Air Rights and Development Rights Buying, selling, and using air rights and development rights.
Unused floor area can be one of a building’s most valuable assets. Transferring it is a zoning question, a title question, and a contract question at once.
We represent owners, developers, co-op and condominium boards, religious and nonprofit institutions, and lenders in transfers of development rights in New York City.
Under the New York City Zoning Resolution, a building’s permitted floor area is calculated on its zoning lot. Owners of contiguous lots can merge them into a single zoning lot, which allows unused floor area on one lot to be used by a building on another. The transfer is usually documented in a zoning lot development agreement between the owners, implemented by a declaration of zoning lot restrictions that is recorded against the merged lots. Every party in interest, including mortgagees, must generally sign the declaration or a waiver.
Landmarks and special districts follow their own rules. The Zoning Resolution allows the owner of a designated landmark to transfer unused floor area to qualifying receiving sites that are not contiguous in some circumstances, generally with City Planning Commission approval. Special districts, including East Midtown and West Chelsea, have their own transfer mechanisms, some tied to contributions to public improvements or to the preservation of a specific resource.
A transfer is permanent and binds future owners of both lots. The selling owner gives up the ability to build into that floor area, often accepts restrictions on future construction, and may take on continuing obligations about light, air, and access. We negotiate those terms, confirm the zoning calculations with the client’s architect and zoning counsel, and coordinate the title and recording work so the transfer survives a later sale or financing.
Our capabilities include:
- Zoning lot development agreements
- Declarations of zoning lot restrictions and waivers
- Landmark and special district transfers
- Light and air easements and no-build covenants
- Co-op and condominium board approvals for sales of building rights
- Lender consents and subordination
- Title insurance, recording, and transfer tax filings
Ways to move development rights
Zoning lot merger
Contiguous lots are combined into one zoning lot so that floor area can be distributed among them, documented by a zoning lot development agreement and a recorded declaration.
Landmark transfer
The owner of a designated landmark transfers unused floor area to an eligible receiving site under the Zoning Resolution, generally with City Planning Commission approval.
Special district transfer
Certain special districts permit transfers within the district, sometimes conditioned on a contribution to a public fund or a preservation commitment.
Light and air easement
A negotiated, recorded agreement that restricts construction on one lot to protect the windows, views, or light of a neighboring building; it is a private covenant rather than a zoning transfer.
A typical transfer
Confirm what is available
The client’s architect or zoning counsel calculates the unused floor area and any zoning limits on the receiving building.
Negotiate the agreement
Price, the amount of floor area, restrictions on the selling lot, cooperation covenants, indemnities, and the allocation of future zoning changes.
Clear title
The title company identifies every party in interest who must sign the declaration or a waiver, including mortgagees and certain tenants.
Obtain approvals
Co-op shareholder or condominium owner votes, lender consents, and any required City Planning Commission action.
Close and record
The agreement or a memorandum and the declaration are recorded, and transfer tax returns are filed.
Key terms
- Air rights
- The informal name for unused development rights above an existing building.
- Development rights
- The floor area a lot may still use under zoning, which may be transferred in some circumstances.
- Floor area ratio (FAR)
- The ratio of permitted floor area to lot area set by zoning.
- Zoning lot
- The parcel used to calculate floor area and other zoning controls, which may include more than one tax lot.
- Zoning lot merger
- The combination of contiguous lots into a single zoning lot.
- Zoning lot development agreement (ZLDA)
- The contract between owners governing the transfer of floor area and their continuing obligations.
- Declaration of zoning lot restrictions
- The recorded instrument that establishes the merged zoning lot.
- Party in interest
- A person with an interest in a lot, such as an owner or mortgagee, who generally must sign the declaration or a waiver.
- Landmark transfer
- A transfer of unused floor area from a designated landmark to an eligible receiving site.
- Granting site
- The lot that transfers its unused floor area.
- Receiving site
- The lot whose building uses the transferred floor area.
- Light and air easement
- A private, recorded restriction protecting light, air, or views across a neighboring lot.
- No-build covenant
- A promise not to construct above a set height or within a set area.
- City Planning Commission
- The City body that reviews special permits and authorizations under the Zoning Resolution.
Questions we hear most
Can a co-op or condo sell its air rights?
Do the lots have to be next to each other?
How are air rights valued?
Is a sale of development rights subject to transfer tax?
Does a transfer affect the selling building’s future plans?
What happens if zoning changes after the transfer?
Do tenants have to consent?
Can a church or nonprofit sell its development rights?
Should the transaction be insured?
How long does a transfer take?
Get in touch
Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.