Private Foundations Private foundations for New York families.
A private foundation gives a family control over its giving and a lasting institution, in exchange for annual filings, a minimum payout, and strict rules on dealings with insiders. The choice of vehicle and the governing documents decide how well it works.
We represent individuals, families, and family businesses in forming private foundations, and the directors, trustees, and officers who run them.
A family that wants to give at scale usually chooses among three vehicles. A donor-advised fund is an account at a sponsoring public charity: the donor receives an immediate deduction and recommends grants, but the sponsor has legal control. A supporting organization is a public charity organized to support one or more specified charities and cannot be controlled by the donor. A private foundation is the family’s own charity, with its own board and investment policy, and generally lower income tax deduction limits: for gifts to a private nonoperating foundation, 30% of adjusted gross income for cash and 20% for capital gain property, with gifts of appreciated property other than qualified appreciated stock generally deductible only at basis.
In New York, the first structural choice is a corporation or a trust. A not-for-profit corporation formed under the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law has a board of directors, limited liability, and bylaws that can be amended as the family changes, and it must follow the statute’s rules on related party transactions and conflict of interest policies. A charitable trust is governed by its trust instrument and the EPTL, which imposes parallel related party and conflict of interest rules, and changes to its purposes generally require a court proceeding. Either way, the foundation registers with the Attorney General’s Charities Bureau under EPTL § 8-1.4 and files annual reports, which the Bureau receives through its CHAR500 filing, with fees that scale with net worth from $25 to $1,500.
Federal law then applies the private foundation rules. The foundation pays an excise tax of 1.39% on net investment income, must make qualifying distributions each year at least equal to 5% of the value of its non-charitable-use assets, generally by the end of the following year, and must avoid self-dealing with substantial contributors, managers, and their families, excess business holdings, jeopardizing investments, and taxable expenditures. The 2025 federal tax law did not change those rules, but it did change individual charitable deductions beginning in 2026, so the timing of gifts to a foundation deserves attention.
Our capabilities include:
- Choosing among a private foundation, donor-advised fund, and supporting organization
- Not-for-profit corporation formation and charitable trust drafting
- IRS Form 1023 exemption applications
- Charities Bureau registration and CHAR500 annual filings
- Bylaws, conflict of interest policies, and related party transaction procedures
- Self-dealing, excess business holdings, and payout compliance
- Gifts of real estate and closely held interests to a foundation
- Succession of family boards, mergers, conversions, and terminations
Three vehicles compared
| Private foundation | Family control of grants, investments, and the board; 1.39% tax on net investment income; 5% minimum distribution; self-dealing and other excise tax rules; annual return open to the public |
|---|---|
| Donor-advised fund | Account at a sponsoring charity; immediate deduction at public charity limits; donor recommends grants; sponsor has legal control; no grants that give the donor more than an incidental benefit |
| Supporting organization | A public charity under IRC § 509(a)(3) that supports named charities; public charity deduction limits; donors and their families may not control it |
| Private operating foundation | A foundation that runs its own charitable programs, such as a museum or research program, and qualifies for different rules |
Rules a foundation’s managers must follow
Self-dealing (IRC § 4941)
Sales, leases, loans, and most other transactions between the foundation and a disqualified person are prohibited even if fair; reasonable compensation for necessary personal services is a narrow exception. The initial tax is 10% of the amount involved on the self-dealer and 5% on a manager who knowingly participates.
Minimum distributions (IRC § 4942)
Qualifying distributions equal to the distributable amount, based on 5% of non-charitable-use assets, generally by the end of the following year; an initial 30% tax applies to the shortfall.
Excess business holdings (IRC § 4943)
The foundation and its disqualified persons together generally may not own more than 20% of the voting stock of a business, with a 2% de minimis rule.
Jeopardizing investments (IRC § 4944)
Investments made without ordinary business care and prudence are taxed at 10% of the amount invested, with a separate tax on managers.
Taxable expenditures (IRC § 4945)
Lobbying, political activity, and certain grants to individuals or non-charities without required procedures trigger an initial 20% tax.
Forming a New York foundation
Choose the vehicle and form
Decide between a corporation and a trust, and draft the certificate of incorporation or trust instrument with the purposes and provisions the IRS requires.
Adopt governance documents
Adopt bylaws, a conflict of interest policy, and procedures for related party transactions, grants, and investments.
Apply for exemption
File Form 1023 electronically; filing within 27 months after the end of the month of formation makes recognition retroactive to formation.
Register in New York
Register with the Charities Bureau and calendar the annual CHAR500 and Form 990-PF filings.
Fund and operate
Transfer assets with attention to the deduction limits and self-dealing rules, and make grants that meet the payout requirement.
Key terms
- Private foundation
- A § 501(c)(3) charity that does not qualify as a public charity, typically funded by one family or company.
- Private operating foundation
- A private foundation that conducts its own charitable activities and meets federal tests for that status.
- Donor-advised fund
- An account at a sponsoring charity over which the donor has advisory privileges but the sponsor has legal control.
- Supporting organization
- A public charity under IRC § 509(a)(3) organized to support one or more specified public charities.
- Disqualified person
- A substantial contributor, foundation manager, certain owners of a substantial contributor, their family members, and entities they control.
- Self-dealing
- A prohibited transaction between a private foundation and a disqualified person, taxed under IRC § 4941.
- Qualifying distribution
- A grant or expenditure for charitable purposes, including reasonable administrative expenses, that counts toward the payout requirement.
- Minimum investment return
- 5% of the fair market value of a foundation’s non-charitable-use assets, less acquisition indebtedness, used to compute the payout.
- Excess business holdings
- Holdings in a business above the limits of IRC § 4943, generally 20% of voting stock combined with disqualified persons.
- Jeopardizing investment
- An investment made without ordinary business care and prudence, taxed under IRC § 4944.
- Taxable expenditure
- A prohibited expenditure under IRC § 4945, such as lobbying or a grant made without required procedures.
- Expenditure responsibility
- The procedures a foundation must follow when it makes certain grants to organizations that are not public charities.
- Form 990-PF
- The annual federal return of a private foundation, which is available for public inspection.
- CHAR500
- The annual filing submitted to the New York Attorney General’s Charities Bureau, with the federal return attached.
- EPTL § 8-1.4
- The New York statute requiring trustees and charitable corporations holding property for charitable purposes to register and report.
- Related party transaction
- A transaction in which a director, officer, key person, or relative has a financial interest, regulated by N-PCL § 715 and EPTL § 8-1.9.
Questions we hear most
How much money does a private foundation need?
Can family members be paid by the foundation?
Can a foundation own part of the family business?
Does a private foundation register with New York?
Is a foundation’s information public?
What is the tax on a foundation’s investment income?
Can I give real estate to my foundation?
What happens if the foundation misses its payout?
Can a foundation be converted or closed later?
Does a New York foundation need a conflict of interest policy?
Schedule a consultation
Estate planning conversations are among the most personal we have with clients. Tell us what you would like to accomplish. Initial consultations are complimentary and confidential, and we quote fees clearly at the outset — a flat fee for a standard estate plan.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Schedule a consultation
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.