Asset Protection Trusts Asset protection planning under New York law.
New York does not let a person put assets in a trust for his or her own benefit and keep them from creditors. Protection comes from planning that works within that rule, done well before any claim arises.
We represent individuals, families, professionals, and business owners who want to protect what they have built from future creditors, long-term care costs, and the risks that follow a family’s wealth to the next generation.
Under EPTL § 7-3.1, a transfer in trust for the use of the person who creates it is void as against that person’s existing and future creditors. A New Yorker generally cannot create a self-settled trust, name himself or herself a beneficiary, and expect the trust to stop a judgment creditor. Protection in New York therefore comes mainly from trusts created by someone else, trusts that benefit a spouse or children rather than the creator, irrevocable trusts in which the creator keeps only income, statutory exemptions, and the way business and real estate interests are owned.
Timing is the line between planning and a voidable transfer. New York’s Uniform Voidable Transactions Act, Debtor and Creditor Law §§ 270–281, governs transfers made on or after April 4, 2020. A creditor can generally undo a transfer made with intent to hinder, delay, or defraud creditors, or one made without reasonably equivalent value while the debtor was insolvent or left with too little to meet its debts. Planning done while finances are sound, and documented as such, stands on far firmer ground than a transfer made after a claim appears.
Some clients ask about domestic asset protection trusts formed under the laws of Delaware or another state that permits them. A New York resident can create one, but whether a New York court, or a bankruptcy court, will respect it against a New York creditor is uncertain, and federal bankruptcy law reaches certain transfers to self-settled trusts made within ten years before a filing. We discuss those trusts candidly as one tool with real conflict-of-law risk, not as a shield.
Our capabilities include:
- Third-party trusts with spendthrift protection for children and other heirs
- Spousal lifetime access trusts
- Medicaid asset protection trusts
- Analysis of out-of-state asset protection trusts
- LLC and entity structuring for real estate and business interests
- Review of exemptions for retirement accounts, insurance, and the homestead
- Solvency analysis and documentation of planning transfers
- Defense of voidable transfer claims
Tools available to New York residents
Third-party trusts
A trust created by a parent or other relative for a beneficiary, with a spendthrift clause and discretionary distributions, generally protects the trust assets from the beneficiary’s creditors and divorcing spouse.
Spousal lifetime access trust
An irrevocable trust for a spouse, and often children, funded by the other spouse. Because the creator is not a beneficiary, it is not self-settled, though access is lost if the marriage ends or the spouse dies.
Medicaid asset protection trust
An irrevocable trust from which the creator may receive income but not principal. Once the 60-month nursing home look-back has run, principal is generally not counted for Medicaid.
Out-of-state asset protection trust
A self-settled trust under the law of a state that allows it. It can add a hurdle for creditors, but a New York court may apply New York policy, and its value for a New York resident is uncertain.
LLCs and other entities
Holding real estate or a business in a properly run LLC can separate the liabilities of each asset and generally limit a member’s personal creditor to a charging order, with less certainty for single-member companies.
Statutory exemptions
New York exempts qualified retirement accounts and IRAs, certain insurance and annuities, and a homestead allowance under CPLR 5206 whose amount varies by county and is adjusted periodically.
What makes a transfer vulnerable
Actual intent
A transfer made to hinder, delay, or defraud a creditor. Courts look to badges of fraud such as transfers to insiders, retained control, concealment, and transfers made after a suit was threatened.
Constructive fraud
A transfer for less than reasonably equivalent value made while insolvent, or that left the debtor unable to pay debts as they came due.
Time limits
Claims under the Act generally must be brought within four years after the transfer; for intent claims, within one year after the transfer was or reasonably could have been discovered, if later.
Bankruptcy
The Bankruptcy Code has its own avoidance powers, including a ten-year reach-back for certain transfers to self-settled trusts made with intent to defraud.
How we build a plan
Inventory and exposure
We list assets, how each is titled, existing and foreseeable claims, and which assets are already exempt.
Solvency check
We confirm that the client remains solvent after the planned transfers and document the analysis.
Choose the structures
We match trusts, entities, and titling to the client’s goals, tax position, and need for access.
Fund and maintain
We retitle assets, observe trust and entity formalities, and review the plan as the family and the law change.
Key terms
- Self-settled trust
- A trust in which the creator is also a beneficiary.
- EPTL § 7-3.1
- The New York statute making a trust for the creator’s own use void as against the creator’s creditors.
- Spendthrift clause
- A trust provision barring a beneficiary from assigning an interest and limiting the reach of the beneficiary’s creditors.
- Discretionary trust
- A trust in which the trustee decides whether and when to make distributions.
- Spousal lifetime access trust
- An irrevocable trust created by one spouse for the other spouse, and often children.
- Medicaid asset protection trust
- An irrevocable, income-only trust used to protect principal from long-term care costs once the look-back has run.
- Domestic asset protection trust
- A self-settled trust permitted under the law of certain states, such as Delaware and Nevada.
- Uniform Voidable Transactions Act
- New York’s law on transfers creditors can undo, Debtor and Creditor Law §§ 270–281, effective April 4, 2020.
- Badges of fraud
- Circumstances from which a court may infer intent to hinder, delay, or defraud creditors.
- Reasonably equivalent value
- Fair consideration for a transfer; its absence, combined with insolvency, can make a transfer voidable.
- Charging order
- A court order giving a member’s judgment creditor a right to distributions from an LLC, rather than control of it.
- Homestead exemption
- The protection under CPLR 5206 for a set amount of equity in a primary residence, which varies by county.
- Tenancy by the entirety
- Joint ownership of real property by spouses, which limits the reach of one spouse’s creditors.
- Conflict of laws
- The rules a court uses to decide which state’s law governs, central to whether an out-of-state trust is respected.
Questions we hear most
Can I create a trust for myself that my creditors cannot reach?
Does a revocable living trust protect assets?
Is it too late to plan if I have already been sued?
Should I form a Delaware or Nevada trust?
Are my retirement accounts protected?
Does owning my home with my spouse protect it?
Can a trust for my children protect their inheritance from a divorce?
Does a SLAT work if we later divorce?
How does Medicaid planning fit into asset protection?
Will a transfer to my spouse protect my assets?
Schedule a consultation
Estate planning conversations are among the most personal we have with clients. Tell us what you would like to accomplish. Initial consultations are complimentary and confidential, and we quote fees clearly at the outset — a flat fee for a standard estate plan.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Schedule a consultation
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.