Easements, Boundary and Adverse Possession Disputes Easements, boundaries, and adverse possession.

A driveway everyone has used for decades, a fence a few feet off the line, a wall two buildings share. These disputes often surface at a sale or a renovation, and the outcome usually depends on the deeds, the survey, and the history.

We represent homeowners, building owners, developers, and co-op and condominium boards in disputes over easements, boundary lines, encroachments, party walls, and adverse possession.

An easement can be created in several ways. An express easement is granted or reserved in a deed or recorded agreement. An implied easement may arise when a single owner divided property and an apparent, continuous use benefiting one part existed before the division, or where a parcel would otherwise be landlocked. A prescriptive easement is acquired by use that is open and notorious, hostile, and continuous for the ten-year statutory period, and it must be proved by clear and convincing evidence. Each type has its own scope, and disputes often turn less on whether an easement exists than on how far it extends.

Adverse possession changed in 2008. Chapter 269 of the Laws of 2008 amended the RPAPL to require, in most cases, that the possessor have a claim of right, defined in RPAPL § 501 as a reasonable basis for the belief that the property belongs to the possessor. New RPAPL § 543 treats de minimis, non-structural encroachments such as fences, hedges, shrubbery, plantings, sheds, and non-structural walls, and acts such as lawn mowing across the line, as permissive and not adverse. The claimant must still prove by clear and convincing evidence possession that is adverse, actual, open and notorious, exclusive, and continuous for ten years, and courts have generally declined to apply the 2008 amendments where title had already vested before they took effect.

Most of these disputes are resolved in an action under RPAPL Article 15 to determine claims to real property, often joined with claims for ejectment, an injunction, or damages. In New York City, party walls that straddle a lot line raise their own questions of support, use, and repair, and construction next door frequently requires temporary access to a neighbor’s property. Where a neighbor will not agree, RPAPL § 881, as rewritten effective December 5, 2025 and further amended in 2026, allows a court to grant a license on conditions that include compensation, insurance, and reimbursement of the neighbor’s professional fees.

Our capabilities include:

  • Quiet title actions under RPAPL Article 15
  • Express, implied, and prescriptive easement claims and defense
  • Adverse possession claims and defense
  • Encroachment, ejectment, and removal actions
  • Survey and title review with surveyors and title insurers
  • Party wall, support, and shared-structure disputes
  • Boundary line and easement agreements to settle disputes of record
  • Temporary access disputes and RPAPL § 881 petitions

Types of easements

ExpressCreated in a deed or recorded agreement; scope depends on its language
Implied from prior useArises when common ownership is divided and an apparent, continuous use existed before the division
By necessityArises when a division leaves a parcel without access; lasts as long as the necessity
PrescriptiveAcquired by open, notorious, hostile, and continuous use for ten years, proved by clear and convincing evidence
LicensePermission to use land that is generally revocable and does not run with the land

Elements of adverse possession after 2008

  • Claim of right

    A reasonable basis for believing the property belongs to the possessor, required in most cases by RPAPL § 501.

  • Actual possession

    Physical use consistent with ownership, of the kind the 2008 amendments describe.

  • Open and notorious

    Acts sufficiently open to put a reasonably diligent owner on notice.

  • Exclusive and continuous

    Possession not shared with the owner and uninterrupted for the full ten-year period.

  • De minimis exclusion

    Fences, hedges, plantings, sheds, non-structural walls, and lawn mowing are treated as permissive under RPAPL § 543.

Resolving a boundary dispute

  1. Assemble the record

    Collect deeds back through the chain, recorded easements and agreements, old surveys, and title reports.

  2. Get a current survey

    Retain a licensed surveyor to locate the line, the improvements, and any encroachments.

  3. Document the history

    Gather photographs, affidavits, and records showing how and how long each area has been used.

  4. Try for an agreement

    A recorded boundary line or easement agreement can resolve the dispute and satisfy a buyer’s title insurer.

  5. Litigate if needed

    Bring or defend an RPAPL Article 15 action, with ejectment or injunctive claims where appropriate.

Key terms

Easement
A right to use another’s land for a specific purpose, such as access, light, or utilities.
Dominant estate
The property that benefits from an easement.
Servient estate
The property burdened by an easement.
Express easement
An easement granted or reserved in a deed or other written instrument.
Implied easement
An easement inferred from circumstances, such as prior use when common ownership was divided.
Easement by necessity
An easement arising when a division of land leaves a parcel without access.
Prescriptive easement
An easement acquired by open, notorious, hostile, and continuous use for ten years.
Adverse possession
Acquisition of title by possession meeting the statutory elements for ten years.
Claim of right
Under RPAPL § 501, a reasonable basis for the belief that the property belongs to the adverse possessor.
De minimis encroachment
A minor non-structural improvement, such as a fence or hedge, treated as permissive under RPAPL § 543.
RPAPL Article 15
The statutory action to determine adverse claims to real property, commonly called quiet title.
Ejectment
An action to recover possession of real property from one wrongfully occupying it.
Party wall
A wall on or along a lot line that supports or serves buildings on both sides.
License
Revocable permission to use another’s land, including a court-ordered license under RPAPL § 881.
Boundary line agreement
A recorded agreement between neighbors fixing the location of their common line.

Questions we hear most

My neighbor’s fence has been on my land for more than ten years. Do they own the strip now?

Not necessarily. Since 2008, fences and similar non-structural improvements are treated as permissive and not adverse under RPAPL § 543, and a claimant generally must also show a claim of right. Older claims where the ten-year period ran before July 2008 may be decided under the prior law.

Can I block a driveway my neighbor has used for years?

Not until you know whether the neighbor has an easement. A recorded grant, an implied easement, or ten years of open, hostile, and continuous use can give the neighbor a right that survives a sale, so review the title and history before acting.

Does a prescriptive easement have to be recorded?

No. It arises from use over the statutory period, which is why it can surprise a buyer. A court judgment or recorded agreement confirming it makes the right clear for future owners and lenders.

My neighbor will not let my contractor onto their property. What can I do?

If the work cannot be done in a commercially reasonable manner without entering the neighbor’s property and the neighbor has refused permission, RPAPL § 881 lets an owner or lessee petition for a court-ordered license. Under the statute as amended in December 2025 and again in 2026, a license is subject to conditions that include reasonable compensation to the neighbor and proof that the licensee maintains commercial general liability insurance, and the court may also require reimbursement of the neighbor’s reasonable professional fees.

How is an easement terminated?

An easement can end by a recorded release, by merger of the two properties into one ownership, by the end of the necessity that created an easement by necessity, or, in some cases, by abandonment or adverse use. Non-use alone generally does not extinguish an easement created by deed.

Can an easement holder expand its use?

Generally not beyond the scope of the grant or, for a prescriptive easement, beyond the character of the use that created it. The owner of the burdened property may also make reasonable use of the area so long as it does not unreasonably interfere with the easement.

Does paying taxes on the disputed strip matter?

It can be evidence of a claim of right or of ownership, but it is not by itself decisive. Courts look at the whole record of possession and title.

What standard of proof applies to adverse possession?

The claimant must prove each element by clear and convincing evidence, a higher standard than in most civil cases. Courts do not favor the acquisition of title by possession.

Can adverse possession run against the government?

Generally not against land held by the State or a municipality for public use. Other public land raises its own questions and should be reviewed individually.

Who is responsible for repairing a party wall?

It depends on the deeds, any party wall agreement, and the nature of the work. Owners generally may not remove a party wall’s support from the neighboring building, and City construction rules require protection of adjoining property during excavation and demolition.
Contact

Tell us about your dispute

Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.

Send inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content