Harassment and HP Actions Harassment, repairs, and habitability.

When conditions go unrepaired or a tenant is pressured to leave, Housing Court can order repairs, impose penalties, and award damages.

An HP action is a Housing Court proceeding that asks the court to order an owner to correct violations of the Housing Maintenance Code. Tenants can combine it with a claim of harassment.

Harassment — repeated interruptions of service, baseless proceedings, threats, or other conduct meant to force a tenant out — is prohibited by the New York City Housing Maintenance Code and can lead to civil penalties and orders restraining the owner. Every residential lease also carries the warranty of habitability under RPL § 235-b, which can support rent abatements.

We also defend owners facing HP actions and harassment claims, often by documenting repairs, access refusals, and good-faith compliance.

Our capabilities include:

  • HP actions for repairs and services
  • Harassment claims and defense
  • Warranty of habitability and rent abatement
  • Emergency orders to restore heat, hot water, and services
  • Access and repair scheduling disputes
  • Negotiated buyouts

Remedies available

  • Orders to correct

    Court-ordered repairs with deadlines and penalties for non-compliance.

  • Harassment findings

    Civil penalties and orders restraining further harassment.

  • Rent abatements

    Reductions for periods when habitability was breached.

  • Emergency relief

    Prompt orders when essential services are cut off.

Key terms

HP action
A Housing Court proceeding, short for Housing Part, in which a tenant or HPD asks the court to order an owner to correct housing code violations.
Housing Maintenance Code
Title 27, Chapter 2 of the New York City Administrative Code, which sets the minimum standards for repairs, heat, hot water, and building services.
HPD
The New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development, which inspects buildings, issues violations, and can be a party to HP actions.
Class A, B, and C violations
HPD’s categories of code violations: non-hazardous, hazardous, and immediately hazardous, each with its own correction period.
Order to correct
A court order directing the owner to fix specified conditions by set dates, enforceable with civil penalties and contempt.
Harassment
Conduct defined in the Housing Maintenance Code, such as repeated service interruptions, baseless court cases, or threats, that is meant to cause a tenant to leave or give up rights.
Civil penalties
Fines the court may impose on an owner for failing to correct violations or for harassment.
Warranty of habitability
The guarantee, under RPL § 235-b, that a residential apartment is fit to live in; a breach can support a rent abatement.
Rent abatement
A reduction of rent for a period when the apartment was not habitable, often measured as a percentage of the rent for each affected period.
Constructive eviction
When conditions are so bad that a tenant is effectively forced out of all or part of the apartment, which can relieve the tenant of rent for the affected space.
Access
The owner’s right, on reasonable notice, to enter an apartment to make repairs; a tenant’s refusal of access can be a defense to an HP claim.
Emergency Repair Program
HPD’s program for making urgent repairs when an owner fails to do so, with the cost billed to the owner and enforceable as a lien.
Heat season
October 1 through May 31, when the Housing Maintenance Code requires owners to provide heat at minimum indoor temperatures.
Certification of correction
The owner’s filing with HPD that a violation has been fixed; a false certification can carry penalties.
Illegal lockout
Removing a tenant without a court order, for example by changing locks; it is unlawful under RPAPL § 768, and the tenant can seek restoration.

Questions we hear most

Do I need to be rent-stabilized to bring an HP action?

No. HP actions are available to residential tenants generally.

Can I withhold rent for repairs?

Withholding carries risk. A better approach is usually an HP action or raising habitability in any non-payment case, with rent set aside.

I am an owner facing an HP action. What should I do?

Document repairs, access attempts, and contractor schedules, and respond promptly; courts look closely at good-faith compliance.

Does it cost money to start an HP action?

Housing Court offers forms for tenants to start an HP action, and the filing fee can often be waived for tenants who cannot afford it. An HPD inspection is usually scheduled as part of the case. We can tell you whether your case would benefit from counsel.

What counts as harassment under city law?

The Housing Maintenance Code lists categories of harassing conduct, including using force or threats, repeated interruptions of essential services, bringing baseless court proceedings, unnecessary or disruptive construction, and offering buyouts in a threatening way. The conduct must generally be intended to cause the tenant to leave or give up rights. Each case depends on the facts.

How long does an owner have to fix a violation?

It depends on the class of violation. HPD sets different correction periods for non-hazardous, hazardous, and immediately hazardous conditions, and an HP court order can set its own deadlines. Heat and hot water outages are generally treated as urgent.

Can I sue for damages for harassment?

Tenants may be able to seek civil penalties, injunctive relief, and in some circumstances damages, either in Housing Court or Supreme Court. Rent abatements for habitability breaches are a common remedy. What is available depends on the claim and the forum.

What if the owner says I refused access?

Owners are entitled to reasonable access to make repairs, and a documented refusal can defeat an HP claim or reduce an abatement. Keep a record of every access request and response. Courts often set access dates in an order to break the impasse.

Can several tenants bring a case together?

Yes. Tenants in the same building often bring a group HP action, which can address building-wide conditions such as heat, leaks, or pests in a single proceeding. Group cases are often more efficient and can carry more weight.

What if my apartment has lead paint or mold?

New York City has specific laws on lead-based paint and indoor allergens such as mold and pests, which impose inspection and remediation obligations on owners, particularly where young children live. These conditions can be raised in an HP action and with HPD. Document the condition and report it.

Can I move out and stop paying rent if conditions are terrible?

Leaving because of conditions may support a claim of constructive eviction, but the standards are demanding and the risks are real. You may remain liable for rent if a court disagrees. Speak with counsel before moving out or withholding rent.

Can owners recover HPD emergency repair charges?

HPD bills owners for emergency repairs it performs, and unpaid charges can become a lien on the property. Owners who dispute the charges should do so promptly. Making the repairs and certifying correction is the best way to avoid them.

As an owner, how do I defend against a harassment claim?

Documentation is the defense: repair logs, access requests, contractor invoices, and the legitimate reasons for any court case or construction. Showing good-faith compliance and a non-harassing purpose often decides these cases. We also look at whether the conduct alleged falls within the statutory definition.

Does a harassment finding affect an owner beyond the case?

It can. A harassment finding may affect eligibility for certain rent increases, such as the higher IAI tier, and in some programs can affect building permits under the city’s certification of no harassment rules. Owners should take these claims seriously from the start.
Contact

Tell us about your dispute

Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.

Send inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content