ADA and Accessibility ADA and accessibility claims and compliance.
New York City storefronts draw a steady volume of accessibility suits. Both the landlord and the tenant can be named, and state and city law add damages that federal law does not.
We represent owners, landlords, and commercial tenants of retail, restaurant, and office space in accessibility claims and in planning compliance before a claim arrives.
Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act applies to places of public accommodation, including stores, restaurants, medical offices, and hotels. Both the owner of the building and the tenant operating the business are responsible for compliance, and while a lease may allocate that responsibility between them, the allocation binds only the landlord and tenant, not a plaintiff. A private Title III plaintiff may obtain an injunction and attorney’s fees but not money damages. The New York State and City Human Rights Laws, which are often pleaded alongside the ADA, do permit damages.
The standard depends on when the space was built or altered. In existing facilities, the ADA requires removal of architectural barriers where that is readily achievable, meaning easily accomplishable without much difficulty or expense. New construction and alterations must meet the ADA Standards for Accessible Design, and an alteration to a primary function area generally requires making the path of travel to it accessible, within cost limits set by the regulations. New York City projects must also satisfy the accessibility chapter of the City Building Code.
Many suits arise from a single visit or a website. Courts in New York have allowed claims that a business’s website is inaccessible to blind and low-vision users, although the law on websites continues to develop. An accessibility survey, a written barrier-removal plan, and a lease that clearly assigns responsibility put an owner or tenant in a far better position than a response drafted after a complaint is served.
Our capabilities include:
- Defense of ADA Title III, State, and City Human Rights Law accessibility suits
- Lease provisions allocating accessibility obligations and costs
- Accessibility surveys and barrier-removal plans with consultants
- Landlord–tenant indemnification and tender disputes
- Website accessibility claims
- Settlement and consent decree terms with realistic remediation schedules
- Alteration planning and path-of-travel analysis
What the law requires
| Existing facilities | Remove barriers where readily achievable; use alternative methods where removal is not |
|---|---|
| Alterations | Altered areas must comply with the ADA Standards; primary function areas generally trigger path-of-travel work within regulatory cost limits |
| New construction | Must be readily accessible and usable by people with disabilities |
| New York City projects | Also governed by the accessibility provisions of the City Building Code |
| Private federal remedy | Injunctive relief and attorney’s fees; damages are available under State and City law |
Responding to an accessibility suit
Tender and notify
Review the lease for responsibility and indemnity, notify the other party, and notify insurers.
Survey the premises
Retain an accessibility consultant to confirm which alleged barriers exist and what fixing them involves.
Assess readily achievable
Weigh the cost and difficulty of each item against the resources of the owner and the business.
Remediate and resolve
Fix what can be fixed and negotiate a schedule for the rest; remediation can narrow or moot injunctive claims.
Key terms
- Title III
- The part of the ADA governing places of public accommodation and commercial facilities.
- Place of public accommodation
- A business open to the public, such as a store, restaurant, office of a service provider, or hotel.
- Readily achievable
- Easily accomplishable and able to be carried out without much difficulty or expense; the barrier-removal standard for existing facilities.
- Barrier removal
- Changes to existing facilities, such as ramps or door hardware, that improve access.
- 2010 ADA Standards
- The Department of Justice’s technical standards for accessible design.
- Alteration
- A change that affects the usability of a facility, which triggers compliance for the altered area.
- Primary function area
- An area where a major activity of the business takes place.
- Path of travel
- The accessible route to an altered primary function area, including restrooms, telephones, and drinking fountains serving it.
- Disproportionality
- The regulatory cost limit on path-of-travel work required by an alteration.
- Alternative methods
- Ways of providing access, such as curbside service, when barrier removal is not readily achievable.
- Mootness
- A defense that injunctive claims are resolved because the barrier has been permanently fixed.
- Tender
- A demand that another party, such as a landlord, tenant, or insurer, defend and indemnify a claim.
- Accessibility survey
- An inspection by a qualified consultant identifying barriers and remediation options.
- WCAG
- The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, commonly referenced in website accessibility claims.
Questions we hear most
We are only the landlord. Can we be sued for a tenant’s store?
Can a plaintiff recover money under the ADA?
What does readily achievable mean?
Does fixing the barrier end the case?
Should the lease address the ADA?
Is an older building grandfathered?
Are there tax incentives for barrier removal?
How are these cases usually resolved?
Can a website be a place of public accommodation?
Does the City Building Code differ from the ADA?
Tell us about your dispute
Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.