Non-performing loan and note acquisitions.

A buyer of a defaulted loan acquires the lender’s rights, along with every defect in how the loan was documented, transferred, and enforced. The diligence has to find those defects before the price is set.

We represent investors, funds, lenders, and special servicers in acquiring, enforcing, and resolving non-performing commercial mortgage and mezzanine loans secured by New York property.

A note purchase is governed by the loan sale agreement, which is typically written for the seller: the loans are sold as is, with limited representations, short survival periods, and repurchase or cure as the main remedy. The buyer’s protection comes from diligence on the collateral file. That file should contain the original promissory note with a complete chain of endorsements or allonges, the recorded mortgage and every recorded assignment, the loan agreement, guaranties, title policy, UCC filings, and the servicing history, including any notices of default, acceleration letters, and prior foreclosure actions. A missing original note can sometimes be addressed through a lost note affidavit and the procedure under New York UCC § 3-804, but it adds cost and risk.

Standing is often the first issue in a New York foreclosure. The Court of Appeals held in Aurora Loan Services, LLC v. Taylor (2015) that a plaintiff that holds the note, or has been assigned it, when the action is commenced has standing, because the mortgage follows the note. In a commercial case, a standing defense is generally waived if it is not raised in the answer or a pre-answer motion, but RPAPL § 1302-a preserves the defense for home loans. The Foreclosure Abuse Prevention Act, enacted December 30, 2022, limits a lender’s ability to reset the six-year statute of limitations by revoking an acceleration or voluntarily discontinuing an action. On November 25, 2025, the Court of Appeals held in Article 13 LLC v. Ponce De Leon Federal Bank, 45 N.Y.3d 441, and Van Dyke v. U.S. Bank, N.A., 45 N.Y.3d 461, that the Act applies retroactively and rejected the due process and Contract Clause challenges raised in those cases, so a loan accelerated years ago may already be time-barred.

The exit strategy drives the price. A judicial foreclosure under RPAPL Article 13 can take years, though a receiver may be appointed to collect rents in the meantime; a deed in lieu of foreclosure is faster but raises title, transfer tax, and merger issues; a mezzanine loan is enforced through a commercially reasonable UCC Article 9 sale of the pledged equity. Loans on one-to-four family homes bring additional rules, including RPAPL § 1304 pre-foreclosure notices, CPLR 3408 settlement conferences, and Department of Financial Services registration requirements for mortgage loan servicers, which affect a buyer’s plan even when its focus is commercial.

Our capabilities include:

  • Loan sale and note purchase agreements
  • Collateral file, endorsement, and assignment diligence
  • Statute of limitations and FAPA analysis
  • Commercial foreclosure and receivership strategy
  • Deeds in lieu, discounted payoffs, and workouts
  • Mezzanine loan UCC Article 9 enforcement
  • Guaranty enforcement and deficiency claims
  • Loan-to-own acquisitions and REO dispositions

What to review in the collateral file

  • Original note and endorsements

    Confirm the original note exists, the endorsement chain is complete and runs to the seller or in blank, and any allonge is properly affixed.

  • Mortgage and assignments

    Confirm the mortgage was recorded and each assignment is in recordable form, with any gaps in the chain identified before closing.

  • Acceleration history

    Identify every acceleration letter, foreclosure action, and discontinuance, because under FAPA they may have started a limitations period that cannot be reset.

  • Guaranties and other credit support

    Review recourse, carve-out, and completion guaranties, letters of credit, and cash management accounts, and confirm they transfer with the loan.

  • Title and liens

    Obtain a title update showing senior and junior liens, mechanic’s liens, tax liens, and any intervening interests.

  • Servicing and borrower communications

    Review payment history, forbearance or modification agreements, and correspondence that could support a borrower defense.

Exit strategies compared

Judicial foreclosureRequired for most New York mortgages; slower, but produces a court-supervised sale and can support a deficiency judgment if timely sought under RPAPL § 1371
ReceivershipA court-appointed receiver collects rents and manages the property while the foreclosure is pending
Deed in lieuThe borrower conveys the property by agreement; requires title review, an estoppel affidavit, and attention to transfer taxes and junior liens
Mezzanine UCC saleEnforcement of a pledge of the borrower’s equity, which must be commercially reasonable under UCC § 9-610 with notice under § 9-611
Note saleResale of the loan to another investor, subject to the buyer’s own diligence
WorkoutA modification, discounted payoff, or forbearance agreement with the borrower

Acquiring a non-performing loan

  1. Sign confidentiality and bid terms

    Agree to the seller’s confidentiality terms and bid procedures, and confirm what data room access includes.

  2. Diligence the loan and the property

    Review the collateral file, title, limitations analysis, property condition, leases, and borrower and guarantor finances.

