Fair housing and human rights claims.
A housing discrimination complaint can be filed with three different agencies or in court, under three overlapping laws. The New York City law is the broadest of them, and it is construed liberally in favor of those it protects.
We represent owners, managing agents, brokers, and co-op and condominium boards responding to fair housing complaints, and tenants and purchasers who believe they were treated unlawfully.
Three bodies of law apply in New York City: the federal Fair Housing Act, enforced by HUD and the federal courts; the New York State Human Rights Law, Executive Law § 296, enforced by the State Division of Human Rights; and the New York City Human Rights Law, Administrative Code § 8-107, enforced by the City Commission on Human Rights. Both the State and City laws prohibit discrimination based on lawful source of income, which generally includes housing vouchers, rental assistance, and public benefits. A listing that says “no vouchers,” or a policy that screens voucher holders out by income requirements, is a common basis for a complaint.
Most claims turn on process rather than intent. Agencies look at what the application asked, how income and credit standards were applied, how a request for a reasonable accommodation or modification was handled, and what was written down. The City law requires a housing provider to engage in a cooperative dialogue with a person who requests an accommodation and to give a written final determination. Consistent written criteria, trained staff, and prompt responses are the strongest protection an owner or board has.
Since January 1, 2025, the New York City Fair Chance for Housing Act, Local Law 24 of 2024, has limited when and how housing providers may consider criminal history. A provider generally must complete its review of an applicant’s other qualifications and extend a conditional offer before running a criminal background check, may consider only certain convictions within limited look-back periods, and must give the applicant an opportunity to respond and conduct an individualized assessment before denying.
Our capabilities include:
- Defense of complaints before the City Commission on Human Rights, the State Division of Human Rights, and HUD
- Source-of-income and voucher compliance
- Reasonable accommodation and modification requests and cooperative dialogue
- Co-op board admission and condominium sale claims
- Fair Chance for Housing Act screening procedures
- Advertising and listing review for owners and brokers
- Written policies and staff training
- Claims on behalf of tenants and purchasers
Where a claim can be filed
| NYC Commission on Human Rights | City Human Rights Law, Administrative Code § 8-107; the broadest list of protected classes |
|---|---|
| NYS Division of Human Rights | State Human Rights Law, Executive Law § 296; complaints generally within three years for conduct on or after February 15, 2024 |
| HUD | Federal Fair Housing Act; administrative complaints generally within one year of the conduct |
| Court | Each law also permits a lawsuit, subject to its own limitations period and election-of-remedies rules |
The Fair Chance for Housing Act in practice
Review everything else first
Evaluate income, credit, references, and other qualifications without asking about criminal history.
Make a conditional offer
Extend a conditional approval before any criminal background check, with the notice the Commission requires.
Limit what is considered
Consider only convictions and registry information the law permits, within its look-back periods.
Assess and respond
Share what was found, give the applicant time to respond, weigh the individual circumstances, and explain any denial in writing.
Key terms
- Fair Housing Act
- The federal statute prohibiting housing discrimination, enforced by HUD and the federal courts.
- State Human Rights Law
- Executive Law Article 15, including § 296, enforced by the New York State Division of Human Rights.
- City Human Rights Law
- Title 8 of the New York City Administrative Code, enforced by the City Commission on Human Rights.
- Lawful source of income
- A protected category under State and City law covering vouchers, rental assistance, and public benefits.
- Reasonable accommodation
- A change in a rule, policy, or practice that a person with a disability needs to use and enjoy housing.
- Reasonable modification
- A physical change to a unit or common area that a person with a disability needs.
- Cooperative dialogue
- The City law’s required good-faith exchange with a person requesting an accommodation, ending in a written determination.
- Disparate impact
- A claim that a neutral policy falls more heavily on a protected group without sufficient justification.
- Fair Chance for Housing Act
- Local Law 24 of 2024, limiting the use of criminal history in housing decisions since January 1, 2025.
- Conditional offer
- Approval of an applicant on all other criteria, required before a criminal background check under the Fair Chance law.
- Individualized assessment
- The review of a specific record, its age and relevance, and the applicant’s circumstances before any denial.
- Testing
- Use by agencies and advocates of matched applicants to detect discriminatory practices.
- Election of remedies
- Rules that may bar a court action after an administrative complaint on the same facts, subject to exceptions.
- Discriminatory advertising
- A listing or statement that indicates a preference or limitation based on a protected characteristic.
Questions we hear most
Can a landlord refuse a Section 8 or CityFHEPS voucher?
Does a co-op board have to explain why it rejected a buyer?
Can a building refuse an emotional support animal under a no-pet policy?
Can we still run criminal background checks in New York City?
Who can be named in a complaint?
What happens after a complaint is filed with the City Commission?
Are minimum income or credit requirements lawful?
What should a board do when it receives a complaint?
Does a reasonable accommodation request have to be in writing?
Who pays for a reasonable modification?
Tell us about your dispute
Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.