Mechanic’s Liens Mechanic’s liens and Lien Law trust claims.
A mechanic’s lien turns an unpaid construction invoice into a claim against the property itself. The Lien Law is strict on both sides: a lienor who misses a deadline loses the lien, and an owner who ignores one can find a sale or refinancing stalled.
We represent owners, developers, general contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers in filing, defending, bonding, and foreclosing mechanic’s liens and in trust fund claims under Article 3-A of the Lien Law.
Under Lien Law §§ 3 and 10, a contractor, subcontractor, laborer, or supplier who improves private property with the owner’s consent or at its request may file a notice of lien in the county clerk’s office where the property is located. The notice generally must be filed within eight months after completion of the contract or the final performance of work or furnishing of materials, and within four months where the property is improved or to be improved with a single-family dwelling. A copy must be served on the owner within five days before or thirty days after filing, and proof of service filed with the county clerk within thirty-five days after filing, or the notice terminates as a lien.
A lien does not last on its own. Under Lien Law § 17, it expires one year after filing unless the lienor commences a foreclosure action and files a notice of pendency, or extends it. On property other than a single-family dwelling, the lienor may file one extension for up to one more year; after that, and for single-family dwellings from the start, only a court order can continue it. An owner or contractor may discharge the lien from the property at any time by posting a bond or undertaking for 110 percent of the lien amount under § 19(4), which moves the dispute from the property to the security, or may petition to discharge a lien that is invalid on its face under § 19(6).
A lien the lienor has willfully exaggerated is void under § 39, and § 39-a makes the lienor liable for the owner’s bond premium, reasonable attorney’s fees, and the difference between the amount claimed and the amount actually due. Separately, Article 3-A makes construction funds received by an owner, contractor, or subcontractor trust assets held for those who furnished the work, and § 79-a makes a trustee and its officers who divert them guilty of larceny. On public improvements, a lien attaches to the unpaid contract funds rather than the property and generally must be filed within thirty days after completion and acceptance of the work.
Our capabilities include:
- Preparing, filing, and serving notices of lien
- Lien foreclosure actions and defense
- Bonding and discharge of liens before closings and refinancings
- Summary petitions to discharge facially invalid liens
- Willful exaggeration claims under Lien Law §§ 39 and 39-a
- Article 3-A trust fund diversion claims and accountings
- Public improvement liens and payment bond claims
- Building loan contract and lender priority disputes
Key Lien Law deadlines
| File the notice of lien | Eight months after completion or last work or materials; four months for a single-family dwelling (§ 10) |
|---|---|
| Retainage | Ninety days after the retainage was due to be released (§ 10) |
| Serve the owner | Five days before to thirty days after filing (§ 11) |
| File proof of service | Within thirty-five days after filing (§ 11) |
| Foreclose or extend | Within one year after filing; extensions as § 17 allows |
| Public improvement lien | Within thirty days after completion and acceptance (§ 12) |
Clearing a lien from the property
Check the notice
Compare the lien against the contract, the work, the dates, and § 9’s content requirements; a late or defective lien may be discharged summarily.
Demand an itemized statement
Under § 38, an owner may demand an itemized statement of the work and materials claimed.
Bond it
Post a surety bond for 110 percent of the lien amount and file it with the county clerk to free the property for a closing or loan.
Shorten the clock
Under § 59, serve a demand requiring the lienor to commence foreclosure within the time the notice sets, which must be at least thirty days.
Litigate the amount
Contest the claim in the foreclosure action and pursue exaggeration damages where the facts support them.
Key terms
- Mechanic’s lien
- A statutory lien on real property for the value or agreed price of labor or materials furnished to improve it.
- Notice of lien
- The document filed with the county clerk that creates a mechanic’s lien, with the contents § 9 requires.
- Single-family dwelling
- Property improved or to be improved with a single-family home, which has a four-month filing period and court-only extensions.
- Retainage
- A portion of contract payments withheld until completion, which carries its own ninety-day filing period.
- Lien foreclosure
- An action to enforce a mechanic’s lien, generally against the property or the security that replaced it.
- Discharge by bond
- Substituting a bond or undertaking for 110 percent of the lien under § 19(4), freeing the property.
- Summary discharge
- A court order under § 19(6) discharging a lien that is invalid on its face or untimely on the public record.
- Willful exaggeration
- Deliberately claiming more than is due, which voids the lien under § 39 and exposes the lienor to damages under § 39-a.
- Itemized statement
- A statement of the work and materials claimed that an owner may demand under § 38.
- Building loan contract
- A construction loan agreement that must be filed under § 22, or the lender risks subordination to mechanic’s liens.
- Notice of lending
- A filing under § 73 that protects a lender’s right to repayment from trust assets for advances made for an improvement.
- Article 3-A trust
- The statutory trust over construction funds received by owners, contractors, and subcontractors.
- Trust diversion
- Use of trust funds for non-trust purposes before trust claims are paid, which § 79-a makes larceny.
- Public improvement lien
- A lien on the unpaid funds of a public contract, filed with the public owner and its financial officer.
Questions we hear most
How long do I have to file a mechanic’s lien in New York?
Can a contract waive my right to file a lien?
The lien is on my property but I paid my general contractor in full. Is the subcontractor’s lien valid?
What happens if the lienor never sues?
Who can file a mechanic’s lien?
Can a tenant’s contractor lien the landlord’s building?
Do I have to foreclose within a year if the lien has been bonded?
What is the risk of filing a lien for too much?
Can trust fund claims reach the owner or contractor’s officers personally?
Does a lien survive a sale of the property?
Tell us about your dispute
Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.