Real Estate Litigation Real estate litigation for owners and tenants.

We represent property owners and tenants in Housing Court, Supreme Court, and before DHCR — from eviction and rent overcharge proceedings to board disputes and contracts that did not close.

Madison Law Firm PLLC brings the same care to contested property matters that we bring to the closing table, for owners and tenants alike.

New York City’s rent regulation system is among the most protective in the country, and the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 changed much of it: overcharge lookbacks, deregulation, improvement increases, eviction notice periods, and security deposits.

For owners, the cost of error can be treble damages and lost rent. For tenants, it can be a home. Both sides need counsel who knows the Rent Stabilization Law, the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law, and how DHCR and the courts actually apply them.

We represent owners and tenants. Which side we take depends on the facts and our client’s interests, and we tell clients candidly where they stand.

Our capabilities include:

  • Non-payment and holdover proceedings
  • Illegal lockout and emergency restoration
  • DHCR rent overcharge complaints and defense
  • Harassment claims and HP actions for repairs
  • Non-primary residence and owner-use proceedings
  • Co-op and condo board disputes
  • Specific performance and contract-of-sale disputes
  • Yellowstone injunctions for commercial tenants

Areas of focus

  • Eviction Proceedings

    Whether you need to recover possession or keep your home, Housing Court cases turn on notices, deadlines, and the regulatory status of the apartment.

    Learn more
  • Rent Overcharge and DHCR

    Rent-stabilized rents are set by a registered history, and errors in that history can cost owners treble damages or cost tenants years of excess rent.

    Learn more
  • Harassment and HP Actions

    When conditions go unrepaired or a tenant is pressured to leave, Housing Court can order repairs, impose penalties, and award damages.

    Learn more
  • Good Cause Eviction for Landlords

    Since April 2024, many New York City market-rate apartments can be recovered only for good cause, and large rent increases must be justified. Knowing which units are covered is the first step.

    Learn more
  • Rent Overcharge Defense for Owners

    An overcharge claim can reach back years and carry treble damages and fees. The defense is built on the registration history, the leases, and the documents behind every increase.

    Learn more
  • COPA for Building Owners

    The Community Opportunity to Purchase Act gives HPD-certified nonprofits a first chance to buy, and a right of first refusal, when certain distressed or HPD-regulated buildings are sold. Owners who may be covered should plan sales around it.

    Learn more
  • Loft Law and Mitchell-Lama

    Former industrial lofts and Mitchell-Lama developments each have their own statute, their own regulator, and rules that override ordinary landlord-tenant law.

    Learn more
  • DOB, HPD and OATH Violations

    Open violations cost money, block permits and sales, and can lead to vacate orders. The way to clear them depends on which agency issued them and what they require.

    Learn more
  • Certification of No Harassment (CONH)

    For covered New York City buildings, a renovation or demolition permit waits on a finding by HPD that tenants were not harassed. A denial can stop work on the building for years.

    Learn more
  • Co-op and Condo Disputes

    Board decisions get substantial deference in New York, but not unlimited deference. We represent shareholders, unit owners, and boards.

    Learn more
  • Commercial Lease Disputes

    Commercial tenants have fewer statutory protections than residential tenants, so the lease and the timing of each notice usually decide the outcome.

    Learn more
  • Yellowstone Injunctions

    When a commercial landlord serves a notice to cure, the tenant’s time to protect the lease is measured in days. A Yellowstone injunction stops the clock.

    Learn more
  • Contract Disputes and Specific Performance

    Failed closings turn on the contract’s terms and on what each side did when the deadline came. We represent buyers and sellers.

    Learn more
  • Title Claims and Quiet Title

    When someone else claims your property, a boundary, or a right of way — or a defect surfaces after closing — the remedy runs through the title policy, the courts, or both.

    Learn more
  • Partition Actions

    When co-owners can no longer agree on what to do with a property, any one of them can generally ask the court to divide it or sell it. The question is usually on what terms.

    Learn more
  • Foreclosure (Lenders and Borrowers)

    New York foreclosure is judicial, technical, and slow. Pre-suit notices, the statute of limitations, and the timing of a deficiency motion decide many cases before the merits are reached.

