Subleases and assignments.

When a tenant needs to move, shrink, or sell, a sublease or assignment is often the way out. Landlord consent and continuing liability are the key issues.

We represent sublandlords, subtenants, assignors, assignees, and landlords in commercial subleases and lease assignments.

In an assignment, the tenant transfers its entire interest; in a sublease, it carves out space or time and stays in the middle. Unless the lease provides otherwise, an assigning tenant generally remains liable after an assignment.

Consent is the gatekeeper. In New York, if a commercial lease simply requires consent without a reasonableness standard, a landlord may generally withhold it. Recapture rights and profit-sharing clauses also shape the deal.

Our capabilities include:

  • Consent requests and negotiations
  • Sublease drafting
  • Assignment and assumption agreements
  • Releases of the original tenant
  • Recapture and profit-sharing analysis
  • Recognition and non-disturbance agreements

For landlords and tenants

Key issues in a transfer

  • Consent standard

    Whether consent may be withheld reasonably or in the landlord’s discretion.

  • Recapture

    Whether the landlord can take the space back instead of consenting.

  • Profit sharing

    How sublease or assignment profits are split.

  • Liability

    Whether the original tenant is released.

  • Recognition

    Whether the subtenant survives if the main lease ends.

Key terms

Assignment
A transfer of the tenant’s entire remaining interest in the lease. The assignee steps into the tenant’s position and generally deals directly with the landlord.
Sublease
A new lease from the tenant to a subtenant for part of the space or part of the remaining term. The tenant stays in the middle as sublandlord and remains responsible to the landlord.
Privity of estate
The relationship between a landlord and whoever holds the tenant’s leasehold. An assignee in possession is generally liable to the landlord for rent and covenants while it holds the lease, even without a written assumption.
Privity of contract
The direct contractual relationship created by signing the lease. The original tenant remains in privity of contract after an assignment, which is why it generally stays liable unless released.
Assumption agreement
An agreement by which the assignee expressly takes on the tenant’s obligations under the lease. With an assumption, the assignee’s liability generally continues by contract, not only while it remains in possession.
Release
A landlord’s agreement that the original tenant is no longer liable after the assignment. Releases are negotiated and are not implied by the landlord’s consent alone.
Novation
A new agreement in which the landlord accepts the assignee in place of the original tenant and discharges the original tenant. In practice it accomplishes what an assignment with a release does.
Consent standard
The test the landlord applies to a transfer request. Under New York law, a landlord may generally withhold consent arbitrarily unless the lease requires it to act reasonably.
Strict construction of restrictions
New York courts generally read restrictions on transfer narrowly. A clause that prohibits only assignment may not prohibit subletting, and the reverse, so the drafting matters.
Change of control
A lease clause that treats a transfer of ownership interests in the tenant, or a merger, as an assignment requiring consent. Without such a clause, a sale of the tenant’s stock or membership interests generally is not an assignment of the lease.
Permitted transfer
A transfer the lease allows without consent, typically to an affiliate, a successor by merger, or a buyer of substantially all of the tenant’s business. Conditions often include notice, minimum net worth, and assumption.
Recapture
A landlord’s right, triggered by a transfer request, to terminate the lease for the affected space instead of consenting. It lets the landlord capture market value itself.
Transfer premium
The amount by which sublease or assignment consideration exceeds the rent under the lease. Leases commonly require the tenant to share it with the landlord, after deducting specified costs.
Prime lease
In a sublease, the original lease between the landlord and the tenant. The sublease is subordinate to it and cannot give the subtenant greater rights than the prime lease gives the tenant.
Incorporation by reference
The sublease technique of adopting the prime lease’s terms, with listed exceptions and modifications. It is efficient but requires care so that the subtenant does not inherit obligations that do not fit.
Consent agreement
A three-party document in which the landlord consents to the transfer and sets conditions. It often addresses continuing liability, the profit split, and limits on further transfers.
Attornment
A subtenant’s agreement to recognize the landlord as its direct landlord if the prime lease ends. It is usually paired with a recognition agreement from the landlord.

Questions we hear most

Does the original tenant stay liable after an assignment?

Generally yes, unless the landlord releases it.

Can my landlord refuse consent for no reason?

In New York, if the lease requires consent without saying it cannot be unreasonably withheld, the landlord generally may refuse.

What happens to my sublease if the tenant defaults?

Without a recognition agreement, a sublease usually ends with the main lease.

What is the difference between an assignment and a sublease?

An assignment transfers the tenant’s whole interest for the rest of the term. A sublease transfers less — part of the space, part of the term, or both — and the tenant keeps its position under the main lease.

Is selling my company an assignment of my lease?

It depends on the lease. Many commercial leases treat a change of control or a merger as an assignment that requires consent; without that language, a sale of ownership interests generally is not an assignment.

Can I sublet if my lease says nothing about subletting?

Under New York law, absent a restriction in the lease, a commercial tenant can generally assign or sublet. Most commercial leases, however, include restrictions.

Can my landlord charge me for reviewing a transfer request?

If the lease allows it. Many leases require the tenant to reimburse the landlord’s reasonable legal and processing costs.

What can I do if my landlord unreasonably refuses consent when the lease requires reasonableness?

The tenant may be able to seek a court determination that consent was unreasonably withheld. Many leases limit the remedy to a declaratory judgment or an order compelling consent, without money damages.

Who does a subtenant pay rent to?

Usually the sublandlord, which then pays the landlord under the main lease. A subtenant generally is not in a direct relationship with the landlord unless a recognition agreement or consent agreement provides one.

Can a subtenant sublet further?

Only if the sublease and the main lease both allow it. Most subleases and consent agreements prohibit further transfers without consent.

What happens to the security deposit when a lease is assigned?

The lease and the assignment agreement decide. Commonly the assignee replaces the deposit and the landlord returns the original tenant’s deposit, or the parties agree that the deposit transfers.

Does an assignment have to be in writing?

It should be. Commercial leases almost always require a written assignment and assumption, and the landlord’s consent should be in writing as well.

What happens to furniture and equipment in a sublease?

It should be addressed separately, either by a bill of sale or by a license for the subtenant to use it. The sublease should state who maintains it and what happens to it at the end.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about the space, the parties, and the timing. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content