Ground Leases Ground leases in New York.

A ground lease separates the land from the building for decades. Its rent mechanics, lender protections, and tax treatment have to work for the developer’s lenders and the landowner’s heirs alike.

We represent landowners, families, institutions, developers, and investors in negotiating, financing, amending, and enforcing long-term ground leases in New York.

Ground leases commonly run 49 to 99 years. The tenant builds and owns the improvements during the term and pays the taxes, insurance, and operating costs, and the improvements usually revert to the landowner when the lease ends. Because the lease will outlive the people who sign it, the rent mechanics, the condition of the reversion, and the remedies for default must be drafted to work decades from now.

Rent resets deserve particular care. In 936 Second Ave. L.P. v. Second Corporate Development Co., 10 N.Y.3d 628 (2008), the Court of Appeals held that, absent an agreement to the contrary, the effect of a net lease must be considered in valuing the property for a reset. Whether the land is appraised as vacant and unencumbered or as encumbered by the lease can move the rent substantially, so the valuation instructions should say exactly what the parties intend.

Financing and tax treatment shape the deal as much as rent. Leasehold lenders generally require notice and cure rights, a new-lease right, and protection against amendment or surrender without their consent. For New York State transfer tax, the creation of a lease is a taxable conveyance where the term plus renewal options exceeds 49 years, substantial capital improvements are or may be made for the tenant, and the lease covers substantially all of the premises. The New York City transfer tax works differently: it generally reaches consideration for the grant of a lease other than rent.

Our capabilities include:

  • Ground lease negotiation for landowners and developers
  • Fixed, CPI, and appraisal-based rent provisions
  • Leasehold mortgagee protections and lender negotiations
  • Fee mortgages, subordination, and non-disturbance agreements
  • Memoranda of lease and estoppel certificates
  • State and City transfer tax and mortgage recording tax analysis
  • Leasehold condominiums and phased developments
  • Reset disputes, defaults, and Yellowstone proceedings

For landlords and tenants

Common ground lease structures

UnsubordinatedThe landowner does not pledge the land for the tenant’s loan. The lender’s collateral is the leasehold alone, and the fee is not at risk if the loan defaults.
SubordinatedThe landowner subordinates the fee to the tenant’s mortgage, so a foreclosure can reach the land. Owners who agree usually do so for higher rent or other concessions.
Fixed escalationsScheduled increases, such as a set percentage every five years. Predictable for both sides, but they may drift away from actual land value over a long term.
CPI adjustmentsRent tied to an inflation index, often with a floor and a cap. Tracks the general price level, not the value of the particular site.
Appraisal resetsRent reset at intervals to a percentage of appraised value. Tracks the land, but the result depends heavily on the valuation instructions and the procedure.
HybridFixed or CPI increases between periodic appraisal resets, often with a no-decrease clause or a cap on any single reset.

Negotiating a ground lease

  1. Term sheet

    Agree on the term and renewals, base rent and the reset method, subordination, any purchase option or right of first offer, and the development timetable.

  2. Diligence

    Review title, survey, zoning and development rights, environmental conditions, existing mortgages on the fee, and the transfer tax consequences of the proposed structure.

  3. Rent and valuation

    Draft the escalation and reset provisions, including the valuation assumptions, appraiser qualifications, deadlines, and what happens if a party fails to appoint an appraiser.

  4. Lender review

    Share the draft with the tenant’s prospective leasehold lender early, so its required protections are built in rather than renegotiated after signing.

  5. Development and operation

    Set construction obligations and completion security, use and alteration rights, insurance, casualty and condemnation provisions, and end-of-term condition.

  6. Closing

    Sign the lease and a memorandum of lease meeting Real Property Law § 291-c, record the memorandum, and file any required transfer tax returns.

A lender financeability checklist

  • Term

    A remaining term, including renewals the tenant controls, that runs well past the loan’s maturity.

  • Notice and cure

    Copies of default notices and added time to cure, including time to foreclose before curing defaults only the tenant can cure.

  • New lease

    The right to a new lease on the same terms if the ground lease is terminated or rejected in bankruptcy.

  • No amendment or surrender

    No amendment, cancellation, or voluntary surrender of the lease without the lender’s consent.

  • Transferability

    The right to foreclose, take the leasehold, and assign it afterward without unreasonable landowner consent requirements.

  • Fee mortgage priority

    Any fee mortgage subordinate to the ground lease, or a non-disturbance agreement from the fee lender.

  • Proceeds

    Insurance and condemnation proceeds applied to restoration or the debt on terms the lender can accept.

  • Estoppels

    A landowner obligation to deliver estoppel certificates within a fixed time after request.

