Estate Litigation and Will Contests Estate litigation in Surrogate’s Court.
When a family disagrees about a will, a trust, or how a fiduciary is handling an estate, the dispute is usually decided in Surrogate’s Court. We represent fiduciaries and beneficiaries on both sides.
Estate disputes range from challenges to the validity of a will to objections to an executor’s accounting and petitions to remove a fiduciary.
At a glance
| Forum | Surrogate’s Court of the county where the estate is administered |
|---|---|
| Pre-objection examinations | Attesting witnesses and the drafting attorney may be examined (SCPA § 1404) |
| Common grounds | Lack of capacity, undue influence, fraud, duress, or improper execution under EPTL § 3-2.1 |
| Who may object | A person whose interest would be adversely affected by probate (SCPA § 1410) |
| No-contest clauses | Enforceable, but EPTL § 3-3.5 protects listed acts such as an SCPA § 1404 examination |
| Compelling an accounting | An interested person may petition to compel a fiduciary to account (SCPA § 2205) |
| Removing a fiduciary | The court may suspend or remove a fiduciary on statutory grounds (SCPA §§ 711, 719) |
A will contest begins with objections to probate. Before deciding whether to object, interested parties may generally examine the attesting witnesses and the drafting attorney under SCPA § 1404. Objections commonly allege lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution, and the burdens of proof differ for each.
Many disputes arise after a will is admitted. Beneficiaries may object to an executor’s or trustee’s accounting, seek to compel an accounting, ask the court to construe ambiguous language, or petition to suspend or remove a fiduciary who is not acting properly.
Our capabilities include:
- Objections to probate and defense of wills
- SCPA § 1404 examinations
- Undue influence and capacity claims
- Accounting proceedings and objections
- Fiduciary removal and surcharge
- Will and trust construction proceedings
Common estate disputes
Lack of capacity
Whether the testator understood the nature of making a will, the extent of the property, and the natural objects of their bounty.
Undue influence
Whether someone exerted influence that overcame the testator’s free will and substituted their own wishes.
Due execution
Whether the will was signed and witnessed as EPTL § 3-2.1 requires.
In terrorem clauses
A no-contest clause can forfeit a beneficiary’s gift if they contest the will, subject to the safe harbors in EPTL § 3-3.5, which include an SCPA § 1404 examination.
Accountings
Objections to how a fiduciary collected, invested, spent, or distributed estate or trust assets.
Removal and construction
Petitions to suspend or remove a fiduciary, and proceedings asking the court to interpret a will or trust.
Key terms
- Objectant
- A party who files objections to probate or to a fiduciary’s account.
- Proponent
- The party offering a will for probate, usually the named executor, who bears the burden of proving due execution and capacity.
- Testamentary capacity
- The mental ability to make a will: understanding the nature of the act, the nature and extent of one’s property, and the natural objects of one’s bounty.
- Undue influence
- Influence that overpowers the testator’s will so the document reflects another person’s wishes. The objectant generally bears the burden of proving it.
- Confidential relationship
- A relationship of trust and dependence that can shift the burden to the beneficiary to explain the transaction in some undue influence cases.
- Fraud
- A knowingly false statement that induced the testator to make a will or a provision they otherwise would not have made.
- Presumption of regularity
- When an attorney supervises the execution, a presumption generally arises that the will was properly executed.
- SCPA § 1404 examination
- Pre-objection depositions of the attesting witnesses and the drafting attorney, and in some circumstances the nominated executor.
- In terrorem clause
- A no-contest clause that forfeits a beneficiary’s gift if they challenge the will, subject to the safe harbors of EPTL § 3-3.5.
- Putnam inquiry
- Heightened scrutiny, from Matter of Putnam, when the attorney who drafted the will is also a beneficiary.
- Compulsory accounting
- A proceeding under SCPA § 2205 compelling a fiduciary to account.
- Surcharge
- A judgment holding a fiduciary personally liable for losses caused by a breach of duty.
- Construction proceeding
- A proceeding under SCPA § 1420 asking the court to interpret ambiguous language in a will.
- Suspension and revocation of letters
- Relief under SCPA § 711 against a fiduciary who has, for example, wasted assets or failed to follow court orders.
- Turnover proceeding
- A proceeding under SCPA § 2103 to recover property belonging to the estate.
- Jury trial
- Contested probate proceedings may be tried before a jury on demand, though many are decided on summary judgment or settled.
Questions we hear most
Who can contest a will?
Will a no-contest clause stop me from examining witnesses?
Do estate disputes always go to trial?
Can I make an executor account for the estate?
How strong is a will contest generally?
What is the time period for discovery in a will contest?
Can a lifetime gift or joint account be challenged?
What evidence supports an undue influence claim?
Does a diagnosis of dementia mean the will is invalid?
Who pays the legal fees in an estate dispute?
Can an executor be removed?
Which court hears trust disputes?
Is there a deadline to contest a will?
Can a will be contested after the executor has distributed assets?
Do you represent executors as well as beneficiaries?
What is a kinship proceeding?
Schedule a consultation
Estate planning conversations are among the most personal we have with clients. Tell us what you would like to accomplish. Initial consultations are complimentary and confidential, and we quote fees clearly at the outset — a flat fee for a standard estate plan.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Schedule a consultation
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.