Multifamily and Rent-Stabilized Buildings Buying and selling multifamily buildings with rent-stabilized units.
In a regulated building, the rent roll is a legal document before it is a financial one. Value depends on whether each rent can be defended.
We represent buyers, sellers, lenders, and joint venture investors in the acquisition, sale, and financing of New York City multifamily buildings with rent-stabilized and rent-controlled apartments.
The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 changed the economics of regulated housing. It ended high-rent vacancy deregulation and the statutory vacancy increase, made rent stabilization permanent, capped Major Capital Improvement increases, and lengthened the period over which overcharge claims are examined. Apartments that were stabilized when the law took effect on June 14, 2019 generally remain stabilized, whatever the rent. A business plan built on deregulating units or on large renovation increases needs to be tested against current law before the contract is signed.
The DHCR rent history is the starting point. Each stabilized apartment’s registered rents, the gaps in registration, prior deregulation claims, preferential rents, and any IAI or MCI increases determine the legal rent a buyer inherits. Overcharge claims are generally examined over a six-year lookback, and longer where there is evidence of a fraudulent scheme to deregulate, and a willful overcharge can carry treble damages. An owner who buys the building generally takes on that exposure, so diligence, contract representations, and indemnities have to address it.
Regulated status is only part of the review. Market-rate units in the building may be covered by the Good Cause Eviction Law. Buildings receiving or formerly receiving J-51 or 421-a benefits carry stabilization obligations of their own. HPD violations, Alternative Enforcement Program status, and Local Law 97 exposure affect the budget. And the City’s Community Opportunity to Purchase Act, Local Law 164 of 2026, signed on November 10, 2026 and taking effect on or about November 10, 2027, will require the owner of a covered building to notify HPD and qualified nonprofit buyers before taking any action to sell.
Our capabilities include:
- DHCR rent history and registration review, apartment by apartment
- Overcharge, deregulation, and preferential rent exposure analysis
- IAI and MCI documentation review
- J-51, 421-a, and HPD regulatory agreement diligence
- Tenant estoppels and rent roll certifications
- Contract representations, indemnities, escrows, and holdbacks
- HPD violation, AEP, and Local Law 97 review
- COPA and Good Cause Eviction planning for sellers and buyers
What the 2019 and 2024 rent laws changed
| Vacancy deregulation | Repealed in 2019. Apartments stabilized as of June 14, 2019 generally stay stabilized regardless of rent. |
|---|---|
| Vacancy increase | The statutory vacancy bonus was eliminated; renewal increases follow the Rent Guidelines Board. |
| Preferential rents | Generally, a tenant’s preferential rent remains the basis for renewal increases for the rest of that tenancy. |
| Major Capital Improvements | Increases are capped annually in New York City and are temporary, ending after 30 years. |
| Individual Apartment Improvements, first tier | Since October 17, 2024, up to $30,000 of improvement costs, recovered at 1/168 or 1/180 of the cost per month depending on building size; the increase is permanent. |
| Individual Apartment Improvements, second tier | Up to $50,000 for qualifying vacant apartments, including those vacant after at least 25 years of continuous occupancy, with DHCR’s prior certification. |
| Overcharge lookback | Generally six years, longer where a fraudulent scheme to deregulate is shown; treble damages for willful overcharges. |
Buyer diligence on a regulated building
Pull the records
Obtain DHCR registration histories for every unit, the building’s MCI and IAI files, and any DHCR orders, including rent reduction orders.
Reconcile the rent roll
Compare the seller’s rent roll and leases with the registrations, flag unregistered years, deregulation claims, and preferential rents, and identify units with litigation.
Check the benefits and agreements
Confirm J-51 and 421-a status, any HPD regulatory agreement, and whether those obligations bind the buyer.
Review the building
Search HPD and DOB violations, AEP status, Local Law 97 reports, and open permits.
Allocate the risk
Negotiate representations on rents and registrations, survival periods, indemnities, and escrows or price adjustments for identified exposure.
Key terms
- Rent stabilization
- New York’s system of regulated rents and renewal rights covering many apartments in buildings of six or more units built before 1974, and units subject to tax benefit programs.
- HSTPA
- The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, which ended vacancy deregulation and tightened the rules for rent increases and overcharges.
- DHCR
- The New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal, which administers rent stabilization and keeps each apartment’s registration history.
- Annual registration
- The yearly filing of each stabilized apartment’s rent with DHCR; gaps in registration can limit the rent an owner may collect.
- Legal regulated rent
- The maximum rent DHCR’s rules allow for a stabilized apartment, built up from the registration history and lawful increases.
- Preferential rent
- A rent below the legal regulated rent; generally it remains the basis for renewals for the rest of the tenancy.
- Overcharge
- Rent collected above the legal regulated rent; a tenant may recover it, with treble damages if the overcharge was willful.
- Lookback period
- The period of rent history examined in an overcharge case, generally six years, longer where fraud is shown.
- Individual Apartment Improvement (IAI)
- Work inside an apartment that can support a rent increase; since October 17, 2024, subject to two tiers capped at $30,000 and $50,000.
- Major Capital Improvement (MCI)
- A building-wide improvement that can support a capped, temporary rent increase for stabilized tenants.
- J-51
- A tax abatement and exemption for renovation of existing buildings; units in buildings receiving it are generally subject to rent stabilization during the benefit.
- 421-a
- A former tax exemption for new construction; many 421-a buildings must keep some or all units stabilized for a set period.
- Tenant estoppel
- A tenant’s signed statement of the rent, deposit, and lease terms, used to confirm the rent roll; residential tenants often decline to sign them.
- Alternative Enforcement Program (AEP)
- An HPD program for buildings with serious and numerous housing code violations, which can require repairs and impose fees.
- Good Cause Eviction Law
- Real Property Law Article 6-A, which since April 20, 2024 has limited evictions and non-renewals and set a rent increase standard for many non-regulated apartments.
- COPA
- The Community Opportunity to Purchase Act, Local Law 164 of 2026, passed by the City Council on October 22, 2026 and signed by the Mayor on November 10, 2026; it takes effect one year after enactment, on or about November 10, 2027.
Questions we hear most
Can I rely on the seller’s rent roll?
Does a buyer inherit overcharge liability?
Can an apartment still be deregulated?
How does COPA affect a sale?
Will residential tenants sign estoppels?
What does a typical rent representation cover?
How do IAIs affect a renovation budget?
Does Good Cause Eviction apply to the market-rate units in a mixed building?
What should a buyer check if the building had J-51 or 421-a?
Do HPD violations transfer with the building?
Get in touch
Tell us about your matter — real estate, leasing, a dispute, estate planning, or a billing claim. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.