Key terms

Fee estate
Ownership of the land itself, which the landowner keeps throughout the ground lease. The fee is subject to the lease, but can be sold, mortgaged, or passed to heirs.
Leasehold estate
The tenant’s right to possess and use the land for the lease term. The leasehold can itself be sold, assigned, and mortgaged, subject to the ground lease’s terms.
Improvements
The buildings the tenant constructs on the land. The lease typically provides that the tenant owns them during the term and that they become the landowner’s property when the lease ends.
Reversion
The landowner’s right to recover the land, and usually the improvements, at the end of the term. Its value grows as the term runs down, which affects financing and sale of the leasehold late in the term.
Absolute net lease
A structure under which the tenant pays all real estate taxes, insurance, maintenance, and operating costs. Ground leases are generally absolute net, so ground rent is the landowner’s return on the land.
Fixed escalations
Scheduled rent increases, such as a percentage increase every few years. They provide predictability for both sides but may not track actual land values over a long term.
Rent reset
A periodic adjustment of ground rent, often to a percentage of the land’s appraised value at the time of the reset. Resets are among the most negotiated and most litigated provisions of ground leases.
Appraisal process
The mechanism for determining value at a reset, typically with each side appointing an appraiser and a third appraiser resolving differences. Some leases use baseball-style procedures in which the neutral must choose one side’s figure.
Valuation assumptions
Instructions telling the appraisers how to value the land — for example, as vacant and unencumbered at its highest and best use, or as encumbered by the lease and its use restrictions. These assumptions can drive the reset more than the appraisers’ judgment.
Leasehold mortgage
A mortgage on the tenant’s leasehold estate. It is how most ground-leased projects are financed, and lenders rely on protections written into the ground lease.
Leasehold mortgagee protections
Ground lease provisions that give the leasehold lender notice of tenant defaults, extended time to cure, the right to foreclose and transfer the leasehold, and protection against amendment or surrender of the lease without its consent.
New lease right
The leasehold lender’s right to receive a new ground lease on the same terms if the existing lease is terminated or rejected in bankruptcy. Lenders generally view it as essential.
Fee mortgage subordination
Whether the landowner pledges the land itself as security for the tenant’s loan. In a subordinated ground lease the fee is at risk if the tenant’s loan defaults; in an unsubordinated ground lease it is not.
Estoppel certificate
A signed statement confirming that the lease is in effect, the rent, and whether any defaults exist. Lenders and buyers of either the fee or the leasehold rely on them, so ground leases require both parties to deliver them on request.
Right of first offer
A right to be offered the chance to buy the other party’s interest before it is marketed to others. It is distinct from a right of first refusal, which allows a party to match a third-party offer and can make the interest harder to sell.
Purchase option
A right of the tenant to buy the fee at a set price or a price determined by formula. Options can be valuable to developers but require careful drafting on price, timing, and exercise.
Casualty and condemnation
Provisions governing whether the tenant must rebuild after a fire or other casualty, and how insurance proceeds and condemnation awards are divided between the landowner, the tenant, and the leasehold lender.
Leasehold condominium
A condominium created on the leasehold rather than on the fee, so unit owners own their units for the remaining term of the ground lease. Buyers and their lenders review the ground lease closely before purchasing.

Questions we hear most

How long should a ground lease be?

Long enough for the project to be financed and to earn a return. Leasehold lenders generally want the remaining term, including renewals the tenant controls, to run well beyond the loan’s maturity, and terms of 49 to 99 years are common.

How is a rent reset decided if the parties disagree?

Usually by the appraisal procedure in the lease, in which each side appoints an appraiser and a third resolves the difference. In New York, unless the lease says otherwise, the effect of the lease itself must be considered in valuing the property, so the valuation instructions often decide the outcome.

Is a long ground lease subject to transfer tax?

It can be. New York State treats the creation of a lease as a taxable conveyance when the term plus renewal options exceeds 49 years, substantial capital improvements are or may be made for the tenant, and the lease covers substantially all of the premises; State regulations measure the consideration, and so the tax base, by the present value of the net rent. The New York City tax generally applies to consideration for a lease other than rent.

What happens to the ground lease if the landowner files for bankruptcy?

If a debtor-landlord rejects the lease, 11 U.S.C. § 365(h) lets the tenant treat the lease as terminated where the rejection would entitle it to do so, or, if the term has begun, keep its rights for the balance of the term and any renewal or extension enforceable under nonbankruptcy law, with a right to offset post-rejection damages against rent.

How is a ground lease different from an ordinary commercial lease?

In an ordinary lease, the tenant rents space in a building the landlord owns. In a ground lease, the tenant leases the land, builds or owns the improvements, and generally bears all costs of the property for a very long term.

Why would a landowner ground lease instead of selling?

A ground lease can provide long-term income while keeping ownership of the land and the reversion for the owner and its heirs. The tax and estate consequences differ from a sale and should be reviewed with the owner’s tax advisers.

Why would a developer ground lease instead of buying the land?

A ground lease can reduce the capital needed up front, since the developer pays rent instead of a purchase price. The trade-off is ongoing rent, rent resets, and an eventual reversion.

Who pays real estate taxes on ground-leased land?

Typically the tenant, along with insurance and all operating costs. The lease should also address tax abatement programs and who benefits from them.

Can the tenant sell its building?

The tenant can generally sell or assign the leasehold, including the improvements, as the lease allows. Some ground leases restrict transfers before construction is complete or require that the buyer meet certain standards.

What happens if the building is destroyed?

The lease decides. Ground leases often require the tenant to rebuild with the insurance proceeds, though some allow the tenant not to rebuild late in the term, with proceeds divided between the parties.

What happens if the government takes the land by eminent domain?

The lease typically divides the award between the landowner, for the land and its reversion, and the tenant and its lender, for the leasehold and the improvements. Without clear terms, the division can be disputed.

Does the landowner have to put up the land as collateral for the developer’s loan?

Not unless it agrees to. Most ground leases are unsubordinated, meaning the landowner’s fee is not pledged, though some landowners agree to subordinate in exchange for higher rent or other terms.

Can a ground lease be recorded?

Yes. Parties typically record a memorandum of lease rather than the full lease, which gives notice of the tenant’s rights to later buyers and lenders.

Why do lenders and buyers keep asking for estoppel certificates?

An estoppel confirms the status of the lease at a moment in time, and the party signing it is generally bound by what it says. Over a long ground lease, estoppels are requested at nearly every financing and sale.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about the space, the parties, and the timing. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content