Fiduciary and Trust Litigation Fiduciary and trust litigation in New York.
Most estate disputes start after the will is admitted or the trust takes effect. They are about how the executor or trustee is doing the job: what they disclose, how they invest, what they pay themselves, and when they distribute.
We represent beneficiaries, executors, administrators, trustees, and co-fiduciaries in contested accountings, removal and surcharge proceedings, turnover proceedings, and trust disputes in Surrogate’s Court and Supreme Court.
An executor or trustee holds property for others and owes them duties of loyalty, prudence, and impartiality. The Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act gives beneficiaries and other interested persons several ways to enforce those duties. Under SCPA § 2102, a beneficiary who has made a written request for information that went unanswered can bring a proceeding to require the fiduciary to supply information about the estate, and other subdivisions of that section can compel payment of a legacy, a distributive share, or a trust interest. Under SCPA § 2205, the court may at any time compel a fiduciary to file an intermediate or final account, on its own initiative or on the petition of an interested person, a creditor, a surety, or a co-fiduciary, among others. Disputes about lifetime trusts can also be brought in Supreme Court under CPLR Article 77, which allows a special proceeding to determine a matter relating to any express trust.
The accounting is usually where the case is decided. Once a fiduciary files an account, interested persons can examine the fiduciary and file objections to what was collected, spent, invested, or distributed and to the commissions claimed. If the fiduciary refuses to account, SCPA § 2206 allows the court to suspend the fiduciary’s letters, appoint a successor, and state the account itself. Objections can lead to a surcharge, which makes the fiduciary personally repay losses caused by a breach of duty, such as self-dealing, commingling, or investing in a way that does not meet the Prudent Investor Act, EPTL § 11-2.3. That statute judges the trustee’s conduct by the facts at the time of the decision, not by results, and generally requires diversification unless the trustee reasonably decides that not diversifying serves the beneficiaries.
When the problem is the fiduciary, the court can act on the office itself. SCPA § 711 lists grounds for suspending, modifying, or revoking letters, including wasting or improperly applying estate property, making unauthorized investments, disobeying a court order, obtaining letters through a false statement, removing estate property from New York without court approval, and failing to account as directed. A testamentary trustee who has violated or threatens to violate the trust can be removed, and SCPA § 719 lets the court act without a petition in some cases, such as when a fiduciary commingles estate funds with personal funds. Timing matters: the Appellate Division, Second Department, has held that a proceeding to compel an accounting is generally subject to a six-year limitations period that runs from the fiduciary’s open repudiation of the role, made known to the beneficiaries, not from the mere passage of time, but other claims may have different periods.
Our capabilities include:
- Petitions to compel an executor, administrator, or trustee to account
- Objections to accountings and defense of fiduciary accounts
- Proceedings to compel information and payment under SCPA § 2102
- Suspension, removal, and replacement of executors and trustees
- Surcharge claims for self-dealing, waste, and imprudent investment
- Discovery and turnover proceedings to recover estate property under SCPA § 2103
- Will and trust construction proceedings
- Disputes over executor and trustee commissions and legal fees
Common fiduciary disputes
Failure to account
A fiduciary who will not explain what came in and what went out can be compelled to account under SCPA § 2205, and under CPLR Article 77 for many lifetime trusts.
Self-dealing and conflicts
Buying estate property, lending estate money to oneself or a family business, or favoring one beneficiary over another.
Imprudent investment
Holding a concentrated position, an idle cash balance, or a deteriorating property without the analysis the Prudent Investor Act requires.
Delay
Leaving an estate open for years, failing to sell or distribute property, or failing to pay taxes and expenses on time.
Withheld property
Estate assets held by a relative, caretaker, or business partner, which the fiduciary can pursue in a discovery and turnover proceeding under SCPA § 2103.
Commissions and fees
Commissions calculated on the wrong base, double commissions, or legal and accounting fees that interested persons dispute on the accounting.
