange and signing of documents, we handle the process, including payer communications, filings, and deadlines. We may ask for clinical notes or physician input on complex cases. We report on status regularly.

What happens to the money once an award is paid?

Payments are generally made by the plan to the practice or to the firm’s escrow account, as arranged in the engagement letter, and the contingency fee is calculated as the engagement letter provides. We reconcile each payment against the determination.

Can patients use these processes?

In some situations patients have their own dispute rights, such as New York’s process for certain surprise bills and the federal patient-provider dispute resolution process for uninsured or self-pay patients who receive a bill well above a good-faith estimate. Our practice represents providers.

Are dental or behavioral health claims covered?

Coverage depends on the plan and the type of service, and whether the service falls within the statutory definitions. Some behavioral health services may be covered; standalone dental plans generally are not part of these processes. We review each claim’s eligibility.
Contact

Request a claims review

Tell us about your practice, your specialty, and your approximate volume of out-of-network commercial claims. We will review your accounts receivable at no charge, identify claims eligible under New York law or the No Surprises Act, and give you a candid assessment. Surprise billing arbitration is handled on a contingency basis under a written engagement letter.

Request a claims review

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content