Guardianship Guardianship, and how to avoid needing it.

When an adult can no longer manage their affairs and has no valid power of attorney or proxy, a court may need to appoint a guardian. We represent families in that process and help clients plan so it is never required.

New York has two guardianship statutes for adults: Article 81 of the Mental Hygiene Law and Article 17-A of the Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act.

At a glance

Two statutesMental Hygiene Law Article 81 and SCPA Article 17-A
Article 81Supreme Court (or County Court outside NYC); powers tailored to need, least restrictive form (MHL § 81.02)
Article 81 standard of proofIncapacity must be shown by clear and convincing evidence (MHL § 81.02(b))
Article 17-ASurrogate’s Court; for a person with an intellectual or developmental disability (SCPA §§ 1750, 1750-a)
Article 17-A proofCertifications by two qualified professionals, such as two physicians or a physician and a psychologist
AlternativesPowers of attorney, health care proxies, trusts, and supported decision-making agreements (MHL Article 82)

Article 81 guardianship is brought in Supreme Court (or, outside New York City, also in County Court) for an adult who, because of functional limitations, cannot manage personal needs or property and does not understand and appreciate those limitations. The court must tailor the guardian’s powers to the person’s actual needs and use the least restrictive form of intervention. Article 17-A guardianship is brought in Surrogate’s Court for a person with an intellectual or developmental disability, and is often used by parents when a child turns 18.

Most guardianships can be avoided with planning. A durable power of attorney, a health care proxy, and, where appropriate, a revocable trust allow trusted people to act without a court proceeding, and supported decision-making agreements can help some adults with disabilities keep making their own decisions.

Our capabilities include:

  • Article 81 petitions for family members
  • Representation of respondents and cross-petitioners
  • Article 17-A guardianship for adults with developmental disabilities
  • Standby and successor guardian designations
  • Guardianship alternatives: powers of attorney, proxies, and trusts
  • Supported decision-making agreements

Article 81 and Article 17-A compared

StatuteMental Hygiene Law Article 81 / SCPA Article 17-A
CourtSupreme Court / Surrogate’s Court
Who it coversAdults with functional limitations from any cause / persons with intellectual or developmental disabilities
Scope of powersTailored to specific needs / generally broader, plenary authority
ProcessCourt evaluator, hearing, and findings on functional limitations / certifications by qualified professionals, with a hearing that may be dispensed with in some cases
ReportingInitial and annual reports to the court / generally less extensive reporting

How planning avoids guardianship

  • Durable power of attorney

    Lets an agent you choose handle finances, real estate, and benefits without a court order.

  • Health care proxy

    Names the agent for medical decisions under Public Health Law Article 29-C.

  • Revocable trust

    Allows a successor trustee to manage trust assets during incapacity.

  • Supported decision-making

    Under Mental Hygiene Law Article 82, an adult with a disability can choose supporters to help them make their own decisions.

Key terms

Incapacitated person
Under Article 81, a person the court finds likely to suffer harm because they cannot provide for personal needs or property management and cannot adequately understand and appreciate that inability.
Functional limitations
The specific activities a person cannot perform, which an Article 81 court uses to tailor the guardian’s powers.
Least restrictive alternative
The principle that a guardian’s powers should go no further than necessary, and that available alternatives should be used where sufficient.
Petitioner
The person who starts the guardianship proceeding, often a relative, a facility, or a social services agency.
Respondent
The person alleged to need a guardian, who has rights to notice, counsel, and a hearing.
Court evaluator
A neutral person appointed in Article 81 cases to investigate and report to the court.
Mental Hygiene Legal Service
A state agency that often serves as court evaluator or counsel for respondents in Article 81 proceedings.
Guardian of the person
A guardian with authority over personal needs, such as medical care and living arrangements.
Guardian of the property
A guardian with authority to manage financial affairs and property.
Temporary guardian
A guardian appointed under Mental Hygiene Law § 81.23 for a limited time or purpose while the proceeding is pending.
Substituted judgment
The authority an Article 81 court may grant to make gifts or transfers, including estate and Medicaid planning, based on what the person would likely have wanted.
Annual report
The report an Article 81 guardian must file with the court on the person’s condition and the property managed.
Standby guardian
A person designated under SCPA § 1726 to become guardian on a specified event, such as a parent’s death or incapacity.
Guardian ad litem
A person appointed by a court to protect the interests of a minor or incapacitated person in a specific proceeding.
UTMA custodian
A custodian under the New York Uniform Transfers to Minors Act who manages property for a minor, generally until 21, without a court guardianship.

Questions we hear most

How long does an Article 81 guardianship take?

The statute calls for an expedited hearing, but the overall timeline varies with the court, the complexity of the case, and whether it is contested.

Can the person object to a guardianship?

Yes. The person has the right to notice, to be present, to counsel, and to contest the petition, and the court may appoint counsel for them.

Can a guardianship be ended or changed?

Yes. A guardian’s powers can be modified, and the guardianship can be discharged if the person regains capacity or the need ends.

Does a power of attorney prevent a guardianship?

It usually makes one unnecessary for financial matters, and the court generally must consider available alternatives. A guardianship may still be sought if the agent is not acting properly or the document does not cover what is needed.

Who can petition for guardianship?

Under Article 81, a relative, a person with whom the respondent resides, a facility, a social services official, and others with a genuine interest in the person’s welfare may petition.

Who is appointed as guardian?

The court chooses a suitable person, often a family member, considering the person’s wishes and any nominations in advance planning documents. A professional guardian may be appointed when no one suitable is available.

Can I choose my own guardian in advance?

Yes. You can nominate a guardian in a power of attorney or other writing, which the court generally considers.

Does the guardian decide everything?

Not in Article 81. The court grants only the powers needed, and the person keeps all other rights.

Can a guardian move the person to a nursing home?

Only if the court has granted that authority, and the court will consider the person’s wishes and the least restrictive setting.

Is a guardian paid?

Guardians may be compensated as the court allows, and the costs of the proceeding are often paid from the person’s estate.

What is the difference between a guardian and an agent under a power of attorney?

An agent is chosen by the principal and acts without court supervision. A guardian is appointed by the court and reports to it.

Do minors need a guardian of property?

A minor who receives significant property, such as an inheritance or settlement, may need a guardian of property or a custodian. A trust in the parent’s will can avoid this.

Who will raise my children if I die?

The guardian you name in your will generally, subject to court approval. A standby guardian designation can provide authority during illness or incapacity.

Is Article 17-A guardianship permanent?

It generally continues for life unless modified or terminated by the court, which is one reason families consider less restrictive alternatives first.

Can a guardianship be challenged after it is granted?

Yes. The person or other interested parties can seek modification, removal of the guardian, or discharge.

How do I avoid a guardianship for my parent?

Help your parent sign a power of attorney, health care proxy, and, if appropriate, a revocable trust while they have capacity to do so.
Contact

Schedule a consultation

Estate planning conversations are among the most personal we have with clients. Tell us what you would like to accomplish. Initial consultations are complimentary and confidential, and we quote fees clearly at the outset — a flat fee for a standard estate plan.

Schedule a consultation

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

Confidential. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. We respond within one business day.

Skip to main content