    Learn more
  • Construction Law

    Construction disputes usually turn on the contract and on deadlines in the Lien Law. Both deserve attention before the first shovel goes in the ground.

    Learn more
  • Appeals

    An appeal is decided on the record and the briefs, under deadlines that do not bend. The first decisions — whether to appeal and whether to seek a stay — are often made within days.

    Learn more
  • Fair Housing and Human Rights Claims

    A housing discrimination complaint can be filed with three different agencies or in court, under three overlapping laws. The New York City law is the broadest of them, and it is construed liberally in favor of those it protects.

    Learn more
  • ADA and Accessibility

    New York City storefronts draw a steady volume of accessibility suits. Both the landlord and the tenant can be named, and state and city law add damages that federal law does not.

    Learn more
  • Real Estate Bankruptcy and Creditors’ Rights

    A bankruptcy filing stops a holdover, a foreclosure, or an arrears case in its tracks. Federal deadlines then decide much of what happens to the lease, the loan, or the apartment.

    Learn more
  • Receiverships

    A receiver takes control of rents and operations while a case is pending. Whether one is appointed, and what that receiver may do, often shapes the outcome more than the merits.

    Learn more
  • Eminent Domain and Condemnation

    When a government or authority takes property, the owner has two questions: whether the taking can be stopped, and what it will be paid. The deadlines for each are short and unforgiving.

    Learn more
  • Deed Theft and Title Fraud

    A stranger can record a forged or fraudulently obtained deed against a home in a matter of minutes. Undoing it takes a court order, and the sooner the record is challenged, the fewer innocent buyers and lenders stand in the way.

    Learn more
  • Mechanic’s Liens

    A mechanic’s lien turns an unpaid construction invoice into a claim against the property itself. The Lien Law is strict on both sides: a lienor who misses a deadline loses the lien, and an owner who ignores one can find a sale or refinancing stalled.

    Learn more
  • Easements, Boundary and Adverse Possession Disputes

    A driveway everyone has used for decades, a fence a few feet off the line, a wall two buildings share. These disputes often surface at a sale or a renovation, and the outcome usually depends on the deeds, the survey, and the history.

    Learn more
  • Construction Defect Claims

    Leaks, failing facades, and mechanical systems that never worked as designed tend to emerge after the sponsor has sold out and the unit owners control the board. By then, several limitations periods may already be running.

    Learn more

What we handle

  • Eviction proceedings

    Non-payment and holdover proceedings for owners and tenants, illegal lockouts, constructive eviction, and stays of warrants.

  • DHCR proceedings

    Overcharge complaints and defense, failure-to-renew cases, rent reduction orders, MCI and IAI applications, petitions for administrative review, and Article 78 challenges.

  • Harassment and repairs

    HP actions, DHCR harassment complaints, warranty of habitability claims, and negotiated buyouts.

  • Primary residence and owner use

    Non-primary residence and owner-use proceedings, on either side, including the protections added in 2019 for long-term tenants.

  • Co-op and condo disputes

    Proprietary lease and bylaw disputes, board decisions, alterations, assessments, and Article 78 proceedings against boards.

  • Contracts and title

    Specific performance, deposit recovery, misrepresentation, quiet title, partition, and commercial lease disputes.

What the 2019 Housing Stability Act changed

  • Six-year overcharge lookback

    The lookback for overcharge claims was extended from four years to six, and treble damages and attorney’s fees apply to willful overcharges.

  • Luxury deregulation repealed

    High-rent and high-income deregulation were eliminated, so regulated apartments generally stay regulated regardless of rent level or tenant income.

  • Vacancy and longevity increases repealed

    Automatic vacancy and longevity increases were abolished; increases now follow the Rent Guidelines Board.

  • Improvement increases capped

    The 2019 law capped individual apartment improvement increases and limited major capital improvement increases. Since October 17, 2024, IAI increases are permanent again, capped at $30,000 — or $50,000 for qualifying vacant apartments with DHCR’s prior certification — over 15 years.

  • Notice requirements strengthened

    Rent demands must be written with 14 days’ notice, and longer notice of non-renewal is required for longer tenancies.

