Two- to Four-Family Home Purchases Buying a two- to four-family home.
A small multifamily house can be a home and a rental business at once. Buyers need to know which tenant laws come with it and what the building is legally allowed to be.
We represent owner-occupants and small investors buying two-, three-, and four-family homes in New York City and the surrounding counties, including purchases with tenants in place.
Small multifamily houses are a common first investment in New York City: the buyer lives in one unit and the rent from the others helps carry the mortgage. The legal work starts with the existing tenancies. A buyer should see every lease, the rent actually paid, any arrears, and the security deposits, and the contract should state which units will be delivered vacant and which are sold subject to named tenants. Tenant estoppel certificates confirm the rent, the deposit, and the absence of side agreements, but tenants generally have no obligation to sign one unless their lease requires it, so the seller’s representations matter as well.
Good Cause Eviction usually turns on who owns the building. In New York City, the State’s Good Cause Eviction Law has applied since April 20, 2024 without any local opt-in; municipalities elsewhere must opt in. It does not apply to an owner-occupied building with ten or fewer units, or to a small landlord who owns ten or fewer units in New York State, counting each individual owner behind an LLC. A buyer who will live in the house is therefore usually outside the law, while an investor who already owns other rental property may be inside it. For covered units, the owner needs a statutory ground to evict or decline to renew, and an increase above the local rent standard, currently 8.38% in New York City, is presumed unreasonable.
Rent stabilization generally does not apply to buildings with fewer than six units, but there are exceptions, including units that receive certain tax benefits and long-term tenants still covered by rent control in pre-1947 buildings of three or more units. Residential tenancies are generally subject to the 2019 rules limiting security deposits to one month’s rent and requiring the landlord to return the deposit, with an itemized statement of any deductions, within 14 days after the tenant leaves. A three- or four-family house is also a multiple dwelling, which brings HPD registration and Housing Maintenance Code obligations, and renting a whole apartment in it for fewer than 30 days is generally prohibited.
Our capabilities include:
- Contracts for two-, three-, and four-family homes
- Lease, rent roll, arrears, and security deposit review
- Tenant estoppel certificates and seller representations
- Good Cause Eviction and rent regulation analysis
- Certificate of occupancy and illegal unit diligence
- Owner-occupant financing and lender coordination
- Delivery of vacant units and tenant transition planning
- Post-closing landlord compliance for new owners
How the rules change with the number of units
| Rent stabilization | Generally not applicable to buildings of fewer than six units, subject to exceptions for tax-benefit units and certain buildings |
|---|---|
| Rent control | Possible in a pre-1947 building of three or more units with a tenant in continuous occupancy since before July 1, 1971 |
| Good Cause Eviction | Not applicable if the owner lives in the building (ten or fewer units) or is a small landlord with ten or fewer units statewide |
| Multiple dwelling status | Three- and four-family houses are multiple dwellings under State law; two-family houses are not |
| HPD registration | Required for three- and four-family houses, and for two-family houses where the owner does not live |
| City transfer tax (seller) | 1% up to $500,000 and 1.425% above for two- and three-family houses; 1.425% up to $500,000 and 2.625% above for four or more units |
| Short-term rentals | Stays under 30 days generally require the host to be present, two guests at most, and OSE registration; whole-unit rentals are generally prohibited |
Buying with tenants in place
Collect the tenancy documents
Obtain every lease and renewal, the rent ledger, deposit records, and any notices or court cases involving the tenants.
Determine regulatory status
Confirm whether any unit is stabilized or controlled and whether Good Cause will apply to you as the new owner.
Draft the contract terms
Specify vacant and occupied units, rent and arrears representations, the transfer of security deposits, and a remedy if a tenant does not vacate.
Request estoppels
Ask tenants to confirm their rent, deposit, and lease terms in writing, and rely on seller representations where they will not sign.
Transfer at closing
Receive the deposits with a credit, prorate the rents, and send tenants written notice of the new owner and where to pay rent.
Legal units, basements, and financing
Count the legal units
Compare the certificate of occupancy with the house. An extra apartment in the basement or attic that is not on the certificate is generally illegal and cannot be relied on for income.
Basement legalization pilot
Local Law 126 of 2024 created a pilot for existing basement and cellar apartments in one- and two-family homes in certain community districts, for units that existed before April 20, 2024, outside flood-prone areas. Implementing rules were proposed in November 2025, and the City had not opened applications as of this writing, so buyers should confirm the program’s status before relying on it.
Owner-occupant loans
Agency and FHA programs for owner-occupied two- to four-unit homes can allow smaller down payments than investor loans and may count rental income, but they generally require the buyer to move in within a set period and live there for at least a year.
Appraisal and unit count
Lenders and appraisers generally value only legal units, so an illegal unit can reduce the loan amount and the property’s value.
Key terms
- Owner-occupant
- A buyer who lives in one unit of the building, which affects financing terms and exemptions such as Good Cause Eviction.
- Good Cause Eviction Law
- Real Property Law Article 6-A, which limits evictions and rent increases for covered unregulated apartments in New York City and opt-in municipalities.
- Small landlord
- Under Good Cause Eviction, an owner of no more than ten units in New York State; for an entity, each individual owner must meet the limit.
- Local rent standard
- Under Good Cause Eviction, inflation plus 5%, capped at 10%; increases above it are presumed unreasonable. It is 8.38% in New York City for 2026.
- Rent roll
- A schedule of units, tenants, rents, lease dates, and deposits, usually supplied by the seller.
- Tenant estoppel certificate
- A tenant’s signed statement confirming lease terms, rent, deposit, and the absence of defaults or side agreements.
- Security deposit
- Money held to secure the tenant’s obligations, limited to one month’s rent and returnable within 14 days after move-out with an itemized statement.
- Delivery vacant
- A contract term requiring the seller to deliver a unit free of occupants at closing.
- Holdover tenant
- A tenant who remains after the lease or right to occupy has ended.
- Multiple dwelling
- A building occupied as the residence of three or more families living independently, regulated under the Multiple Dwelling Law.
- Illegal unit
- An apartment not authorized by the certificate of occupancy, such as many basement and cellar apartments.
- Basement legalization pilot
- A program under Local Law 126 of 2024 for legalizing existing basement and cellar units in one- and two-family homes in certain community districts.
- Proration
- The division of rent, taxes, and charges between seller and buyer as of the closing date.
- Non-renewal notice
- Advance written notice, of 30, 60, or 90 days depending on the length of the tenancy, required before declining to renew or raising rent by 5% or more.
Questions we hear most
Does Good Cause Eviction apply if I live in my three-family house?
How much security deposit can I collect from my tenants?
Can the seller deliver the house vacant?
Can I rent out the basement apartment?
Do I have to honor the existing leases?
What notice do I need to raise the rent on a market-rate tenant?
Is a four-family house taxed differently from a three-family house?
Does the City’s Community Opportunity to Purchase Act affect small buildings?
Can I run an Airbnb in the extra unit?
Do lead paint rules apply to a small rental house?
Get in touch
Tell us about the property and your timing. Initial consultations are complimentary, and residential closings are quoted at a flat fee.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.