Deed theft and title fraud.
A stranger can record a forged or fraudulently obtained deed against a home in a matter of minutes. Undoing it takes a court order, and the sooner the record is challenged, the fewer innocent buyers and lenders stand in the way.
We represent homeowners, heirs, estates, and owners of investment and mixed-use property whose title has been stolen or clouded, and purchasers and lenders caught in the middle of a disputed transfer.
The Heirs Property Protection and Deed Theft Prevention Act of 2024, enacted as part of the 2024–25 State budget and effective July 19, 2024, made deed theft a form of grand larceny regardless of the property’s value. Stealing residential property occupied as a home by at least one person, a home owned by an elderly, incompetent, incapacitated, or physically disabled person, or three or more residential properties is grand larceny in the first degree; one residential property, a mixed-use property with at least one residential unit, or two or more commercial properties is second degree; and one commercial property is third degree. A prosecution must generally be commenced within five years after the crime or within two years after the owner discovers it, whichever is later, and the Attorney General has concurrent authority with the district attorneys to prosecute. An earlier law, effective in December 2023, allows prosecutors to seek a pause of related eviction and title proceedings and allows a homeowner who shows evidence of deed theft to seek a stay of a housing court eviction.
The criminal case does not return the property by itself. Title is restored in a civil action, usually an action to quiet title under RPAPL Article 15 combined with a claim to cancel the deed and any mortgage that rests on it, backed by a notice of pendency so that no later buyer or lender can claim to have taken without notice. New York distinguishes between a forged deed, which is void from the start and passes nothing even to a good-faith purchaser, and a deed the true owner signed but was tricked into signing, which is voidable and may leave a bona fide purchaser or lender for value protected. The Court of Appeals has held that the six-year fraud limitations period does not bar a claim to cancel a forged deed; claims based on a fraudulently induced deed remain subject to it.
The 2024 law also changed partition of heirs property under RPAPL § 993. A partition action concerning heirs property may not be started by someone who bought or otherwise acquired a share other than by inheritance, and when a co-tenant receives a bona fide offer from an outsider, the co-tenants who inherited their interests have a right to buy the share on the same terms, with first priority to a co-tenant who lives in the property as a primary residence. The same law authorized transfer-on-death deeds under Real Property Law § 424, which must be witnessed by two witnesses, acknowledged, and recorded before the owner’s death. A separate bill that would add a private right of action for deed theft as RPAPL § 891, S7721-A and A8863-A, remains pending and has not been enacted.
Our capabilities include:
- Actions to quiet title and cancel forged or fraudulent deeds and mortgages
- Notices of pendency and emergency relief to stop a further transfer
- Defense of eviction and ejectment proceedings brought by a purported new owner
- Coordination with the Attorney General, district attorneys, and the Sheriff
- Title insurance claims and disputes with lenders and title companies
- Heirs property partition actions and rights of first refusal
- Estate and family title disputes involving recorded deeds
- Owner monitoring through the City Register’s notification program
Deed theft under the 2024 law
| Grand larceny, first degree | Residential property occupied as a home by at least one person; a home owned by an elderly, incompetent, incapacitated, or physically disabled person; or three or more residential properties |
|---|---|
| Grand larceny, second degree | One residential property, one mixed-use property with at least one residential unit, or two or more commercial properties |
| Grand larceny, third degree | One commercial property, regardless of value |
| Time to prosecute | Five years after the crime or two years after the owner discovers it, whichever is later |
| Who may prosecute | District attorneys, and the Attorney General with concurrent authority |
| Effective date | July 19, 2024 |
If a deed has been recorded against your property
Pull the record
Obtain certified copies of the recorded deed and any mortgage from ACRIS, or from the Richmond County Clerk for Staten Island property.
Report it
Report the fraud to the Sheriff’s Office and the district attorney for the borough where the property is located.
Lock the title
File an action and a notice of pendency so that later buyers and lenders take subject to your claim.
Protect possession
If a purported owner starts an eviction or ejectment case, raise the deed theft and seek a stay.
Clear the record
Obtain a judgment cancelling the deed and any dependent mortgage and record it with the City Register or County Clerk.
Civil remedies
Quiet title
An action under RPAPL Article 15 to determine who holds title and to bar adverse claims.
Cancellation
A judgment declaring a forged deed void, or rescinding a fraudulently induced deed, and directing the recording officer to mark the record.
Notice of pendency
A filing under CPLR Article 65 that gives notice of the claim to anyone who later deals with the property.
Damages
Claims against the wrongdoers and, depending on the facts, others who participated in the transfer.
Key terms
- Deed theft
- The taking or transfer of title to real property without the owner’s knowledge or consent, now a form of grand larceny in New York.
- Forged deed
- A deed bearing a signature the owner did not make; void from the start and incapable of passing title.
- Fraudulently induced deed
- A deed the owner actually signed because of a misrepresentation; voidable rather than void.
- Void ab initio
- Invalid from the outset, so that no one can acquire rights through the instrument.
- Bona fide purchaser
- A buyer for value without notice of another’s claim, who may be protected against a voidable but not a void deed.
- Quiet title action
- An action under RPAPL Article 15 to determine claims to real property and remove clouds on title.
- Notice of pendency
- A filing under CPLR Article 65, also called a lis pendens, that gives constructive notice of a claim affecting title.
- ACRIS
- The City Register’s Automated City Register Information System for recorded documents in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, and Queens.
- Notice of Recorded Document program
- The New York City Department of Finance program that notifies registered owners when documents are recorded against their property.
- City Register
- The Department of Finance office that records deeds and mortgages in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, and Queens.
- Heirs property
- Property held by co-tenants that meets the RPAPL § 993 definition, generally where a significant share passed by inheritance among relatives.
- Right of first refusal
- The right of inheriting co-tenants of heirs property to match a bona fide outside offer for a co-tenant’s share.
- Transfer-on-death deed
- A deed under Real Property Law § 424, effective July 19, 2024, that passes property to a named beneficiary at the owner’s death.
- Title insurance
- A policy insuring an owner or lender against loss from defects in title, subject to its exclusions and conditions.
Questions we hear most
How do I find out whether someone has recorded a deed against my property?
If a forged deed was sold to a good-faith buyer, can I still get my home back?
Does a criminal conviction automatically restore my title?
Can I sue the title company or lender under the new law?
How long do I have to challenge a forged deed?
What is the deadline to challenge a deed I signed because I was deceived?
Someone claiming to own my house has started an eviction case. What should I do?
Who can bring a partition action against heirs property?
Does a transfer-on-death deed avoid probate?
Is there a private right of action for deed theft?
Tell us about your dispute
Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.