Condo and Co-op Conversions Converting occupied rental buildings to cooperatives and condominiums.
Since 2019, a conversion of an occupied New York City rental building must proceed as a non-eviction plan, and it cannot take effect until a majority of the tenants in occupancy agree to buy.
We represent sponsors, owners, tenants’ associations, and individual tenants in conversions of rental buildings to cooperative or condominium ownership.
Conversions of occupied residential buildings in New York City are governed by General Business Law § 352-eeee and by the Martin Act’s offering plan requirements, administered by the Attorney General’s Real Estate Finance Bureau. The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 eliminated new eviction plans in the City: a plan submitted after the 2019 amendments must be a non-eviction plan, and it may not be amended to become an eviction plan.
The purchase threshold is the central hurdle. A non-eviction plan generally cannot be declared effective until written purchase agreements have been executed and delivered for at least 51 percent of the dwelling units, counting only bona fide tenants in occupancy on the date the Attorney General accepts the plan for filing. Buildings with five or fewer units are subject to a lower threshold and special rules. If a plan does not become effective within 15 months after acceptance, it is deemed abandoned, and a new plan for the property generally cannot be submitted for at least 12 months.
Tenants who do not buy keep significant protections. They cannot be evicted for failing to purchase, rent-regulated tenants remain rent-regulated, and eligible senior citizens and disabled persons who elect protected status receive additional protection. Outside the City, General Business Law § 352-eee applies in cities, towns, and villages in Nassau, Westchester, and Rockland Counties that have elected to adopt it, with its own thresholds and protections.
Our capabilities include:
- Feasibility review before a plan is drafted
- Offering plans and amendments filed with the Attorney General
- Tenant purchase campaigns and insider pricing
- Counsel to tenants’ associations negotiating terms
- Non-purchasing tenant and senior protections
- Rent-regulated unit compliance after conversion
- Sponsor obligations, unsold units, and transition to the board
Key rules under GBL § 352-eeee
| Plan type in NYC | Non-eviction plans only for plans submitted after the 2019 amendments |
|---|---|
| Purchase threshold | Generally 51% of units, by bona fide tenants in occupancy on the acceptance date |
| Small buildings | Five or fewer units: a 15% threshold and special occupancy rules |
| Exclusive purchase right | Tenants in occupancy: 90 days, then a six-month right to match a third-party contract |
| Plan lapse | Deemed abandoned if not effective within 15 months of acceptance |
| Resubmission | Generally no new plan for 12 months after abandonment |
Rights of non-purchasing tenants
No eviction for not buying
Eviction proceedings may not be brought for failure to purchase, though tenants remain subject to proceedings for nonpayment, illegal use, and similar breaches.
Rent regulation continues
Tenants in rent-stabilized or rent-controlled units remain under rent regulation.
No unconscionable increases
In units not subject to rent regulation, rents may not be raised to unconscionable levels to force a purchase.
Seniors and disabled persons
Eligible tenants who elect protected status on the Attorney General’s forms receive additional statutory protections.
Protection from harassment
Conduct that substantially interferes with tenants’ comfort or peace, including interruption of essential services, is unlawful and may be enjoined.
Key terms
- Conversion
- The transformation of a rental building into cooperative or condominium ownership under an offering plan.
- Sponsor
- The owner or developer offering the units or shares for sale under the plan.
- Offering plan
- The disclosure document a sponsor must file with the Attorney General before offering units for sale.
- Martin Act
- General Business Law Article 23-A, which regulates offerings of co-op and condominium interests in New York.
- GBL § 352-eeee
- The statute governing conversions of occupied residential buildings in New York City.
- GBL § 352-eee
- A parallel conversion statute that applies in Nassau, Westchester, and Rockland municipalities that adopt it.
- Non-eviction plan
- A plan under which tenants who do not buy may remain in occupancy and may not be evicted for failing to purchase.
- Eviction plan
- A plan permitting eviction of non-purchasers after a period; no longer available for new New York City plans.
- Bona fide tenant in occupancy
- A tenant lawfully living in the apartment as a residence, counted toward the purchase threshold.
- Acceptance for filing
- The Attorney General’s letter accepting the plan, which sets the date for counting tenants.
- Declaration of effectiveness
- The sponsor’s amendment declaring the plan effective once the threshold is met.
- Insider price
- The price offered to tenants in occupancy, usually below the price offered to outside purchasers.
- Eligible senior citizen
- A non-purchasing tenant aged 62 or older, and spouse, who elects protected status.
- Eligible disabled person
- A non-purchasing tenant with a qualifying permanent impairment, and spouse, who elects protected status.
- Unsold shares or units
- Units the sponsor still owns after conversion, often occupied by non-purchasing tenants.
Questions we hear most
Can a sponsor still evict tenants who do not buy?
Who counts toward the 51 percent?
Does a rent-stabilized tenant lose protection after conversion?
Does the Attorney General approve the price?
How long does a tenant have to decide whether to buy?
What does a tenants’ association negotiate?
What happens to units the sponsor cannot sell?
Can a plan be converted later into an eviction plan?
Does the conversion law apply to vacant buildings?
Is harassment during a conversion actionable?
Get in touch
Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.