Eminent domain and condemnation.

When a government or authority takes property, the owner has two questions: whether the taking can be stopped, and what it will be paid. The deadlines for each are short and unforgiving.

We represent owners, commercial tenants, and lenders whose property or leasehold interests are taken or affected by condemnation in New York.

The Eminent Domain Procedure Law governs most takings in New York. Before acquiring property, a condemnor generally must hold a public hearing under EDPL Article 2 and then make and publish a determination and findings. An owner who wants to challenge the taking itself must petition the Appellate Division within 30 days after the condemnor completes publication of that determination, under EDPL § 207. The court’s review is limited to whether the proceeding was constitutional, within the condemnor’s authority, procedurally proper, and for a public use, benefit, or purpose.

Most cases are about compensation. Just compensation is generally measured by the fair market value of the property taken for its most valuable reasonably probable use, and, in a partial taking, by the loss in value to the remainder. After acquisition, the condemnor must make a written offer, and an owner may generally accept it as an advance payment without giving up the right to claim more. Owners and tenants should be ready to prove value with appraisals and, where relevant, evidence of fixtures and improvements.

Claims follow two tracks. For acquisitions by the State, the claim is heard in the Court of Claims and must generally be filed within three years after service of the notice of acquisition or the date of vesting, whichever is later; a failure to file is deemed an acceptance of the amount paid. For other condemnors, such as the City, claims are heard in Supreme Court within the time the court sets. Where the award substantially exceeds the condemnor’s offer, the court may award additional fees under EDPL § 701.

Our capabilities include:

  • Challenges to takings in the Appellate Division under EDPL § 207
  • Participation in EDPL Article 2 public hearings
  • Just compensation claims in the Court of Claims and Supreme Court
  • Partial takings, easements, and damage to the remainder
  • Tenant claims for leasehold value and trade fixtures
  • Advance payment and offer negotiations
  • Allocation of awards among owners, tenants, and lenders
  • Coordination with appraisers and relocation assistance

How a New York taking proceeds

  1. Public hearing

    The condemnor generally holds an EDPL Article 2 hearing on the project; owners can appear and submit comments, which also preserves the record.

  2. Determination and findings

    The condemnor publishes its determination and findings, and the 30-day period to challenge in the Appellate Division begins when publication is complete.

  3. Acquisition and vesting

    Title vests in the condemnor on filing of the acquisition map or as the court orders, depending on the condemnor.

  4. Offer and advance payment

    The condemnor makes a written offer, which the owner may generally accept as an advance payment while preserving its claim.

  5. Claim and trial

    The owner files its claim in the Court of Claims or Supreme Court and proves value, typically through appraisals.

What compensation can include

  • Land and improvements

    Fair market value of the property taken, considering its most valuable reasonably probable use.

  • Damage to the remainder

    In a partial taking, the reduction in value of the property left behind.

  • Trade fixtures

    Fixtures installed by an owner or tenant can be compensable when they are taken with the real property.

  • Leasehold interests

    Tenants may claim the value of a lease where its terms are more favorable than market, subject to the lease’s condemnation clause.

  • Interest and fees

    Interest from vesting and, in qualifying cases, an additional allowance for fees and appraisal costs.

Key terms

Eminent domain
The government’s power to take private property for public use on payment of just compensation.
EDPL
The Eminent Domain Procedure Law, which governs most condemnations in New York.
Condemnor
The government or authority taking the property.
Condemnee
The owner or other holder of an interest in property being taken.
Determination and findings
The condemnor’s published decision to proceed after the public hearing.
EDPL § 207
The provision for challenging a taking in the Appellate Division within 30 days after publication.
Public use
The constitutional requirement that a taking serve a public use, benefit, or purpose.
Vesting
The point at which title passes to the condemnor.
Advance payment
Payment of the condemnor’s offer that the owner may accept without waiving a claim for more.
Just compensation
Payment for property taken, generally measured by fair market value for the property’s most valuable reasonably probable use.
Highest-value use
The reasonably probable, legally permitted use that produces the greatest value, on which appraisals are based.
Partial taking
A taking of part of a parcel, which may support a claim for damage to the remainder.
Trade fixtures
Equipment and improvements installed for a business, which may be compensable.
Court of Claims
The court that hears claims arising from acquisitions by the State.
Additional allowance
Fees and costs the court may award under EDPL § 701 when the award substantially exceeds the offer.

Questions we hear most

Can I stop the government from taking my property?

Sometimes, but the window is short. A challenge must be filed in the Appellate Division within 30 days after the condemnor completes publication of its determination and findings, and courts generally defer to a condemnor’s finding of public use.

Should I accept the condemnor’s offer?

An owner may generally accept the offer as an advance payment while reserving the right to claim more. The offer is the condemnor’s number, and owners commonly obtain their own appraisal before deciding.

I am a commercial tenant. Do I get anything?

Possibly. Tenants may claim for the value of their leasehold and for trade fixtures, but many leases contain condemnation clauses that terminate the lease or assign the award to the landlord, so the lease must be reviewed first.

How long do I have to file a claim?

For State acquisitions, the claim must generally be filed within three years after service of the notice of acquisition or the vesting date, whichever is later. For other condemnors, the court sets the deadline, so the notice must be read carefully.

What is the public hearing for?

It is the public’s opportunity to comment on the project, and for owners it builds the record a court will review in any later challenge. Issues not raised there may be harder to raise later.

Are any takings exempt from a hearing?

Yes. The EDPL exempts certain acquisitions from the hearing requirement, including some where a comparable hearing was held under another law. Whether an exemption applies should be checked early.

Who owns the award when there is a mortgage?

The lender generally has a claim to the award up to the debt, and the mortgage may give it rights to participate in the proceeding. The allocation among owner, lender, and tenants is often negotiated or decided by the court.

How is a business compensated for moving?

Relocation assistance is generally provided under separate programs rather than as part of just compensation, and eligibility depends on the condemnor and its funding. Claims for lost business profits are generally not compensable in New York.

Does the condemnor pay my appraiser?

Not ordinarily. Where the award is substantially higher than the condemnor’s proof or offer, the court may grant an additional allowance for appraisal and attorney’s fees under EDPL § 701.

What if only an easement is taken?

The owner is compensated for the loss in value caused by the easement, including any effect on the remainder of the property.
Contact

Tell us about your dispute

Whether you are a tenant facing eviction, an owner with a non-paying or non-compliant tenant, or a party to a contract that did not close, we welcome the conversation. Initial consultations are complimentary. If a court date is approaching, please include it in your message.

Send inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content