Appeals Appeals in real estate, estates, and commercial cases.

An appeal is decided on the record and the briefs, under deadlines that do not bend. The first decisions — whether to appeal and whether to seek a stay — are often made within days.

We represent appellants and respondents in the Appellate Division, the Appellate Term, and the Court of Appeals in real estate, landlord-tenant, estate, and commercial matters.

In New York civil cases, an appeal as of right is generally taken by serving and filing a notice of appeal within 30 days after service of the judgment or order with notice of entry, under CPLR 5513, with additional time where service was made by mail. Most appeals from Supreme Court and Surrogate’s Court go to the Appellate Division. In New York City, appeals from the Civil Court, including its Housing Part, generally go to the Appellate Term in the First and Second Departments.

Filing a notice of appeal does not stop enforcement. Except where CPLR 5519(a) provides an automatic stay, such as for certain money judgments secured by an undertaking, a party must ask the court for a stay under CPLR 5519(c). In landlord-tenant and foreclosure appeals, a stay is often the most important relief, and courts commonly condition it on payment of use and occupancy or posting security.

Under the Appellate Division’s practice rules, an appeal generally must be perfected within six months of the date of the notice of appeal, by filing the record or appendix and the brief, unless the time is extended. Appeals to the Court of Appeals lie as of right only in limited cases; most require leave, sought by motion within 30 days after service of the order with notice of entry.

Our capabilities include:

  • Evaluating whether and what to appeal
  • Notices of appeal and motions for leave to appeal
  • Motions for stays and interim relief
  • Records on appeal and appendices
  • Appellate briefs and oral argument
  • Appellate Term appeals from Civil and Housing Court
  • Court of Appeals leave applications
  • Responding to appeals for prevailing parties

Key appellate deadlines

Notice of appeal as of right30 days after service of the order or judgment with notice of entry (CPLR 5513), plus time for service by mail
Motion for leave to appeal30 days after service of the order with notice of entry
Perfecting in the Appellate DivisionGenerally within 6 months of the notice of appeal, unless extended
Stay of enforcementAutomatic only in cases under CPLR 5519(a); otherwise by motion under CPLR 5519(c)

How an appeal moves

  1. Preserve and decide

    Confirm the issues were preserved below and decide quickly whether to appeal.

  2. Notice and stay

    Serve and file the notice of appeal and, if needed, move for a stay.

  3. Record

    Assemble the record or appendix from the papers, transcripts, and exhibits before the lower court.

  4. Brief and argue

    File the briefs within the court’s schedule and present oral argument where allowed.

  5. Further review

    After decision, consider reargument or leave to appeal to the Court of Appeals.

Key terms

Appellate Division
New York’s intermediate appellate court, organized in four judicial departments.
Appellate Term
The court in the First and Second Departments that hears appeals from Civil Court and certain other lower courts.
Court of Appeals
New York’s highest court.
Notice of appeal
The document that starts an appeal as of right.
Notice of entry
Notice that an order or judgment was entered, which starts the time to appeal when served.
CPLR 5513
The rule setting the time to take an appeal or move for leave.
Perfecting an appeal
Filing the record or appendix and the appellant’s brief.
Record on appeal
The papers, transcripts, and exhibits from the lower court on which the appeal is decided.
Appendix method
A method of perfecting with an appendix of relevant papers instead of the full record.
CPLR 5519
The rule governing stays of enforcement pending appeal.
Undertaking
Security posted to obtain a stay or protect the other side.
Leave to appeal
Permission to appeal, required where there is no appeal as of right.
Preservation
The requirement that an issue have been raised in the lower court.
Reargument
A motion asking the same court to reconsider a decision for points overlooked or misapprehended.

Questions we hear most

How long do I have to file a notice of appeal in New York?

Generally 30 days after you are served with the order or judgment with notice of entry, under CPLR 5513, with additional time if service was made by mail. Missing the deadline usually ends the right to appeal.

Can I appeal a Housing Court decision?

Yes. In New York City, appeals from Civil Court, including Housing Court, generally go to the Appellate Term of the First or Second Department.

Will filing an appeal stop my eviction or foreclosure sale?

Not automatically in most cases. You must usually move for a stay, and courts often require payment of use and occupancy or security as a condition.

Can I raise new arguments on appeal?

Generally no. Appellate courts usually consider only issues preserved in the lower court, with limited exceptions for pure questions of law apparent on the record.

Can an interim order be appealed?

In the Appellate Division, many non-final orders in civil cases are appealable as of right under the CPLR, which is broader than in many other courts. Rules differ for appeals to the Court of Appeals.

How long does an appeal take?

Usually many months from notice of appeal to decision, depending on when the appeal is perfected and the court’s calendar.

What does an appeal cost?

Costs depend on the size of the record, transcript costs, the complexity of the issues, and whether there is a stay motion. We give an estimate after reviewing the record.

Can a respondent cross-appeal?

Yes, by serving a notice of cross-appeal within the time allowed under CPLR 5513, which includes additional time after service of the other side’s notice of appeal.

What standard of review applies?

It depends on the issue. Questions of law are reviewed fresh, while factual findings and discretionary rulings receive deference, and the Appellate Division has broad power to review facts and discretion.

Can a Surrogate’s Court decree be appealed?

Yes. Appeals from Surrogate’s Court generally go to the Appellate Division under the same CPLR rules.
Contact

Tell us about your dispute

Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.

Send inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content