Commercial lease disputes.
Commercial tenants have fewer statutory protections than residential tenants, so the lease and the timing of each notice usually decide the outcome.
We represent landlords and tenants in disputes over defaults, rent, use, alterations, assignments, and guaranties, in Civil Court and Supreme Court.
A tenant served with a notice to cure must act before the cure period expires. A Yellowstone injunction — named for First National Stores v. Yellowstone Shopping Center, 21 N.Y.2d 630 (1968) — tolls the cure period and preserves the lease while the dispute is litigated, but only if sought in time.
For landlords, carefully drafted default and termination notices and properly enforced guaranties are what make a commercial non-payment or holdover proceeding efficient.
Our capabilities include:
- Yellowstone injunctions
- Commercial non-payment and holdover proceedings
- Notices to cure, default, and termination
- Personal and “good guy” guaranty enforcement
- Assignment, sublet, and use disputes
- Lease buyouts and surrender agreements
Where the fight usually is
Default notices
Whether the notice was proper, timely, and served as the lease requires.
Cure periods
Whether the tenant can still cure, and whether a Yellowstone injunction is available.
Guaranties
The scope of the guarantor’s liability and any surrender conditions.
Use and alterations
Whether the tenant’s business or build-out complies with the lease and the certificate of occupancy.
Key terms
- Notice of default
- A landlord’s notice identifying a lease violation. Its required contents and method of service are set by the lease, and a defective notice can undermine a later proceeding.
- Notice to cure
- A notice demanding that the tenant fix a default within the period the lease allows. It is generally a prerequisite to terminating the lease for a non-monetary default.
- Cure period
- The time the lease gives the tenant to fix a default. Many leases extend the period if the tenant begins curing promptly and proceeds diligently, so the exact wording matters.
- Yellowstone requirements
- To obtain a Yellowstone injunction, a commercial tenant generally must show that it holds a commercial lease, received a notice of default or notice to cure or a threat of termination, applied before the cure period and lease expired, and is prepared and able to cure by means short of vacating.
- Conditional limitation
- A lease clause providing that the lease ends automatically on the date set in a termination notice. After that date, the landlord may proceed with a holdover proceeding.
- Condition subsequent
- A lease clause that gives the landlord the right to end the lease after a default, rather than ending it automatically. Under such a clause, the landlord generally cannot use a summary holdover proceeding and may need to bring an ejectment action instead.
- Termination notice
- The notice that ends the lease after the cure period expires without a cure. Once the termination date passes, a Yellowstone injunction is generally no longer available.
- Commercial holdover proceeding
- A summary proceeding to recover possession from a tenant whose lease has expired or been terminated. In New York City it is generally brought in the Commercial Part of Civil Court.
- Commercial non-payment proceeding
- A summary proceeding to recover possession and unpaid rent when the tenant fails to pay. It requires a proper written rent demand before the proceeding begins.
- Rent demand
- The written demand for payment that must precede a non-payment proceeding, as required by statute and often by the lease. It must accurately state the amount claimed.
- Use and occupancy
- Payments for the use of the premises during a holdover or after termination, when rent is no longer technically due. Courts may order a tenant to pay use and occupancy while a case is pending.
- Attorney’s fees clause
- In a commercial lease, a party generally recovers its legal fees only if the lease provides for it. Real Property Law § 234, which makes a landlord’s fee clause reciprocal for tenants, applies to residential leases, not commercial ones.
- Waiver by acceptance of rent
- Accepting rent after a termination notice can, in some circumstances, be argued to revive the lease or waive the default. Non-waiver clauses help, but landlords should handle post-termination payments with care.
- Self-help re-entry
- Retaking possession without a court proceeding. In New York, commercial self-help is generally permitted only if the lease allows it and it can be done peaceably, and it carries significant risk if done improperly.
- No duty to mitigate
- Under Holy Properties Ltd. v. Kenneth Cole Productions, 87 N.Y.2d 130 (1995), a commercial landlord generally has no duty to re-let the premises after the tenant abandons them. The lease may change that result.
- Acceleration clause
- A clause making all future rent due on a default. New York courts generally enforce it, but may decline to do so where the result would be a disproportionate penalty.
- Partial eviction
- An actual eviction from part of the premises by the landlord, which can suspend the tenant’s obligation to pay rent. A constructive eviction claim, by contrast, generally requires the tenant to abandon the affected space.
- Counterclaim waiver
- A lease clause barring the tenant from asserting counterclaims in a summary proceeding. Courts often enforce it, but may allow counterclaims that are closely intertwined with the landlord’s claim.
Questions we hear most
When must I seek a Yellowstone injunction?
What is a good guy guaranty?
Which court hears commercial evictions?
My landlord served a notice to cure. What should I do first?
Can my landlord lock me out of my commercial space?
Can I withhold rent because my landlord failed to make repairs?
If I lose a non-payment case, can I pay and keep my space?
Will I recover my attorney’s fees if I win?
If I leave early, does my landlord have to re-rent the space?
Can my landlord demand all of the future rent at once?
Do I have to keep paying during the case?
What if my landlord accepts rent after terminating my lease?
Can my landlord evict me because my use violates the certificate of occupancy?
Can I raise counterclaims in the eviction case?
Can we settle a commercial lease dispute without a trial?
Tell us about your dispute
Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.