  • Security deposits limited

    Deposits are capped at one month’s rent and must be returned, with an itemized statement, within 14 days after the tenant leaves.

Where we appear

  • Housing Court

    The Housing Part of the Civil Court of the City of New York: non-payment and holdover proceedings, HP actions, and lockouts.

  • New York State Supreme Court

    Specific performance, Yellowstone injunctions, Article 78 proceedings, overcharge actions, and complex contract and fraud claims.

  • DHCR

    The state agency that administers rent stabilization and rent control: overcharge, harassment, MCI and IAI, and renewal proceedings.

Key terms

Housing Court
The Housing Part of the Civil Court of the City of New York, where most residential eviction cases and HP actions are heard.
Summary proceeding
The fast-track court case, governed by the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law, that an owner brings to recover possession of property.
RPAPL
The Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law, the New York statute that sets the rules for eviction cases, partition, quiet title, and other property actions.
Rent Stabilization Law
The New York City law, with the Rent Stabilization Code, that limits rent increases and gives tenants renewal rights in covered apartments.
HSTPA
The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, which rewrote much of New York’s rent regulation and eviction law.
DHCR
The New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal, the agency that administers rent stabilization and rent control.
Legal regulated rent
The maximum rent an owner may lawfully charge for a rent-stabilized apartment, built up from registered rents and lawful increases.
Rent Guidelines Board
The New York City board that sets the annual percentage increases allowed on renewal leases for rent-stabilized apartments.
Primary residence
The home a tenant actually lives in; a rent-stabilized tenant generally must occupy the apartment as a primary residence to keep its protections.
Warranty of habitability
The promise, implied into every residential lease by RPL § 235-b, that the apartment is fit to live in and free of conditions dangerous to health or safety.
Article 78 proceeding
A proceeding in Supreme Court under CPLR Article 78 to challenge a decision of a government agency, such as DHCR, or in some cases a co-op board.
Notice of pendency
A notice filed with the county clerk, also called a lis pendens, warning anyone dealing with the property that a lawsuit affects title to it.
Yellowstone injunction
A court order that pauses a commercial tenant’s cure period while the tenant disputes a landlord’s claim that the lease was breached.
Business judgment rule
The rule under which courts generally defer to co-op and condo board decisions made in good faith and within the board’s authority.
Good Cause Eviction Law
Real Property Law Article 6-A, which since April 20, 2024 has required owners of many non-regulated New York City apartments to show a statutory ground to evict or not renew.
COPA
The Community Opportunity to Purchase Act, Local Law 164 of 2026, signed on November 10, 2026 and taking effect on or about November 10, 2027, which gives HPD-certified nonprofits a first chance to buy certain distressed or HPD-regulated buildings offered for sale.

Questions we hear most

How do I know if my apartment is rent-stabilized?

Generally, an apartment is rent-stabilized if it is in a building of six or more units built before 1974, or in a building receiving certain tax benefits such as 421-a or J-51. You can request your apartment’s registered rent history from DHCR. We help clients confirm their status and evaluate whether the rent is lawful.

What is a rent overcharge, and what are the remedies?

An overcharge is rent above the legal regulated rent. Since 2019, the lookback is generally six years from the complaint. Remedies include refund of the overcharge, treble damages where the overcharge is willful, and attorney’s fees. Claims can be brought at DHCR or in court.

Can a landlord evict without going to court?

No. A landlord must obtain a judgment and a warrant of eviction through a court proceeding. Changing locks, removing belongings, or cutting off services to force a tenant out is unlawful; since 2019 it is a misdemeanor under RPAPL § 768, and RPAPL § 853 allows treble damages. A tenant who is locked out can seek emergency restoration.

What is an HP action?

An HP action is a Housing Court proceeding in which a tenant asks the court to order the landlord to make repairs, correct violations, or restore services. It is available to all tenants, regulated or not.

What is a Yellowstone injunction?

Named for First National Stores v. Yellowstone Shopping Center, 21 N.Y.2d 630 (1968), it is an order that tolls the cure period in a landlord’s notice to cure a commercial lease default, preserving the lease while the dispute is litigated. It must be sought before the cure period expires.

My landlord claims I don’t use my apartment as my primary residence. What can they do?

