Trust Decanting and Modification Decanting and modifying irrevocable trusts in New York.
An irrevocable trust is hard to change, not impossible. New York offers several routes, and each has its own limits, notice rules, and risks.
We represent trustees, grantors, and beneficiaries in decanting irrevocable trusts, amending trusts by consent, and bringing or opposing construction, reformation, and trustee appointment proceedings.
Trusts written decades ago often no longer fit the family, the assets, or the tax law. The administrative terms may be outdated, the trustee provisions unworkable, or a beneficiary may now need a supplemental needs trust to protect government benefits. New York law offers four main routes to change: decanting by the trustee under EPTL § 10-6.6; revocation or amendment by the grantor with the written, acknowledged consent of every beneficially interested person under EPTL § 7-1.9; a court proceeding to construe or, in limited cases, reform the instrument; and changing the trustees. As of this writing, New York has not enacted a general statute authorizing nonjudicial settlement agreements of the kind found in states that adopted the Uniform Trust Code, so agreements among family members do not, on their own, change a trust’s terms.
Decanting is a trustee’s power, not a beneficiary’s. Under EPTL § 10-6.6, an authorized trustee, which the statute defines to exclude the grantor and any trustee who is a current or possible beneficiary, may appoint trust principal to a new irrevocable trust. A trustee with unlimited discretion to distribute principal has broad latitude to change the beneficial terms; a trustee whose discretion is limited, for example by a health, education, maintenance, and support standard, may generally change only administrative and certain other terms and must keep the same beneficiaries and distribution standards. The statute bars a decanting that reduces a beneficiary’s current right to mandatory income or principal, an annuity, or a unitrust amount once it has taken effect, that exonerates the trustee for failing to use reasonable care, or that would jeopardize certain tax benefits. The trustee acts by a signed, acknowledged instrument served on the grantor, anyone with power to remove the trustee, and the interested persons, and the decanting takes effect 30 days after service unless they all consent to an earlier date.
The limits are real. In Matter of Chheda, decided by the Erie County Surrogate’s Court in August 2025, beneficiary co-trustees of a testamentary trust asked the court to appoint a non-beneficiary co-trustee so the trust could be decanted. The court denied the petition, noting that beneficiary-trustees are not authorized trustees under the statute, that the proposed changes would have reduced the rights of the income beneficiary, and that SCPA § 1502(2) bars appointing a trustee where the appointment would contravene the will’s express terms. A trustee also generally may not decant where there is substantial evidence that the grantor would have opposed the change, unless it can be shown that the grantor would likely have changed that intent in light of later circumstances, so the record of the grantor’s intent matters as much as the trustee’s powers.
Our capabilities include:
- Decanting irrevocable trusts under EPTL § 10-6.6
- Consent amendments and revocations of lifetime trusts under EPTL § 7-1.9
- Converting trusts to supplemental needs trusts for beneficiaries with disabilities
- Construction proceedings to resolve ambiguous trust and will provisions
- Reformation proceedings to correct drafting mistakes
- Trustee resignation, removal, and appointment of successor and co-trustees
- Changing trust administration, governing law, and situs where permitted
- Representing beneficiaries who object to a proposed decanting or modification
Routes to change an irrevocable trust
| Decanting (EPTL § 10-6.6) | An authorized trustee appoints principal to a new trust; no court approval required, though the trustee may seek it; 30-day notice |
|---|---|
| Consent amendment (EPTL § 7-1.9) | The grantor revokes or amends a lifetime trust with the written, acknowledged consent of all persons beneficially interested |
| Construction (SCPA § 1420; CPLR Article 77) | A court interprets ambiguous language and binds the parties to the proceeding |
| Reformation | A court corrects the instrument in limited circumstances, generally on clear proof of a mistake or of the grantor’s intent |
| Trustee changes | Resignation, removal, or appointment of successors under the instrument or by the court, subject to the instrument’s terms (SCPA § 1502(2)) |
| Nonjudicial settlement | No general enacted statute in New York as of this writing |
How a decanting works
Confirm the power
Read the trust to determine whether an authorized trustee has unlimited or limited discretion over principal and whether the trust expressly prohibits decanting.
Check the limits
Confirm the change will not reduce a vested mandatory right, exonerate the trustee, eliminate removal rights, or jeopardize tax treatment, and look for evidence of contrary grantor intent.
Draft the new trust
Prepare the appointed trust and the decanting instrument, stating whether all or part of the principal is appointed.
Serve notice
Serve the signed, acknowledged instrument on the grantor if living, anyone with power to remove the trustee, and the interested persons. The decanting takes effect 30 days after service unless all consent earlier.
File and administer
Keep a copy with the trust records and, where required, file the original with the court that has jurisdiction over the trust within 20 days after the effective date.
Key terms
- Decanting
- A trustee’s exercise of the power under EPTL § 10-6.6 to appoint principal from one trust to a new irrevocable trust.
- Invaded trust
- The existing trust whose principal is appointed in a decanting.
- Appointed trust
- The new irrevocable trust that receives principal in a decanting.
- Authorized trustee
- A trustee with authority to pay principal to a current beneficiary, other than the grantor or a current or possible beneficiary.
- Unlimited discretion
- An unlimited right to distribute principal that is not limited or modified by terms such as an ascertainable standard.
- Limited discretion
- A power to distribute principal subject to a standard, such as health, education, maintenance, and support.
- Mandatory right
- A current right to income, principal, an annuity, or a unitrust amount, or a withdrawal right, that a decanting may not reduce once it has taken effect.
- Supplemental needs trust
- A trust that supplements, rather than replaces, government benefits for a person with a disability (EPTL § 7-1.12).
- Persons beneficially interested
- Everyone with a beneficial interest in a trust whose written consent EPTL § 7-1.9 requires for a consent amendment.
- Testamentary trust
- A trust created by a will, which takes effect after death and is generally supervised by the Surrogate’s Court.
- Lifetime trust
- A trust created during the grantor’s life, also called an inter vivos trust.
- Construction
- A court’s determination of what ambiguous language in a will or trust means.
- Reformation
- A court’s correction of a trust or will to reflect the creator’s intent, available only in limited circumstances.
- Situs
- The place where a trust is administered, which can affect governing law, court jurisdiction, and state income tax.
- Spendthrift provision
- A clause preventing a beneficiary from assigning an interest. Under EPTL § 10-6.6, it does not by itself prevent a decanting.
- Nonjudicial settlement agreement
- An agreement among interested parties that resolves trust matters without court approval, authorized by statute in many states but not generally in New York as of this writing.
Questions we hear most
Can a trustee who is also a beneficiary decant?
Does decanting require court approval?
Can beneficiaries and the grantor agree to change a trust?
Can a decanting reduce my income from a trust?
Who must be notified of a decanting?
Can a beneficiary stop a decanting?
Can decanting extend the length of a trust?
Can a trustee change its own commissions by decanting?
Does a spendthrift clause prevent decanting?
Can an old trust be moved to another state?
Schedule a consultation
Estate planning conversations are among the most personal we have with clients. Tell us what you would like to accomplish. Initial consultations are complimentary and confidential, and we quote fees clearly at the outset — a flat fee for a standard estate plan.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Schedule a consultation
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.