DOB, HPD and OATH Violations DOB, HPD, and OATH building violations.
Open violations cost money, block permits and sales, and can lead to vacate orders. The way to clear them depends on which agency issued them and what they require.
We represent owners, co-op and condo boards, buyers, and managing agents in resolving building violations before the Department of Buildings, HPD, OATH, and Housing Court.
The Department of Buildings issues two main kinds of violations. DOB violations record a condition that must be corrected and dismissed by DOB. Summonses formerly known as ECB violations are heard at the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH), which can impose civil penalties; in many cases the owner must also file a certificate of correction with DOB showing the condition was cured. A penalty paid at OATH does not by itself mean the condition is closed.
HPD violations follow fixed correction periods. HPD classifies housing maintenance violations as Class A (non-hazardous), Class B (hazardous), or Class C (immediately hazardous). The owner must correct the condition and certify the correction within the period stated on the notice, measured from service: generally 90 days for Class A, 30 days for Class B, and 24 hours for most Class C violations, with different periods for some Class C conditions such as lead-based paint, mold, pests, and self-closing doors, and none for heat and hot water. Violations that are not timely certified may require a reinspection and can support civil penalties in Housing Court.
Repeated serious violations can bring a building into HPD’s Alternative Enforcement Program, which can lead to additional fees and HPD-directed repairs billed to the owner. DOB may issue stop work orders, and DOB or HPD may issue vacate orders when conditions are dangerous. Each of these requires a specific path to lift it.
Our capabilities include:
- OATH hearings on DOB and other agency summonses
- Certificates of correction and violation dismissals
- HPD violation certification and reinspection requests
- Housing Court HP proceedings and civil penalty defense
- Stop work order and vacate order rescission
- Alternative Enforcement Program discharge
- Violation review for buyers, sellers, and lenders
HPD correction periods
| Class A (non-hazardous) | 90 days from service |
|---|---|
| Class B (hazardous) | 30 days from service |
| Class C (immediately hazardous), generally | 24 hours from service |
| Class C lead-based paint, window guards, mold, and pests | 21 days from service |
| Class C self-closing doors | 14 days from service |
| Class C heat and hot water | No correction period |
Clearing a DOB or OATH matter
Identify the violation
Pull the DOB and OATH records to see what is open, what has a hearing date, and what has defaulted.
Cure the condition
Correct the work, obtain any required permits, and gather proof from a licensed professional.
Attend or resolve the hearing
Appear at OATH, or submit a cure or plea where permitted, to address the penalty.
File for dismissal
Submit a certificate of correction or other dismissal request to DOB with supporting documents.
Key terms
- DOB
- The New York City Department of Buildings.
- HPD
- The New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development, which enforces the Housing Maintenance Code.
- OATH
- The Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, which hears summonses issued by DOB and other agencies.
- ECB violation
- The former name for summonses heard at OATH’s Hearings Division, still widely used.
- Certificate of correction
- A submission to DOB showing that the condition in a violation has been corrected.
- Class A violation
- An HPD non-hazardous violation, generally with a 90-day correction period.
- Class B violation
- An HPD hazardous violation, generally with a 30-day correction period.
- Class C violation
- An HPD immediately hazardous violation, generally with a 24-hour correction period.
- Certification
- An owner’s statement to HPD that a violation has been corrected.
- Dismissal request
- A request for HPD reinspection to remove a violation not timely certified.
- HP proceeding
- A Housing Court proceeding to compel repairs, brought by tenants or HPD.
- Alternative Enforcement Program
- HPD’s program for distressed multiple dwellings with serious violations.
- Stop work order
- A DOB order halting all or part of construction at a site.
- Vacate order
- An order requiring occupants to leave a building or unit because of dangerous conditions.
Questions we hear most
If I pay the OATH penalty, is the violation closed?
How long do I have to fix an HPD Class C violation?
Can open violations stop a sale or refinance?
What is HPD’s Alternative Enforcement Program?
What if I missed an OATH hearing?
Can a tenant see violations on my building?
Who is responsible for violations in a co-op?
Does HPD audit certifications?
How is a stop work order lifted?
Are old violations a problem for a sale?
Tell us about your dispute
Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.