How a contested accounting proceeds
Request information
Ask the fiduciary in writing for an inventory, statements, and an informal account. An unanswered written request supports a proceeding under SCPA § 2102.
Petition to compel
File a petition in the Surrogate’s Court where letters were issued, or in Supreme Court for many lifetime trusts, asking the court to direct an account.
Review the account
The fiduciary files a formal account with schedules of receipts, disbursements, investments, and distributions, and asks the court to settle it.
Examine and object
Interested persons may examine the fiduciary under oath and file objections to specific items, commissions, and fees.
Resolve or try
Many objections are resolved by agreement or mediation. Those that are not are tried, and the decree may surcharge the fiduciary, reduce commissions, or direct distribution.
Remedies the court can order
| Compelled accounting | Intermediate or final account within a time the court directs (SCPA §§ 2205, 2206) |
|---|---|
| Information or payment | Information about the estate, payment of a legacy, distributive share, or trust interest (SCPA § 2102) |
| Suspension or removal | Suspension, modification, or revocation of letters on statutory grounds (SCPA §§ 711, 719) |
| Surcharge | Personal liability of the fiduciary for losses caused by a breach of duty |
| Turnover | Determination of title and delivery of property withheld from the estate (SCPA § 2103) |
| Construction | A binding interpretation of a disputed will provision (SCPA § 1420) |
Key terms
- Fiduciary
- A person or institution holding property for others, such as an executor, administrator, trustee, or guardian.
- Letters
- The Surrogate’s Court certificate, such as letters testamentary or letters of trusteeship, that gives a fiduciary authority to act.
- Judicial settlement of account
- A court proceeding under SCPA Article 22 in which a fiduciary’s account is reviewed, objections are decided, and a decree fixes what the fiduciary owes.
- Intermediate account
- An account covering part of the administration, often ordered when an estate or trust has been open for a long time.
- Compulsory accounting
- A proceeding in which the court, on petition or its own initiative, directs a fiduciary to account (SCPA § 2205).
- Objections
- A written statement of the specific items in an account that an interested person disputes.
- Surcharge
- An order making a fiduciary personally pay for a loss caused by a breach of duty.
- Self-dealing
- A transaction in which the fiduciary deals with estate or trust property for personal benefit, which is generally prohibited.
- Prudent Investor Act
- EPTL § 11-2.3, which sets the standard of care for investing and managing trust property.
- Diversification
- Spreading investments to reduce risk, which the Prudent Investor Act requires unless the trustee reasonably decides otherwise.
- Removal
- Revocation of a fiduciary’s letters on grounds such as waste, misconduct, or failure to obey court orders (SCPA § 711).
- Discovery and turnover proceeding
- A proceeding under SCPA § 2103 in which a fiduciary seeks information about, and recovery of, property belonging to the estate.
- Construction proceeding
- A proceeding under SCPA § 1420 to determine the validity, meaning, or effect of a will provision.
- CPLR Article 77
- The Supreme Court special proceeding for determining matters relating to express trusts, including many lifetime trusts.
- Open repudiation
- A fiduciary’s clear disavowal of the fiduciary role, known to the beneficiaries, which generally starts the limitations period for compelling an account.
- Commissions
- Statutory compensation for executors (SCPA § 2307) and trustees (SCPA §§ 2308, 2309), which interested persons may dispute on the accounting.
Questions we hear most
Can a beneficiary force an executor to account?
What does it take to remove a trustee?
Is a trustee liable because the investments lost money?
Is there a deadline to compel an accounting?
Which court hears a fiduciary dispute?
Can a fiduciary be removed while the case is pending?
Who pays the legal fees in a fiduciary dispute?
Can a court reduce a fiduciary’s commissions?
What is the difference between a surcharge and removal?
Do you represent fiduciaries as well as beneficiaries?
Schedule a consultation
Estate planning conversations are among the most personal we have with clients. Tell us what you would like to accomplish. Initial consultations are complimentary and confidential, and we quote fees clearly at the outset — a flat fee for a standard estate plan.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Schedule a consultation
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.