Brownfield Cleanup Program The New York State Brownfield Cleanup Program.
The Brownfield Cleanup Program can turn a contaminated site into a financeable project with State liability protection and refundable tax credits. The decisions made at the application stage shape what the project receives at the end.
We represent developers, owners, buyers, lenders, and investors in entering, completing, and financing sites in New York’s Brownfield Cleanup Program and in related New York City cleanup programs.
The Brownfield Cleanup Program is established by Article 27, Title 14 of the Environmental Conservation Law and administered by the Department of Environmental Conservation. A site is generally eligible if contaminants are present at levels exceeding DEC’s soil cleanup objectives or other health-based or environmental standards. Some sites are excluded, including National Priorities List sites, Class 1 and Class 2 sites on the State’s registry of inactive hazardous waste disposal sites (a Class 2 site owned by, or under contract to, a volunteer may still qualify if DEC has not identified a responsible party able to pay for the cleanup), and sites subject to certain cleanup orders or pending enforcement actions. An accepted applicant signs a Brownfield Cleanup Agreement with DEC and performs the investigation and cleanup under DEC oversight.
The program’s value turns on the certificate of completion. DEC issues the certificate when the remedial action objectives in the site’s decision document are met; it provides a limitation of liability to the State for contamination identified by the remedial program and makes the applicant eligible for the refundable brownfield tax credits. The 2022 State budget extended the program: sites must generally be admitted by December 31, 2032 and receive a certificate of completion by December 31, 2036. The same legislation added a $50,000 program fee, with a hardship waiver that must be requested with the application.
Applicant status carries different obligations. A volunteer, an applicant whose liability, if any, arises solely from owning or operating the site after the contamination occurred and who takes reasonable steps to address it, must address contamination on the site and prevent its migration off-site, while a participant, such as an owner at the time of disposal, must also address contamination that has migrated off-site. In New York City, the Mayor’s Office of Environmental Remediation administers the City’s Voluntary Cleanup Program and the E-designation program. A site enrolled in the State program cannot also enroll in the City’s Voluntary Cleanup Program, but a State program site that carries an E-designation must still satisfy the Office of Environmental Remediation’s E-designation requirements.
Our capabilities include:
- Brownfield Cleanup Program eligibility analysis and applications
- Brownfield Cleanup Agreements and amendments, including added parcels and parties
- Volunteer and participant status and certifications
- Remedy selection, cleanup tracks, and environmental easements
- Certificates of completion and transfers of program benefits
- Brownfield tax credit structuring with tax advisors
- NYC E-designations and Voluntary Cleanup Program coordination
- Purchase contracts, joint ventures, and financing for brownfield sites
The four cleanup tracks
Track 1
A cleanup that allows unrestricted use of the property, with no use restrictions or long-term engineering controls; it carries the highest site preparation credit rate.
Track 2
A restricted-use cleanup that meets DEC’s generic soil cleanup objectives for residential, restricted residential, commercial, or industrial use.
Track 3
A restricted-use cleanup that meets soil cleanup objectives modified for site-specific conditions, for the same categories of use as Track 2.
Track 4
A restricted-use cleanup that relies on engineering and institutional controls, including a cover system of soil or hardscape over the site that meets the soil cleanup objectives for the intended use.
Environmental easement
Restricted-use cleanups are generally backed by a recorded environmental easement and a site management plan that bind future owners and must be accounted for in leases and financing.
Brownfield tax credits at a glance
| Site preparation and groundwater components | A percentage of eligible investigation, remediation, and site preparation costs, from 22% to 50% depending on the cleanup track and the use of the site |
|---|---|
| Tangible property component | A base rate of 10% of qualifying improvements, with additional percentages for factors such as a Track 1 cleanup, affordable housing, manufacturing, Brownfield Opportunity Areas, and disadvantaged communities |
| Tangible property cap | Generally the lesser of $35 million or three times the site preparation and groundwater costs, with a higher cap for manufacturing sites |
| New York City limitation | For City sites accepted after July 1, 2015, the tangible property credit is available only if the site meets a test such as being upside down, underutilized, in an Environmental Zone, or used for affordable housing |
| Trigger | Credits generally become available only after DEC issues the certificate of completion |
From application to certificate of completion
Prepare the pre-application
Assemble Phase I and Phase II data, settle the site boundaries, and meet with DEC regional staff before filing.
File the application
Describe the site history and contamination clearly, claim volunteer or participant status, and request any fee waiver with the application.
Sign the cleanup agreement
Negotiate and execute the Brownfield Cleanup Agreement and submit the community participation plan.
Investigate and select the remedy
Complete the remedial investigation and remedial action work plan, followed by a public comment period and DEC’s decision document.
Remediate and close out
Perform the cleanup, record any environmental easement, submit the final engineering report, and obtain the certificate of completion.
Key terms
- Brownfield Cleanup Program (BCP)
- The DEC program under ECL Article 27, Title 14 for the voluntary cleanup and redevelopment of contaminated sites.
- Brownfield site
- Real property where contaminants exceed applicable soil cleanup objectives or other health-based or environmental standards.
- Brownfield Cleanup Agreement (BCA)
- The agreement between DEC and the applicant governing investigation and cleanup of the site.
- Volunteer
- An applicant whose liability, if any, arises solely from owning or operating the site after the contamination occurred, and whose obligations focus on the site and preventing off-site migration.
- Participant
- An applicant that was an owner or operator at the time of disposal or is otherwise responsible, with obligations that extend off-site.
- Soil cleanup objectives (SCOs)
- DEC’s contaminant levels, set by use category, that a cleanup must meet.
- Track 1 through Track 4
- The four cleanup tracks under 6 NYCRR Part 375, ranging from unrestricted use to site-specific restricted use.
- Decision document
- DEC’s document selecting the remedy for the site after public comment.
- Certificate of completion (COC)
- DEC’s certificate that the remedial action objectives have been met, which triggers liability protection and tax credit eligibility.
- Environmental easement
- A recorded restriction under ECL Article 71, Title 36 that enforces use limits and engineering controls on a cleaned-up site.
- Site management plan
- The plan governing long-term monitoring, engineering controls, and reporting after the cleanup.
- Site preparation credit
- The tax credit component based on eligible investigation, remediation, and site preparation costs.
- Tangible property credit
- The tax credit component based on the cost of qualifying buildings and improvements placed in service on the site.
- Upside down
- A site whose estimated cleanup cost is at least 75% of its value as if uncontaminated, one of the City tests for the tangible property credit.
- NYC Voluntary Cleanup Program
- The City cleanup program administered by the Office of Environmental Remediation, open to most City sites other than those enrolled in the State program, on the State hazardous waste registry, on the National Priorities List, or subject to a State cleanup order.
Questions we hear most
Is the Brownfield Cleanup Program still accepting sites?
What is the difference between a volunteer and a participant?
Does a certificate of completion release all environmental liability?
Can a New York City site receive the full tax credits?
Is there a fee to enter the program?
Can a buyer step into a seller’s brownfield site?
Are pre-application investigation costs eligible for credits?
Does a restricted-use cleanup affect financing?
Should a City site use the State program or the City program?
What happens if the site is not finished by the deadline?
Get in touch
Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.