Co-op and Condo Disputes Co-op and condominium disputes.

Board decisions get substantial deference in New York, but not unlimited deference. We represent shareholders, unit owners, and boards.

Co-op boards act under the proprietary lease and bylaws; condominium boards under the declaration and bylaws. Courts review most board decisions under the business judgment rule.

Under Levandusky v. One Fifth Avenue Apartment Corp., 75 N.Y.2d 530 (1990), a court will not second-guess a board acting in good faith, within its authority, and for a legitimate purpose. Decisions that are discriminatory, outside the board’s authority, or made in bad faith are not protected.

Most disputes are better settled than tried. We start with the governing documents and the board’s record, and look for a resolution before litigation where one exists.

Our capabilities include:

  • Proprietary lease, declaration, and bylaw disputes
  • Alteration agreements and renovation disputes
  • Assessments, maintenance, and common charges
  • Sublet and occupancy disputes
  • Board elections and governance
  • Article 78 and plenary actions

Frequent disputes

  • Alterations

    Approval, conditions, and damage from a neighbor’s renovation.

  • Charges and assessments

    Maintenance, common charges, special assessments, and the fees boards may impose.

  • Use and occupancy

    Sublets, short-term rentals, pets, and house rules.

  • Leaks and repairs

    Whether the building or the owner is responsible under the governing documents.

  • Admissions

    Board decisions on purchases, including fair housing and Fair Chance for Housing Law limits.

Key terms

Proprietary lease
The lease between a co-op corporation and each shareholder that gives the right to occupy an apartment and sets the parties’ obligations.
Shares
In a co-op, ownership of stock in the corporation that owns the building; the shares are tied to a specific apartment through the proprietary lease.
Declaration
The recorded document that creates a condominium under RPL Article 9-B and defines the units and common elements.
Bylaws
The rules governing how the co-op corporation or condominium is run, including board elections, meetings, and assessments.
House rules
Building rules adopted by the board on matters such as move-ins, renovations, noise, and pets.
Offering plan
The disclosure document filed with the Attorney General when a building is converted or sold as a co-op or condo, which can affect owners’ and sponsors’ rights.
Business judgment rule
Under Levandusky v. One Fifth Avenue Apartment Corp., courts defer to board decisions made in good faith, within the board’s authority, and for a legitimate purpose.
Fiduciary duty
The duty of board members to act in good faith and in the interests of the corporation or condominium, rather than for personal benefit.
Alteration agreement
The contract a shareholder or unit owner signs with the board before renovating, setting approval conditions, insurance, deposits, and work rules.
Special assessment
A one-time charge imposed on owners to pay for capital projects or shortfalls, beyond regular maintenance or common charges.
Common charges
A condominium unit owner’s share of building expenses; unpaid charges can become a lien on the unit under RPL § 339-z.
Maintenance
A co-op shareholder’s monthly payment to the corporation for building expenses, taxes, and debt service.
Right of first refusal
A condo board’s right, if granted by the governing documents, to buy a unit on the same terms a third party has offered, before the sale can close.
Flip tax
A transfer fee charged by some co-ops on a sale, if authorized by the governing documents.
Objectionable conduct
Under many proprietary leases, conduct that allows the board to terminate a shareholder’s lease; 40 West 67th Street Corp. v. Pullman, 100 N.Y.2d 147 (2003), applied the business judgment rule to such a termination.
Sponsor
The developer or converter who offered the units for sale and may still own unsold units with special rights under the offering plan.

Questions we hear most

Can a co-op board reject a buyer for no reason?

Generally a co-op board need not explain a rejection, but it may not discriminate on a protected basis, and New York City’s Fair Chance for Housing Law limits how criminal history may be considered.

Is the condo board responsible for a leak into my unit?

It depends on where the leak originates and what the declaration and bylaws assign to the board versus the unit owner.

Do you represent boards?

Yes. We represent boards, shareholders, and unit owners, subject to conflicts.

Can I see the building’s financial statements and minutes?

Shareholders and unit owners generally have rights to inspect certain corporate or condominium records, though the scope differs between co-ops and condos and depends on the governing documents and statute. Boards may restrict access to some materials. A written request identifying what you want and why is a good start.

Can the board fine me?

A board may impose fees or fines only if the governing documents authorize them. Courts look at whether the fine was adopted properly and applied fairly. Unauthorized fines can be challenged.

My neighbor’s renovation damaged my apartment. Who pays?

The renovating owner, their contractor, and sometimes the building may all bear responsibility, depending on the alteration agreement, insurance, and the cause of the damage. Notify the board and the neighbor in writing, document the damage, and file a claim with your insurer. Many such cases resolve through insurance.

Can the board stop me from renting out my unit?

It depends on the governing documents. Co-ops often restrict or prohibit sublets and may require board approval and fees. Condos generally allow more freedom but may have a right of first refusal or leasing rules. Short-term rentals are also restricted under New York City law.

How do I challenge a board decision?

Depending on the decision, a shareholder or unit owner may bring an Article 78 proceeding or a plenary action in Supreme Court. Article 78 proceedings have a short deadline, generally four months. Because courts often defer to boards, the claim usually must show bad faith, discrimination, or action outside the board’s authority.

Can a board terminate my proprietary lease?

Many proprietary leases allow termination for objectionable conduct after a shareholder vote, and the Court of Appeals has applied the business judgment rule to that decision. The procedure in the lease must be followed carefully. A termination can be challenged if the process was flawed or the board acted in bad faith.

What can a condo do if an owner stops paying common charges?

Unpaid common charges are generally a lien on the unit under RPL § 339-z, and the condominium may foreclose on the lien or sue for the money. The declaration and bylaws may also permit late fees and recovery of attorney’s fees.

Is the sponsor still responsible for construction defects?

Possibly. Claims against a sponsor may arise under the offering plan, the purchase agreement, express warranties, or New York’s housing merchant implied warranty for new homes, subject to limitations periods and disclaimers. These claims are often brought by the board on behalf of the building.

Can a co-op board reject a buyer for a discriminatory reason?

No. Board decisions are subject to federal, state, and city fair housing laws, which prohibit discrimination based on protected characteristics. A board that rejects a buyer on such a basis is not protected by the business judgment rule.

Can I run for the board or call a special meeting?

The bylaws govern eligibility, elections, and how shareholders or unit owners may call a special meeting, often by petition of a set percentage. Following the bylaws exactly matters if the vote is later challenged.

Who is responsible for repairs inside my apartment?

The proprietary lease or declaration allocates responsibility between the building and the owner, often by distinguishing building systems from fixtures inside the unit. The answer can differ for pipes, windows, and appliances. We start with the governing documents.
Contact

Tell us about your dispute

Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.

Send inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content