  3. Negotiate the loan sale agreement

    Focus on the representations about the note and the file, cure and repurchase remedies, and delivery of the original documents.

  4. Close and take control

    Obtain endorsements or allonges, recordable assignments, a servicing transfer, and notices to the borrower and guarantors.

  5. Enforce or resolve

    Pursue foreclosure, a receivership, a deed in lieu, a UCC sale, or a negotiated workout, as the loan and the property warrant.

Key terms

Non-performing loan (NPL)
A loan in payment or covenant default, typically sold at a discount to its unpaid balance.
Loan sale agreement
The contract governing the sale of a loan or pool of loans, including representations, remedies, and document delivery.
Collateral file
The original loan documents, including the note, mortgage, assignments, and guaranties.
Allonge
A separate paper attached to a note to carry endorsements when there is no room on the note itself.
Endorsement in blank
An endorsement that names no payee, making the note payable to whoever holds it.
Assignment of mortgage
A recorded instrument transferring the mortgage to a new holder.
Lost note affidavit
A sworn statement used to enforce a note whose original cannot be located, under New York UCC § 3-804.
Standing
The right to bring the foreclosure, generally held by the party holding or assigned the note when the action is commenced.
Acceleration
The lender’s demand for the entire loan balance, which generally starts the six-year statute of limitations under CPLR 213(4).
Foreclosure Abuse Prevention Act (FAPA)
The 2022 law that limits a lender’s ability to reset the limitations period through de-acceleration or voluntary discontinuance.
Receiver
A court-appointed person who collects rents and manages a property during a foreclosure.
Deed in lieu of foreclosure
A conveyance of the property from the borrower to the lender in satisfaction or reduction of the debt.
Deficiency judgment
A judgment for the debt remaining after a foreclosure sale, which must be sought by timely motion under RPAPL § 1371.
UCC Article 9 sale
The sale of pledged personal property, such as equity in a borrower, to enforce a mezzanine loan.
Election of remedies
The rule in RPAPL § 1301 limiting a lender from suing on the debt and foreclosing at the same time without leave of court.

Questions we hear most

Who has standing to foreclose after a loan is sold?

Generally, the party that held the note, or had been assigned it, when the foreclosure action was commenced. A buyer of a loan in a pending foreclosure usually seeks to be substituted as plaintiff, and should confirm the prior plaintiff’s standing.

What did the Court of Appeals decide about FAPA?

On November 25, 2025, in Article 13 LLC v. Ponce De Leon Federal Bank, 45 N.Y.3d 441, and Van Dyke v. U.S. Bank, N.A., 45 N.Y.3d 461, the Court held that the Foreclosure Abuse Prevention Act applies retroactively and rejected the due process and Contract Clause challenges raised in those cases. A lender generally cannot reset the limitations period by revoking an earlier acceleration.

Can we foreclose on a mezzanine loan without going to court?

Generally, yes. A mezzanine loan secured by a pledge of equity is enforced through a UCC Article 9 sale, which must be commercially reasonable and preceded by proper notice. The intercreditor agreement with the mortgage lender will also govern who may buy and on what terms.

Is a deed in lieu better than a foreclosure?

It is usually faster and cheaper, but it does not wipe out junior liens the way a foreclosure can, and it must be structured to avoid claims that the transfer was coerced or that the mortgage merged into the deed. Title insurance and transfer taxes also need to be addressed.

Does the seller have to deliver the original note?

The loan sale agreement should require it. Without the original note, the buyer may need a lost note affidavit and court proof to enforce the loan, which adds cost and gives the borrower an issue to contest.

Does FAPA apply to commercial loans?

FAPA’s amendments to the CPLR are not limited by their terms to residential loans, so any loan with an old acceleration or a discontinued foreclosure should be analyzed under the Act before a bid is made.

Can a guarantor be sued while the foreclosure is pending?

Often, yes, depending on the guaranty and the procedural posture. Many commercial guaranties are written as guaranties of payment that can be enforced directly, but the election of remedies rule and any deficiency judgment requirements must be considered.

What are the extra rules for residential loans?

Home loans require RPAPL § 1304 pre-foreclosure notices, CPLR 3408 settlement conferences, and other protections, and RPAPL § 1302-a preserves the borrower’s standing defense. Servicers of these loans are subject to registration and conduct rules administered by the Department of Financial Services.

How long does a commercial foreclosure take in New York?

It varies widely by county, the borrower’s defenses, and court calendars, and contested cases can take years. A receiver can protect the property and the rents while the case is pending.

Can a buyer of a loan in litigation continue the existing case?

Generally, yes. The buyer moves to be substituted as plaintiff, and the case continues, but the buyer inherits the record, including any rulings, defects, and delays.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content