AI and PropTech in Real Estate AI and proptech in real estate transactions.
Software now screens tenants, sets prices, reads leases, and opens doors. The legal duties still belong to the owner, broker, or manager who uses it.
We represent owners, managing agents, brokers, co-op and condominium boards, and proptech companies on the legal risks of using AI and data-driven tools in New York real estate.
Tenant screening tools, automated valuation models, pricing software, smart building systems, and AI drafting tools all make decisions or recommendations that used to be made by people. The law does not excuse a discriminatory or unlawful decision because a vendor’s software made it. Under the federal Fair Housing Act, the Supreme Court recognized disparate-impact liability in Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs v. Inclusive Communities Project (2015), and the New York State and City Human Rights Laws independently prohibit housing discrimination on a broader list of grounds, including lawful source of income. New York City’s Fair Chance for Housing Act, effective January 1, 2025, generally bars considering criminal history until after a conditional offer and limits what records may be considered, so a screening product must be configured to follow that sequence.
New York has restricted algorithmic rent-setting. In October 2025, the State enacted General Business Law § 340-b, which prohibits facilitating agreements among residential landlords not to compete, including through software performing a “coordinating function,” and separately prohibits landlords from setting rents or lease terms based on such software’s recommendations. On September 29, 2026, the Southern District of New York, in RealPage, Inc. v. James, preliminarily enjoined the Attorney General from enforcing the landlord-facing provision, subsection (3), while leaving the facilitation provision in effect; the Attorney General has asked the court to reconsider. Federal and state antitrust law continue to apply in either case.
Data collected by building technology raises its own obligations. New York City’s Tenant Data Privacy Act, Local Law 63 of 2021, regulates owners of multiple dwellings that use smart access systems such as key fobs, apps, and biometrics, requiring a privacy policy, limiting what data may be collected, requiring deletion of authentication data within 90 days unless anonymized, and prohibiting sale of the data. The City’s biometric identifier law, Administrative Code §§ 22-1201 to 22-1205, requires signs at entrances of covered commercial establishments that collect biometric data and prohibits selling it. Vendor contracts should address these duties, along with confidentiality when AI tools are used to draft or review documents.
Our capabilities include:
- Fair housing review of tenant screening and leasing tools
- Fair Chance for Housing Act compliance in screening workflows
- Advice on algorithmic pricing and antitrust risk
- Tenant Data Privacy Act and biometric law compliance
- Proptech vendor contracts, data terms, and indemnities
- Policies on AI use for brokers, managers, and boards
- Confidentiality and privilege in AI-assisted document work
- Defense of discrimination complaints involving automated tools
Where AI meets New York real estate law
| Tenant screening | Fair Housing Act, State and City Human Rights Laws, Fair Chance for Housing Act, and limits on application fees and background checks under Real Property Law § 238-a |
|---|---|
| Rent pricing | General Business Law § 340-b (subsection (3) preliminarily enjoined as of September 29, 2026) and federal and state antitrust law |
| Smart access systems | Tenant Data Privacy Act, Local Law 63 of 2021, for multiple dwellings using key fobs, apps, or biometrics |
| Biometric data in commercial spaces | Administrative Code §§ 22-1201 to 22-1205: entrance signs and a ban on selling biometric data |
| Valuation | Lender and appraisal rules on automated valuation models, and disclosure of how values are derived |
| Document drafting and review | Confidentiality, privilege, and accuracy obligations when AI tools handle client or deal information |
Terms to require in a proptech vendor contract
Compliance with law
A specific covenant that the tool complies with fair housing, consumer reporting, and New York City requirements, not just a general representation.
Configuration control
The owner’s ability to set and audit screening criteria, including the Fair Chance for Housing Act’s two-step sequence.
Data use limits
Limits on the vendor’s use, sale, and retention of tenant and building data, consistent with the Tenant Data Privacy Act where it applies.
Security and breach notice
Security standards, breach notification, and cooperation with New York’s data breach notification requirements.
Pricing inputs
For pricing tools, disclosure of the data used and confirmation that the tool does not use competitors’ non-public data to coordinate rents.
Indemnity and insurance
Vendor indemnity for claims caused by the tool and insurance to back it, with limits that reflect the actual risk.
Reviewing an AI tool before deployment
Map the decision
Identify what the tool decides or recommends, who relies on it, and which laws govern that decision.
Test the criteria
Review screening and pricing criteria for disparate impact and for factors New York law prohibits.
Review the data flows
Confirm what data is collected, where it goes, how long it is kept, and whether notices or consents are required.
Negotiate the contract
Secure compliance covenants, audit rights, data limits, and indemnity.
Train and monitor
Train staff on the tool’s limits, keep human review of adverse decisions, and audit results periodically.
Key terms
- Proptech
- Technology products used in buying, selling, leasing, financing, or managing real estate.
- Disparate impact
- Liability for a practice that disproportionately harms a protected group without sufficient justification, even without intent.
- Fair Chance for Housing Act
- New York City’s law, effective January 1, 2025, restricting the use of criminal history in housing decisions.
- Conditional offer
- An offer of housing made before any criminal history review, as the Fair Chance for Housing Act requires.
- Individualized assessment
- The case-by-case review required before revoking a conditional offer based on criminal history.
- Source of income
- A protected category under New York law covering lawful income such as housing vouchers.
- Coordinating function
- Under General Business Law § 340-b, software that gathers multiple owners’ data and recommends rents or lease terms.
- Automated valuation model (AVM)
- Software that estimates property value from data rather than an appraiser’s inspection.
- Smart access system
- A building entry system using key fobs, apps, cards, or biometrics.
- Tenant Data Privacy Act
- Local Law 63 of 2021, regulating data from smart access systems in New York City multiple dwellings.
- Biometric identifier information
- Physiological or biological characteristics used to identify a person, such as fingerprints or face geometry.
- Authentication data
- Data generated when a person uses a smart access system to enter.
- Consumer report
- A report on a consumer’s credit, rental, or criminal history, regulated by federal and New York law.
- Algorithmic pricing
- Software-driven setting or recommendation of rents or prices.
Questions we hear most
Can a landlord be liable for a screening company’s algorithm?
Is algorithmic rent-setting software banned in New York?
Do smart lock and key fob systems have special rules in New York City?
Can brokers and managers use AI tools to draft leases and listings?
Does the Fair Chance for Housing Act apply to co-op boards?
Does New York City’s biometric law apply to residential buildings?
What penalties apply under the biometric identifier law?
Are automated valuation models regulated?
Can AI-drafted documents waive privilege or confidentiality?
What should a landlord do after an adverse screening decision by software?
Get in touch
Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.