Co-op and Condo Board Counsel Counsel to co-op and condominium boards.

Boards run buildings worth hundreds of millions of dollars with volunteer directors. We help them make decisions they can defend.

We serve as general counsel to cooperative and condominium boards in New York City, working with managing agents on the day-to-day legal work of running a building.

A co-op is a corporation governed by the Business Corporation Law, its bylaws, and the proprietary lease; a condominium is governed by the Condominium Act, Real Property Law Article 9-B, and its declaration and bylaws. New York courts review most board decisions under the business judgment rule recognized in Matter of Levandusky v. One Fifth Avenue Apartment Corp. (1990): a decision made in good faith, within the board’s authority, and for the building’s legitimate purposes is generally upheld.

That protection depends on process. Boards that follow their governing documents, document their reasons, avoid conflicts of interest, and treat shareholders and unit owners consistently are in the strongest position when a decision is challenged.

Our capabilities include:

  • Sales, refinances, and sublet applications
  • Alteration and renovation agreements
  • Arrears collection, co-op proceedings, and condo common charge liens
  • Amendments to bylaws, proprietary leases, declarations, and house rules
  • Access disputes with neighbors and RPAPL 881 licenses
  • Vendor, managing agent, and construction contracts
  • Local Law 97, facade, and other compliance obligations
  • Shareholder and unit owner disputes

Co-op and condo boards compared

Governing lawCo-op: Business Corporation Law and proprietary lease. Condo: Real Property Law Article 9-B, declaration, and bylaws.
SalesCo-op boards generally may approve or decline purchasers. Condo boards usually hold a right of first refusal, typically waived.
Collecting arrearsCo-op: proceedings under the proprietary lease, including summary proceedings. Condo: a lien for unpaid common charges that may be foreclosed.
Standard of reviewBoth: the business judgment rule for good-faith decisions within the board’s authority.

What we handle for boards

  • Applications

    Purchase, refinance, and sublet applications, recognition agreements, and consistent written policies.

  • Renovations

    Alteration agreements, insurance, deposits, and enforcement when work goes beyond what was approved.

  • Neighbors

    License agreements for access to adjoining property during construction, and RPAPL 881 petitions when owners cannot agree.

  • Finances

    Arrears, assessments, underlying mortgage and line-of-credit documents, and reserve planning.

  • Governance

    Elections, meetings, conflicts of interest, and amendments that require shareholder or unit owner votes.

Key terms

Proprietary lease
The lease that gives a co-op shareholder the right to occupy an apartment and sets the shareholder’s obligations.
Declaration
The recorded document that creates a condominium and defines its units and common elements.
Bylaws
The rules for how the co-op corporation or condominium is governed.
House rules
Building rules adopted by the board on day-to-day matters such as moves, pets, and renovations.
Business judgment rule
The standard under which courts generally defer to good-faith board decisions within the board’s authority.
Levandusky
The 1990 Court of Appeals decision applying the business judgment rule to co-op board decisions.
Right of first refusal
A condo board’s right to buy a unit on the same terms as a proposed sale.
Maintenance
A co-op shareholder’s monthly charge for building expenses, taxes, and debt service.
Common charges
A condo owner’s monthly share of the building’s common expenses.
Assessment
A special charge to shareholders or unit owners for a particular expense.
Flip tax
A transfer fee some co-ops charge on sales, set by the governing documents.
Alteration agreement
The contract governing a renovation, including plans, insurance, deposits, and work rules.
Recognition agreement
An agreement among a co-op, a lender, and a shareholder protecting the lender’s security interest in the shares.
RPAPL 881
The statute allowing a court to grant a license to enter a neighbor’s property for repairs or improvements.
Local Law 97
New York City’s building emissions law, which sets carbon limits for many large buildings.

Questions we hear most

Does a co-op board have to give a reason for rejecting a buyer?

Generally no. A co-op board may decline a purchaser without stating a reason, but it may not discriminate on a basis protected by federal, state, or New York City law. Consistent criteria and records protect the board.

Can a condo board reject a buyer?

Usually not outright. Most condominium declarations give the board a right of first refusal, which it may exercise by matching the price, rather than an approval right.

How are unpaid common charges collected in a condo?

Under the Condominium Act, unpaid common charges are a lien on the unit that can be foreclosed, subject to the priority rules in the statute and the bylaws.

What protects directors from personal liability?

The business judgment rule, the indemnification provisions in the governing documents, and directors and officers insurance. Directors who act in good faith within their authority are generally protected.

How often should our governing documents be updated?

When they no longer match how the building operates or current law. Amendments usually require a shareholder or unit owner vote, so we draft them with the vote threshold in mind.

Can the board restrict sublets?

Co-ops generally may restrict subletting under the proprietary lease and board policies, applied consistently. Condominiums have less power to restrict leasing unless the declaration or bylaws provide for it.

What should be in an alteration agreement?

Approved plans, the contractor’s insurance and licensing, work hours, deposits, the board’s right to stop work, and responsibility for damage to other apartments.

What if a neighboring owner needs access to our building for construction?

Most access is handled by a negotiated license agreement covering protection, insurance, monitoring, and fees. If the parties cannot agree, the owner may petition the court for a license under RPAPL 881.

Can a shareholder sue the board?

Yes, but courts generally defer to good-faith decisions within the board’s authority under the business judgment rule. Claims of bad faith, self-dealing, or discrimination are treated differently.

Do boards need their own counsel for each sale?

Many boards rely on counsel for transfer documents, recognition agreements, and unusual applications, while the managing agent handles routine packages.

Is there a deadline for a co-op board to decide on a purchase application?

Yes, for most New York City co-ops. A 2026 local law, enacted over a mayoral veto and in effect since late July 2026, generally requires the board to acknowledge an application within 15 days and to decide within 45 days after it is complete, with one 14-day extension. It does not require the board to give reasons for a rejection, and HPD enforces it.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content