Construction defect claims.
Leaks, failing facades, and mechanical systems that never worked as designed tend to emerge after the sponsor has sold out and the unit owners control the board. By then, several limitations periods may already be running.
We represent condominium boards, cooperative boards, building owners, and developers in claims against and on behalf of sponsors, contractors, architects, and engineers arising from defective construction.
A new condominium is sold under an offering plan filed with the Attorney General under the Martin Act, General Business Law Article 23-A, and the plan, its amendments, and the purchase agreements describe what the sponsor promised to build. The Attorney General enforces the Martin Act, which does not give purchasers or boards a private right of action; claims by owners and boards are instead brought for breach of contract, breach of warranty, or fraud based on the plan and related representations, although a fraud claim that rests solely on omissions from the offering plan is barred as an attempt to enforce the Martin Act privately. Under Real Property Law § 339-dd, a condominium board of managers may sue on behalf of two or more unit owners on claims relating to the common elements or more than one unit.
The limitations period depends on who is sued and why. Breach of contract claims are generally subject to the six-year period of CPLR 213(2), and an owner’s claim against a contractor for defective construction generally accrues on completion of the work. Claims against architects and engineers for professional malpractice are subject to the three-year period of CPLR 214(6), whether framed in contract or tort, and generally accrue when the professional’s performance under the contract is complete. Fraud claims carry the longer of six years from the fraud or two years from discovery. Because sponsor control of the board can delay discovery and decision-making, the board should obtain an independent transition or engineering report promptly after turnover and calendar each deadline.
The statutory housing merchant implied warranty in General Business Law Article 36-B applies only to a new home as § 777 defines it, which includes a single-family house or a for-sale unit in a condominium or cooperative structure of five stories or less, and it may be replaced by a limited warranty that meets § 777-b. Many sponsors are single-purpose entities that distribute sale proceeds and wind up after sellout, so recovery often depends on insurance, including commercial general liability and wrap-up policies, on claims against contractors and design professionals, and on how the sponsor entity and its principals handled known claims.
Our capabilities include:
- Claims by condominium and cooperative boards against sponsors
- Transition and engineering report review and claim development
- Claims against general contractors, subcontractors, architects, and engineers
- Offering plan and purchase agreement claims
- Housing merchant implied warranty and limited warranty claims
- Insurance coverage, notice, and tender to sponsors’ and contractors’ insurers
- Defense of sponsors and developers in defect litigation
- Settlement structures funding repairs and reserves
Common limitations periods
| Breach of contract (CPLR 213(2)) | Six years; against a contractor, generally from completion of the work |
|---|---|
| Professional malpractice (CPLR 214(6)) | Three years; against an architect or engineer, generally from completion of performance |
| Fraud (CPLR 213(8)) | Six years from the fraud or two years from discovery, whichever is later |
| Housing merchant implied warranty | Written notice no later than thirty days after the warranty period; suit within one year after the period or four years after the warranty date, whichever is later |
| Contractual limits | Construction contracts and warranties may shorten periods or set notice conditions |
After the sponsor turns over the board
Collect the documents
Obtain the offering plan and amendments, plans and specifications, permits, warranties, and the sponsor’s closeout files.
Commission a transition report
Retain an independent engineer or architect to compare the building as built with the plans, the offering plan, and the Building Code.
Give notice
Send written notice of claims to the sponsor, contractors, and warrantors, and tender to every insurer that may respond.
Calendar the deadlines
Identify each potential defendant’s limitations period and any contractual notice or claim periods.
Negotiate or file
Present the claim with the report and repair estimates, and sue or arrange tolling before periods expire.
Who may be responsible
Sponsor
The selling entity, under the offering plan, purchase agreements, and any warranty it gave.
Contractors and subcontractors
Under their contracts, and through the sponsor’s rights where they can be reached.
Architects and engineers
For design and inspection failures, subject to the shorter professional malpractice period.
Insurers
Under policies covering the sponsor and contractors, depending on the policy terms, exclusions, and notice.
Key terms
- Sponsor
- The developer or entity that offers and sells condominium or cooperative units under an offering plan.
- Offering plan
- The disclosure document filed with the Attorney General describing the building, the units, and the sponsor’s obligations.
- Amendment
- A filed change to the offering plan, which may alter the description of the building or the sponsor’s commitments.
- Martin Act
- General Business Law Article 23-A, under which the Attorney General regulates and enforces real estate securities offerings.
- Transition report
- An engineering or architectural report commissioned by the board after turnover to identify defects and deviations.
- Turnover
- The transfer of board control from sponsor designees to unit owners.
- Board of managers
- The governing body of a condominium, which may sue on behalf of owners under Real Property Law § 339-dd.
- Common elements
- The parts of a condominium owned in common, such as the roof, facade, structure, and building systems.
- Housing merchant implied warranty
- The statutory warranty for new homes under General Business Law Article 36-B.
- Limited warranty
- A written warranty meeting § 777-b that may replace the statutory implied warranty.
- CPLR 214(6)
- The three-year limitations period for professional malpractice other than medical, regardless of the theory pleaded.
- Wrap-up policy
- An owner- or contractor-controlled insurance program covering multiple parties on a project.
- Tolling agreement
- An agreement suspending limitations periods while the parties investigate or negotiate.
- Winding up
- The process by which a dissolved entity settles its affairs, pays or provides for claims, and distributes assets.
Questions we hear most
When does the clock start on a condominium board’s claims?
Can unit owners sue the sponsor under the Martin Act?
Does the housing merchant implied warranty cover a high-rise condominium?
The sponsor LLC has dissolved. Is there anyone left to sue?
Should the board sue right away?
Can individual unit owners bring their own claims?
What does a transition report cover?
Can a board recover from the sponsor’s insurers directly?
Do sponsors defend these claims?
Can a board’s claim reach the architect if the board never contracted with the architect?
Tell us about your dispute
Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.