A landlord who believes a rent-stabilized apartment is not a tenant’s primary residence may bring a holdover proceeding, and must prove it. Courts look at tax returns, voter registration, driver’s license, utility use, and time spent there. These cases are fact-intensive and turn on preparation.

What is the difference between rent control and rent stabilization?

Rent control covers a small and shrinking number of apartments in older buildings occupied by the same tenant or a qualifying successor since before July 1, 1971. Rent stabilization covers roughly a million apartments. DHCR administers both.

Do you represent landlords as well as tenants?

Yes. We represent owners and tenants in every type of proceeding described on this page, and we check for conflicts before taking any matter.

I received court papers. How long do I have to respond?

It depends on the type of proceeding and how the papers were served, so read the notice of petition carefully and note the date it gives. In many residential cases the first step is appearing in court or filing an answer by a stated date. If you miss it, a default judgment can be entered against you, so contact counsel promptly.

Can a tenant get a free lawyer in New York City Housing Court?

New York City’s Right to Counsel program provides free legal representation to income-eligible tenants in many eviction proceedings, and brief advice to others. Availability depends on income and case type. Owners do not have a comparable program, so they should retain counsel early.

What is the difference between Housing Court and Supreme Court?

Housing Court handles summary proceedings over possession and rent, along with HP actions for repairs. Supreme Court is the general trial court and hears larger claims, injunctions, Article 78 proceedings, specific performance, and many overcharge and board cases. Some disputes could be brought in either, and the choice affects speed, cost, and remedies.

How long does a typical eviction case take?

Timing varies widely with the type of case, the court’s calendar, whether the tenant has counsel, and whether the tenant raises defenses or seeks a stay. Many cases resolve by stipulation at an early stage, while contested holdovers can take considerably longer. We give clients a realistic sense of the timeline once we see the papers.

Can a landlord charge late fees?

Yes, within limits. Since 2019, Real Property Law § 238-a generally caps a residential late fee at $50 or five percent of the monthly rent, whichever is less, and the rent must be at least five days late. Late fees and other non-rent charges generally cannot be recovered in a non-payment proceeding.

I received a notice to cure. What should I do?

A notice to cure states a claimed lease violation and gives a deadline to correct it before the owner may terminate the tenancy. Read the deadline carefully, gather evidence about the claimed violation, and get advice before the cure period ends. Whether to cure, dispute, or both depends on the claim and the type of tenancy.

Does rent stabilization end when the rent gets high enough?

Generally, no longer. The 2019 law repealed high-rent and high-income deregulation, so most apartments that were stabilized on or after June 14, 2019 stay stabilized regardless of rent level. Whether an apartment was lawfully deregulated before then is a separate question that often turns on its rent history.

What evidence should I gather before calling a lawyer?

Gather your lease and renewals, rent ledgers or payment records, any notices you sent or received, photos of conditions, and correspondence with the other side. For rent-stabilized apartments, a DHCR rent history is especially useful. Bring court papers with any return date clearly noted.

Can I recover my attorney’s fees?

Sometimes. Many residential leases contain a fee clause, and RPL § 234 makes a landlord’s fee clause reciprocal for tenants. Statutes such as the overcharge provisions of the Rent Stabilization Law also allow fee awards. Whether fees are recoverable depends on the lease, the claim, and who prevails.

Do you handle commercial landlord-tenant disputes?

Yes. We handle commercial lease disputes, including non-payment and holdover proceedings, Yellowstone injunctions, and lease-default disputes. Commercial tenancies are not rent-regulated and are governed mostly by the lease itself, so the lease language usually decides the case.

What happens to my case if the building is sold?

A sale generally does not end an existing lease or a pending proceeding; the new owner usually steps into the prior owner’s position. Rent-stabilized protections stay with the apartment. Records of rent history and repairs can become harder to obtain after a sale, so secure them early.

Is mediation available in landlord-tenant disputes?

Yes. Many disputes are resolved through negotiated stipulations in Housing Court, and court-connected mediation programs are available in some cases. Co-op and condo disputes and contract disputes can also be mediated privately. We look for a resolution before trial when one serves the client’s interests.
Contact

Tell us about your dispute

Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.

Send inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content