Public-Private Partnerships Public-private partnerships and public land dispositions.
A public development deal is a negotiated contract and a public approval at the same time. The approvals set the timeline, and the agreements outlast them.
We represent developers, nonprofit sponsors, investors, and operators responding to public solicitations and negotiating development agreements, ground leases, and incentive packages with New York City and New York State entities.
Much of New York’s development happens on public land or with public partners. The New York City Economic Development Corporation (NYCEDC), the Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD), Empire State Development (ESD), and public authorities regularly solicit proposals to develop City or State property, usually through a request for proposals or a request for expressions of interest. The selected developer then negotiates a term sheet, a development agreement, and typically a long-term ground lease, with the public entity retaining ownership of the land and controlling use, affordability, design, and timing.
The approval path depends on who owns the land. A disposition of City-owned property, including a long-term lease, generally requires review under the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure (ULURP) under City Charter § 197-c, along with environmental review, and often a rezoning or special permit in the same application. State entities follow their own procedures; ESD, for example, can approve a general project plan under the Urban Development Corporation Act that may override local zoning after public hearings. A developer’s schedule and financing should be built around those approvals.
Public deals carry obligations that private deals do not. Development agreements commonly include construction milestones with reverter or termination rights, minority- and women-owned business enterprise (M/WBE) participation goals, local hiring and prevailing wage requirements where applicable, affordability covenants, and reporting. Incentives such as industrial development agency benefits and payments in lieu of taxes come with recapture provisions. The ground lease, the development agreement, and the regulatory agreements have to be read together, and financing terms should be negotiated with the lender’s requirements in mind.
Our capabilities include:
- Responses to NYCEDC, HPD, ESD, and public authority RFPs
- Term sheets and development agreements
- Ground leases from public entities and leasehold financing
- ULURP, land use, and environmental review coordination
- IDA benefits and PILOT agreements
- M/WBE, hiring, and wage requirement compliance planning
- Community benefits agreements
- Amendments, defaults, and restructurings of public development deals
Common public partners and processes
| NYCEDC | Solicits developers for City-owned commercial, industrial, and mixed-use sites and administers the City’s industrial development agency |
|---|---|
| HPD | Disposes of City-owned land for affordable housing, often with subsidy loans and regulatory agreements |
| ESD | The State’s economic development entity; may adopt general project plans for large projects |
| Public authorities | Entities such as the MTA, the Port Authority, and the Battery Park City Authority lease and develop their own property under their own rules |
| ULURP | The City’s public review process, involving community boards, borough presidents, the City Planning Commission, and the City Council |
| Industrial development agencies | Local public benefit corporations that grant tax benefits to qualifying projects |
Terms to focus on in a public ground lease
Term and rent
Long terms with fixed rent steps, periodic resets, or participation in revenue or sale proceeds.
Construction obligations
Commencement and completion deadlines, with extensions for delays outside the developer’s control.
Use and affordability restrictions
Permitted uses, affordability levels, and operating covenants that bind the developer and successors.
Transfer restrictions
Consent requirements for assignments, changes of control, and transfers of interests in the developer.
Leasehold financing
Lender protections such as notice and cure rights and a new-lease right after termination, which most lenders require.
Remedies
Termination, reverter, and step-in rights, and how they interact with lender protections.
From solicitation to closing
Respond to the solicitation
Assemble the team, review the RFP’s requirements and form documents, and present a financing plan and schedule.
Negotiate the term sheet
After designation, agree on price or rent, program, affordability, M/WBE goals, and milestones.
Obtain approvals
Complete ULURP or the applicable State process, environmental review, and any board approvals of the public entity.
Document the deal
Negotiate the development agreement, ground lease, regulatory agreements, and incentive agreements.
Close and perform
Close the land transaction and financing, then meet construction, reporting, and compliance obligations.
Key terms
- Public-private partnership (P3)
- A contractual arrangement in which a private party develops, finances, or operates property or infrastructure with a public entity.
- Request for proposals (RFP)
- A public solicitation inviting developers to submit proposals for a site or project.
- Designation
- A public entity’s selection of a developer to negotiate a project, before final approvals and documents.
- Development agreement
- The contract setting the developer’s obligations to design, finance, and build a project.
- Disposition
- A sale or lease of public property to a private party.
- ULURP
- The Uniform Land Use Review Procedure under City Charter § 197-c.
- General project plan
- An Empire State Development plan for a State project that can override local zoning.
- Ground lease
- A long-term lease of land under which the tenant builds and owns the improvements for the term.
- Reverter
- A right of the public entity to recover the property if the developer fails to meet conditions.
- PILOT
- A payment in lieu of taxes agreement replacing ordinary real property taxes for a period.
- Industrial development agency (IDA)
- A public benefit corporation that grants tax benefits to qualifying projects.
- M/WBE
- Minority- and women-owned business enterprises certified under City or State programs.
- Community benefits agreement
- An agreement committing a developer to benefits for the surrounding community, such as jobs, space, or funding.
- Design-build
- A delivery method in which one entity is responsible for both design and construction.
Questions we hear most
Does a long-term lease of City land require ULURP?
What is a general project plan?
Are M/WBE requirements mandatory in public development deals?
Can a public ground lease be financed?
How long does a public land deal take?
Can a developer assign its designation?
Are community benefits agreements legally required?
What alternative delivery methods are available on City projects?
Do IDA benefits come with conditions?
What happens if the developer misses a construction deadline?
Get in touch
Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.