Good Cause Eviction for Landlords Good Cause Eviction for property owners.
Since April 2024, many New York City market-rate apartments can be recovered only for good cause, and large rent increases must be justified. Knowing which units are covered is the first step.
The Good Cause Eviction Law, Real Property Law Article 6-A, applies to eviction proceedings commenced on or after April 20, 2024 in New York City and in municipalities that opt in.
For covered apartments, an owner needs a statutory ground — such as non-payment, a substantial lease violation, nuisance, illegal use, unreasonable refusal of access, or occupancy by the owner or a family member under the law’s conditions — to evict or decline to renew. A rent increase above the local rent standard, set each year at inflation plus five percent with a ten percent ceiling (currently 8.38 percent in New York City), is presumed unreasonable, though the owner may rebut the presumption with evidence such as higher taxes or significant repairs.
Exemptions do much of the work. Small landlords who own ten or fewer units in New York State, owner-occupied buildings of ten or fewer units, rent-regulated and income-restricted units, co-ops and condos, newer buildings for 30 years after their certificate of occupancy, and high-rent units above 245 percent of fair market rent are among the exemptions. An owner who claims the small-landlord exemption in court must disclose its holdings.
Our capabilities include:
- Unit-by-unit coverage and exemption analysis
- Rent increase planning under the local rent standard
- Required Good Cause notices for leases, renewals, and proceedings
- Non-renewals and holdover proceedings on statutory grounds
- Rebutting the unreasonable-increase presumption
- Portfolio and LLC ownership analysis for the small-landlord exemption
Common exemptions
Small landlords
Owners of ten or fewer units in New York State; for an LLC, each individual owner must meet the limit.
Owner-occupied buildings
Buildings of ten or fewer units in which the owner lives.
Regulated and affordable units
Apartments already subject to rent regulation or income restrictions.
Co-ops and condos
Units in cooperative and condominium buildings.
Newer buildings
Buildings with a first certificate of occupancy on or after January 1, 2009, for 30 years.
High-rent units
Units renting above 245 percent of HUD fair market rent.
Key terms
- Good Cause Eviction Law
- Real Property Law Article 6-A, which limits the grounds for eviction and non-renewal and sets a presumptive cap on rent increases for covered apartments.
- Covered unit
- A residential apartment subject to the law because it is not exempt under one of the statute’s exemptions.
- Local rent standard
- The annual increase threshold, equal to inflation plus five percent with a ceiling of ten percent, that DHCR publishes; increases above it are presumed unreasonable.
- Rebuttable presumption
- The law’s assumption that an increase above the local rent standard is unreasonable, which the owner can overcome with evidence such as higher costs or significant repairs.
- Good cause ground
- A statutory reason that allows an owner to evict or decline to renew, such as non-payment, a substantial lease violation, nuisance, illegal use, or refusal of reasonable access.
- Small landlord exemption
- The exemption for owners who own no more than ten residential units in New York State.
- Owner-occupied exemption
- The exemption for buildings of ten or fewer units in which the owner lives.
- New construction exemption
- The exemption for buildings with a first certificate of occupancy on or after January 1, 2009, for 30 years.
- High-rent exemption
- The exemption for units whose rent exceeds 245 percent of the fair market rent published by HUD for the area.
- Fair market rent
- The HUD-published rent benchmark used to calculate the high-rent exemption threshold.
- Good Cause notice
- The notice owners must give tenants explaining whether the apartment is covered and, if exempt, the basis for the exemption.
- Ownership disclosure
- The information an owner claiming the small-landlord exemption must provide, including the holdings of the entity and its individual owners.
- Reasonable renewal terms
- Renewal lease terms that comply with the law; a tenant’s refusal to sign a renewal on reasonable terms can be a ground for non-renewal.
- Owner use
- A ground, subject to the law’s conditions, allowing an owner or immediate family member to recover a unit for personal use as a primary residence.
- Opt-in municipality
- A city or village outside New York City that has chosen to adopt the law, sometimes with local modifications.
Questions we hear most
How much can I raise the rent on a covered apartment?
Do I have to give tenants a notice about Good Cause?
I own buildings through several LLCs. Am I a small landlord?
Does Good Cause apply to apartments I rent out in a two-family house I live in?
Can I still evict for non-payment?
What evidence rebuts the presumption that an increase is unreasonable?
How do I calculate the 245 percent of fair market rent threshold?
Does the law apply to my commercial tenants?
Are there penalties for a wrong exemption claim?
Can I decline to renew to sell the building or renovate?
Do I need to say anything about Good Cause in my court papers?
Does Good Cause apply to rent-stabilized apartments?
Do the same rules apply outside New York City?
What if a tenant is not paying because of a repair dispute?
Tell us about your dispute
Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.