Partition Actions Partition actions between co-owners.

When co-owners can no longer agree on what to do with a property, any one of them can generally ask the court to divide it or sell it. The question is usually on what terms.

We represent co-owners, siblings, heirs, and former partners in partition actions and in negotiated buyouts that avoid a forced sale.

Under RPAPL Article 9, a person who holds real property as a joint tenant or tenant in common with others may bring an action for partition. The court first determines the parties’ rights and shares, and then whether the property can be physically divided without great prejudice to the owners. In New York City, where most properties cannot be divided practically, partition usually means a sale and division of the proceeds.

The accounting often matters more than the sale. Before the proceeds are divided, the court may credit an owner who paid more than a fair share of the mortgage, taxes, insurance, or necessary repairs, and may charge an owner who had exclusive use of the property or collected rents. Partition is equitable, so the court considers the full history of the ownership.

New York has adopted the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act in RPAPL § 993 for qualifying residential and agricultural property held as tenants in common where title came from a relative. In those cases, the court must hold a settlement conference, order an appraisal if there is no agreed value, give the other co-owners a chance to buy out the co-owner who sought a sale, and favor partition in kind unless it would cause great prejudice to the co-owners as a group.

Our capabilities include:

  • Partition actions for co-owners and heirs
  • Buyout negotiations and settlement agreements
  • Accounting for mortgage, tax, and repair contributions
  • Heirs property act proceedings under RPAPL § 993
  • Referee sales and distribution of proceeds
  • Co-op apartment disputes between co-owners
  • Coordination with estate administration

How a partition action proceeds

  1. Commencement

    The plaintiff files the complaint and a notice of pendency, naming every owner and lienholder.

  2. Interlocutory judgment

    The court determines the owners’ shares and whether the property can be divided or must be sold.

  3. Referee

    A referee may take testimony on the accounting and conduct the sale.

  4. Sale

    The property is sold, usually at public auction, unless the parties agree otherwise.

  5. Final judgment

    The court confirms the sale and directs distribution of the proceeds after credits and charges.

Heirs property under RPAPL § 993

  • Who it covers

    Residential or agricultural property held as tenants in common, where a co-owner acquired title from a relative, living or deceased, and the other statutory conditions are met.

  • Settlement conference

    The court must hold a conference, and parties must negotiate in good faith.

  • Appraisal

    Absent an agreed value, the court orders an appraisal by a disinterested licensed appraiser and sets fair market value after any objections.

  • Buyout

    Co-owners who did not seek a sale may elect to buy the interest of the co-owner who did, at the determined value.

  • Partition in kind preferred

    The court orders physical division unless it would cause great prejudice to the co-owners as a group, weighing factors such as family ownership and contributions.

Key terms

Partition
A court proceeding to divide co-owned property or sell it and divide the proceeds.
RPAPL Article 9
The New York statute governing partition actions.
Tenancy in common
Co-ownership in which each owner holds a separate, transferable share.
Joint tenancy
Co-ownership with a right of survivorship.
Tenancy by the entirety
Co-ownership between spouses, which generally cannot be partitioned while the marriage continues.
Partition in kind
Physical division of the property among the owners.
Partition by sale
Sale of the property and division of the proceeds.
Interlocutory judgment
The court’s intermediate ruling on shares and the method of partition.
Referee
A court-appointed officer who takes testimony, reports, and conducts the sale.
Accounting
The court’s reckoning of each owner’s contributions and benefits.
Ouster
Exclusion of a co-owner from the property, which can affect claims for use and occupancy.
Heirs property
Property defined in RPAPL § 993, generally held by relatives as tenants in common.
Buyout
The purchase of a co-owner’s interest by the other owners.
Notice of pendency
A filing that gives notice of the action to anyone dealing with the property.

Questions we hear most

Can my sibling force a sale of the house we inherited?

Generally a co-owner can seek partition, but if the property qualifies as heirs property under RPAPL § 993, the other co-owners may have the right to buy out that sibling’s interest at an appraised value before any sale.

Will I get credit for paying the mortgage and taxes?

Often yes. In the accounting, the court may credit an owner who paid more than a fair share of carrying costs and necessary repairs, and may charge an owner who had exclusive use.

Can a co-op apartment be partitioned?

Co-op shares are personal property, so RPAPL Article 9 does not apply directly. Courts can resolve co-owner disputes over a co-op apartment through equitable actions that may order a sale and an accounting, subject to the co-op’s approval rights.

Is a forced sale the only outcome?

No. Many partition cases settle with one owner buying out the others, a negotiated private sale, or an agreed division.

How long does a partition action take?

It depends on the court, the number of parties, and whether the accounting is contested. Settlement can shorten the process considerably.

Can I bring a partition action while the estate is still open?

Sometimes, but the estate’s administration, the fiduciary’s powers, and who holds title must be addressed first. Coordination with the Surrogate’s Court proceeding is often needed.

Who pays the costs of the partition?

Costs and the referee’s fees are generally paid from the sale proceeds, and the court may allocate them among the owners.

Can the co-owner living in the house be charged rent?

Generally only where there has been an ouster or other circumstances the court finds equitable. The rules on use and occupancy credits are fact-specific.

Does a mortgage prevent partition?

No. Lienholders are named as parties, and a sale is made subject to or free of the liens as the judgment provides, with liens paid from the proceeds.

Can co-owners waive partition by agreement?

Yes. Co-ownership or operating agreements can limit partition, and courts generally enforce reasonable restrictions.
Contact

Tell us about your dispute

Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.

Send inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content