Amending Governing Documents Amending co-op and condominium governing documents.
Governing documents written decades ago often no longer fit how a building operates. Changing them is a legal process with fixed vote requirements, and a defective vote can be undone in court.
We represent co-op and condominium boards proposing amendments, and shareholders and unit owners who question whether an amendment was validly adopted.
A co-op has several layers of documents. The certificate of incorporation is amended under the Business Corporation Law, generally by board authorization followed by a vote of the holders of a majority of the outstanding shares entitled to vote, and the certificate of amendment is filed with the Department of State. The bylaws are amended as the bylaws and the Business Corporation Law provide. The proprietary lease usually contains its own amendment clause, and many leases require the approval of shareholders holding two-thirds or more of the shares.
In a condominium, the bylaws must provide a method of amendment. Real Property Law § 339-v generally requires that bylaw amendments be approved by at least 66⅔ percent of unit owners in number and in common interest, and RPL § 339-u provides that a bylaw amendment is valid only if it is set forth in an amendment to the declaration that is duly recorded. A change to a unit’s percentage of common interest generally requires the consent of the affected owners.
The vote is only as strong as the process behind it. Notice of the meeting, the form of proxy, the quorum, the record date, and the count each need to match the governing documents and the statute. We draft the amendment, the explanatory memorandum, and the proxy together so that the amendment holds up if it is challenged.
Our capabilities include:
- Proprietary lease and occupancy agreement amendments
- Co-op bylaw and certificate of incorporation amendments
- Condo declaration and bylaw amendments and recording
- House rules and board policies
- Proxies, ballots, notices, and meeting procedure
- Inspector-of-election and vote count review
- Challenges to amendments adopted without a valid vote
Who must approve what
| Co-op certificate of incorporation | Board authorization, then generally a majority of outstanding shares entitled to vote; filed with the Department of State |
|---|---|
| Co-op bylaws | Shareholders, or the board where the certificate or bylaws allow it |
| Co-op proprietary lease | As the lease provides, commonly two-thirds or more of the shares |
| Condo bylaws | Generally at least 66⅔% of unit owners in number and common interest; recorded as an amendment to the declaration |
| Condo declaration | As the declaration provides; changes to common interest generally need consent of affected owners |
| House rules | Usually the board alone, within the authority the documents give it |
How an amendment moves forward
Identify the problem
Confirm what needs to change, which document controls it, and whether a board resolution or house rule can do the job without a vote.
Draft for the threshold
Write the amendment, a plain-language explanation, and a proxy that satisfy the notice and vote requirements.
Hold the vote
Call the meeting or written consent as the documents allow, appoint inspectors of election, and keep the proxies and tally.
Make it effective
File the certificate of amendment with the Department of State, or record the condo declaration amendment with the City Register or county clerk, and circulate the final text.
Key terms
- Certificate of incorporation
- The document filed with the Department of State that creates a co-op corporation and sets its authorized shares.
- Certificate of amendment
- The filing that changes a certificate of incorporation.
- Bylaws
- The internal rules for meetings, elections, officers, and board authority.
- Proprietary lease
- The lease between the co-op and each shareholder that governs occupancy of the apartment.
- Declaration
- The recorded document that creates a condominium and defines its units and common elements.
- Common interest
- A condo unit’s percentage interest in the common elements, which also sets voting weight and share of common charges.
- House rules
- Day-to-day building rules adopted by the board.
- Business Corporation Law
- The New York statute that governs co-op corporations.
- Condominium Act
- Real Property Law Article 9-B, which governs New York condominiums.
- Proxy
- A written authorization for another person to vote a shareholder’s or unit owner’s interest.
- Quorum
- The minimum participation needed for a meeting to act.
- Record date
- The date that fixes who is entitled to vote.
- Inspector of election
- A neutral person who receives proxies and certifies the vote count.
- Written consent
- Action by shareholders in writing without a meeting, where the documents and statute permit it.
Questions we hear most
Can a co-op board change the proprietary lease on its own?
Does a condo bylaw amendment need to be recorded?
Can we vote by proxy or online?
What if an amendment was adopted without enough votes?
What kinds of changes do buildings commonly make?
Is a flip tax adopted by amendment enforceable?
Can a condo restrict leasing by amendment?
Who pays for the amendment process?
Can shareholders propose an amendment?
How long does it take?
Get in touch
Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.