Contract Disputes and Specific Performance When a real estate contract does not close.

Failed closings turn on the contract’s terms and on what each side did when the deadline came. We represent buyers and sellers.

When a party refuses or fails to close, the remedies are specific performance, recovery or retention of the down payment, or damages.

A buyer seeking specific performance must generally show it was ready, willing, and able to close. A seller who keeps a defaulting buyer’s down payment may usually retain a deposit of up to ten percent without proving damages. Whether a closing date was “of the essence” often decides who was in default.

Early moves matter. A notice of pendency can protect a buyer’s claim against a sale to someone else, and a properly served time-of-the-essence notice can set up a default.

Our capabilities include:

  • Specific performance actions
  • Down payment and escrow disputes
  • Time-of-the-essence notices and defaults
  • Notices of pendency
  • Quiet title and boundary actions
  • Partition actions among co-owners

Related actions

  • Quiet title

    An action under RPAPL Article 15 to determine competing claims to real property.

  • Partition

    An action under RPAPL Article 9 to divide or sell property held by co-owners who cannot agree.

  • Misrepresentation and fraud

    Claims arising from false statements about the property, within the limits of the contract’s disclaimers.

  • Broker and escrow disputes

    Claims over commissions and funds held in escrow.

Key terms

Contract of sale
The written agreement to buy and sell real property, which sets the price, down payment, contingencies, and closing terms.
Statute of frauds
General Obligations Law § 5-703, which generally requires a contract to sell real property to be in a signed writing.
Down payment
The deposit paid on signing, typically held in escrow until closing; whether it is returned or kept depends on who defaults.
Escrow agent
The attorney or company holding the down payment, who must release it according to the contract and may refuse to release it if the parties dispute it.
Mortgage contingency
A clause allowing the buyer to cancel and recover the down payment if financing is not obtained by a stated date, on the clause’s conditions.
Specific performance
A court order directing a party to complete the sale, available because each parcel of real property is considered unique.
Ready, willing, and able
What a buyer seeking specific performance generally must show: that it had the funds and intent to close on the contract’s terms.
Time of the essence
A term making a closing date firm, so that failing to close on that date is a default; if the contract is silent, a party can generally set such a date by clear notice giving reasonable time.
Law day
The closing date set by a time-of-the-essence notice, on which the non-defaulting party appears ready to close to establish the other side’s default.
Anticipatory repudiation
A clear statement by one party, before closing, that it will not perform, which can allow the other party to pursue remedies without waiting.
Liquidated damages
An agreed amount of damages, often the down payment, that a seller may keep if a buyer defaults, in place of proving actual loss.
Notice of pendency
Also called a lis pendens, a notice filed under CPLR Article 65 that a lawsuit affects title, which generally remains effective for three years and can be extended.
Title objection
A defect, lien, or encumbrance shown in the title report that the seller may be required to cure before closing.
Marketable title
Title free of reasonable doubt that a prudent buyer would accept; many contracts define it by reference to what a title insurer will insure.
Property Condition Disclosure Statement
The form required by RPL Article 14 for many residential sales, describing the property’s known condition; a 2023 amendment ended the option of giving a credit instead.
Partition
An RPAPL Article 9 action to divide or sell property owned by co-owners who cannot agree.

Questions we hear most

Can I force the seller to close?

Possibly. Specific performance is available for real property because each parcel is unique, but you must show you were ready, willing, and able to close.

Will I get my down payment back?

It depends on who defaulted and the contract’s terms. A buyer who defaults generally forfeits a deposit of up to ten percent.

What is a notice of pendency?

A filing in the county clerk’s records that puts later buyers and lenders on notice of the lawsuit affecting title.

The seller backed out after we signed. What can I do?

You may be able to sue for specific performance, which asks the court to order the sale, or for return of your down payment and damages. You will generally need to show you were ready, willing, and able to close. Filing a notice of pendency early can protect your claim if the seller tries to sell to someone else.

Can a seller keep my down payment if my financing fell through?

If your contract has a mortgage contingency and you complied with it, including deadlines and good-faith application requirements, you may be entitled to its return. If the deadline passed or the conditions were not met, the seller may have a claim to keep it. The contract language decides.

What happens if neither side shows up on the closing date?

If time was not of the essence, missing the scheduled date usually is not by itself a default. Either party can generally make time of the essence by giving clear written notice that sets a reasonable new date. The party who then fails to close is usually in default.

Can I get damages in addition to specific performance?

Sometimes. Courts can award incidental damages along with specific performance in appropriate cases, such as for costs caused by the delay. A buyer who cannot obtain specific performance may seek damages, subject to the contract’s limits on remedies.

What if the title search shows a problem?

Many contracts give the seller a chance to cure title objections, and some limit the seller’s obligation to clear certain defects. If the seller cannot or will not cure, the buyer’s remedy is often a refund of the down payment and title costs. The contract’s title provisions control.

Is an email exchange a binding contract to sell property?

Possibly, if the writing includes the essential terms and is signed in a way the law recognizes, but courts look carefully at whether the parties intended to be bound before a formal contract. In New York practice, most parties do not consider a deal binding until a formal contract is signed and delivered.

How long does a notice of pendency last?

Under CPLR § 6513, a notice of pendency is generally effective for three years from filing and can be extended for good cause. It can be cancelled if the action is not prosecuted or if the claim does not affect title. Filing one improperly can expose a party to costs.

Can the escrow agent release the deposit without both parties agreeing?

Generally, an escrow agent must follow the contract’s escrow terms, which often require notice to the other party and allow the agent to hold the funds or deposit them with the court if there is a dispute. An agent who releases funds contrary to those terms can face liability.

The seller did not disclose a defect. Do I have a claim?

New York traditionally follows caveat emptor in real estate, and contracts often contain as-is clauses and disclaimers. Claims may still exist for active concealment, misrepresentation in the Property Condition Disclosure Statement, or facts peculiarly within the seller’s knowledge. The disclaimers in your contract are central.

My co-owner wants to sell and I do not. Can they force a sale?

A co-owner can generally bring a partition action under RPAPL Article 9, and the court may order the property divided or sold. Co-ownership agreements can limit that right. Partition cases often settle with one owner buying out the other.

Can a broker sue for a commission if the deal did not close?

It depends on the brokerage agreement and the reason the deal failed. Under New York law, a broker may earn a commission by producing a ready, willing, and able buyer, but many agreements condition the commission on closing. We review the agreement and the facts.
Contact

Tell us about your dispute

Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.

Send inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content