Yellowstone Injunctions Yellowstone injunctions and notices to cure.

When a commercial landlord serves a notice to cure, the tenant’s time to protect the lease is measured in days. A Yellowstone injunction stops the clock.

A Yellowstone injunction, named for First National Stores v. Yellowstone Shopping Center (1968), tolls the cure period in a commercial lease so the tenant can contest an alleged default without risking termination of the lease.

New York courts generally grant a Yellowstone injunction when the tenant shows that it holds a commercial lease, that it received a notice of default, a notice to cure, or a threat of termination, that it applied for the injunction before the lease was terminated and before the cure period ran out, and that it is prepared and able to cure the alleged default by means short of vacating the premises.

Timing is everything. Once the cure period expires and the landlord terminates the lease, a court cannot revive it. Tenants who receive a notice to cure should contact counsel immediately, not at the end of the cure period. Courts commonly condition relief on payment of ongoing rent or use and occupancy, and may require an undertaking.

Commercial leases sometimes contain a waiver of the right to seek declaratory relief or a Yellowstone injunction. The Court of Appeals enforced such a waiver between sophisticated commercial parties in 159 MP Corp. v. Redbridge Bedford, LLC (2019), so the lease language matters.

Our capabilities include:

  • Review of notices of default and notices to cure
  • Emergency Yellowstone applications and temporary restraining orders
  • Declaratory judgment actions on the alleged default
  • Negotiated cures and lease amendments
  • Landlord-side notices drafted to withstand challenge
  • Defense of Yellowstone applications for owners

The four elements

  • A commercial lease

    The tenant holds a commercial lease. Residential tenants have separate statutory protections.

  • Notice of default

    The tenant received a notice of default, a notice to cure, or a threat of termination.

  • Timely application

    The tenant moved for relief before the lease was terminated and before the cure period expired.

  • Ability to cure

    The tenant is prepared and able to cure the alleged default by means short of vacating the premises.

What to do after a notice to cure

  1. Read the deadline

    Calculate the cure period under the lease’s notice provisions, including how and when notice is deemed given.

  2. Gather the lease

    Review the default, cure, waiver, and attorney’s fee provisions.

  3. Decide quickly

    Cure, negotiate, or file for a Yellowstone injunction before the period ends.

  4. Keep paying

    Continue paying rent or use and occupancy while the dispute is pending.

Key terms

Yellowstone injunction
A court order tolling a commercial lease’s cure period while the tenant contests an alleged default.
First National Stores v. Yellowstone
The 1968 Court of Appeals case that gives the injunction its name.
Notice to cure
A landlord’s notice identifying a default and the time the tenant has to correct it.
Notice of termination
A notice ending the lease after the cure period expires without a cure.
Conditional limitation
A lease clause under which the lease ends automatically on notice after an uncured default.
Cure period
The time the lease gives the tenant to correct a default after notice.
Tolling
Pausing a deadline, such as a cure period, while a dispute is decided.
Temporary restraining order
Short-term court relief that holds the situation in place until the injunction motion is heard.
Undertaking
A bond or other security a court may require as a condition of injunctive relief.
Use and occupancy
Payment for the tenant’s continued use of the space while a dispute is pending.
Declaratory judgment
A court ruling defining the parties’ rights, such as whether a default occurred.
Yellowstone waiver
A lease provision waiving the tenant’s right to seek declaratory or Yellowstone relief.

Questions we hear most

Can I get a Yellowstone injunction after the cure period has expired?

Generally no. Once the cure period ends and the landlord terminates the lease, a court cannot revive it. The application must be made before the cure period runs out.

Does a Yellowstone injunction apply to nonpayment of rent?

Usually not. Nonpayment disputes generally proceed in a summary nonpayment proceeding, and tenants can typically avoid eviction by paying. Yellowstone relief is aimed at non-monetary defaults such as alterations, use, insurance, or repair obligations.

Can my lease waive Yellowstone relief?

Yes, in some cases. The Court of Appeals enforced a waiver between sophisticated commercial parties in 159 MP Corp. v. Redbridge Bedford (2019). Review the lease before relying on Yellowstone relief.

I represent a landlord. How do I make a notice to cure hold up?

Follow the lease’s notice provisions exactly, describe the default specifically, give the full cure period, and keep proof of service. Defective notices are a common ground for tenant relief.

How fast can a Yellowstone application be heard?

A tenant can seek a temporary restraining order on the day it files, which preserves the lease until the injunction motion is heard. That is why the application should be filed well before the cure period ends.

What defaults are typical in Yellowstone cases?

Unapproved alterations, use clause violations, insurance lapses, failure to make repairs, unauthorized sublets or assignments, and building code violations.

Will I have to post a bond?

Courts may require an undertaking and commonly require continued payment of rent or use and occupancy as a condition of relief. The amount depends on the court and the facts.

Does a Yellowstone injunction decide who is right?

No. It preserves the lease while the court decides whether a default occurred. The underlying dispute is resolved later in the action.

What does it mean that the tenant must be able to cure?

The tenant must show it is prepared and able to fix the alleged default if the court finds one, without giving up the premises.

Can a landlord still bring a holdover proceeding?

If the lease has not terminated because the cure period was tolled, a holdover based on that default generally cannot proceed while the injunction is in place.
Contact

Tell us about your dispute

Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.

Send inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content