Construction Law Construction contracts, liens, and disputes.
Construction disputes usually turn on the contract and on deadlines in the Lien Law. Both deserve attention before the first shovel goes in the ground.
We represent owners, developers, co-op and condo boards, contractors, and subcontractors in construction contracts, mechanic’s liens, and payment, delay, and defect disputes.
Most projects begin with a form contract, often an AIA document, modified for the job. The terms that matter most in a later dispute are scope and change orders, payment and retainage, schedule and delay remedies, warranties, insurance and indemnity, termination, and the dispute resolution clause. For private projects of $150,000 or more that are not excluded residential work, New York’s Prompt Payment Act, General Business Law Article 35-E, sets payment rules and limits retainage to 5 percent of the contract sum; since December 19, 2025, contract provisions requiring more than 5 percent retainage are void.
Mechanic’s lien deadlines are short and strict. Under Lien Law § 10, a notice of lien generally must be filed within eight months after completion of the contract or the last work or materials, and within four months for a single-family dwelling. Under Lien Law § 17, a lien lapses one year after filing unless the lienor starts a foreclosure and files a notice of pendency, or extends it; extension by filing is not available for single-family dwellings, which require a court order. Owners may discharge a lien by bond or deposit and may challenge a lien that is untimely, defective, or willfully exaggerated.
Funds an owner or contractor receives for a project are trust funds under Lien Law Article 3-A and must be used to pay those who furnished labor and materials before they are diverted for other purposes. Owners should also understand Labor Law §§ 240(1) and 241(6), which can make owners and contractors liable for certain worker injuries regardless of fault, with an exemption for owners of one- and two-family dwellings who do not direct or control the work. Insurance and indemnity provisions in the contract are the owner’s main protection.
Our capabilities include:
- Drafting and negotiating AIA and custom construction contracts
- Mechanic’s lien filing, foreclosure, bonding, and discharge
- Lien Law Article 3-A trust fund claims
- Prompt Payment Act claims and retainage disputes
- Delay, disruption, and change order claims
- Construction defect claims for owners and boards
- Insurance and indemnity review for Labor Law exposure
- Arbitration and litigation of construction disputes
Mechanic’s lien deadlines
| File notice of lien, generally | Within 8 months after completion or the last work or materials |
|---|---|
| File notice of lien, single-family dwelling | Within 4 months after completion or the last work or materials |
| Lien duration | 1 year from filing, unless foreclosure is commenced with a notice of pendency or the lien is extended |
| Extension by filing | Up to 1 year; not available for single-family dwellings |
| Extension by court order | Up to 1 year per order |
Contract terms to get right
Scope and change orders
A clear scope and a written change order process with pricing and time adjustments.
Payment and retainage
Payment applications, approval, and retainage within the Prompt Payment Act’s 5 percent limit where it applies.
Schedule and delay
Substantial completion, liquidated damages, no-damages-for-delay clauses, and notice requirements.
Insurance and indemnity
Additional insured coverage and indemnity drafted to work with New York’s anti-indemnity rules.
Disputes
Notice, mediation, arbitration or litigation, and venue.
Key terms
- AIA documents
- Standard construction contract forms published by the American Institute of Architects.
- Change order
- A written modification of the contract’s scope, price, or time.
- Retainage
- A portion of each payment withheld until completion.
- Prompt Payment Act
- General Business Law Article 35-E, governing payment on covered private construction contracts.
- Mechanic’s lien
- A lien on real property for the value of labor or materials furnished for its improvement.
- Notice of lien
- The document filed with the county clerk to create a mechanic’s lien.
- Lien Law § 10
- The section setting the deadlines for filing a notice of lien.
- Lien Law § 17
- The section setting the duration and extension of a lien.
- Bonding a lien
- Discharging a lien by substituting a bond as security.
- Willful exaggeration
- Knowingly overstating a lien amount, which can void the lien.
- Trust funds
- Project funds held for those who furnished labor and materials, under Lien Law Article 3-A.
- Diversion
- Using trust funds for purposes other than paying project costs.
- Substantial completion
- The stage at which the work can be used for its intended purpose.
- Liquidated damages
- An agreed amount payable for late completion.
- Labor Law § 240(1)
- The Scaffold Law, imposing liability on owners and contractors for certain gravity-related worker injuries.
Questions we hear most
How long do I have to file a mechanic’s lien in New York?
Does the Prompt Payment Act apply to my project?
Can an owner get rid of a lien before the dispute is resolved?
What is a willfully exaggerated lien?
Can a subcontractor file a lien if the owner already paid the general contractor?
Must a lien be served on the owner?
Is a no-damages-for-delay clause enforceable?
Can a contractor be paid if it is unlicensed?
What happens when there is a construction defect?
Is arbitration better than court for construction disputes?
Tell us about your dispute
Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.