Subleases and assignments for landlords.
A transfer request is an opportunity to protect the building, recapture space, or share in profits. The consent document is where that happens.
We represent landlords reviewing and documenting tenant requests to sublet or assign.
Landlords should evaluate the proposed occupant’s use and credit, exercise recapture rights where valuable, and collect their share of profits under the lease.
The consent agreement should keep the original tenant liable, bind the new occupant to the lease, and limit further transfers.
Our capabilities include:
- Transfer request review
- Recapture decisions
- Profit-sharing calculations
- Consent agreements
- Assumption and guaranty requirements
- Recognition agreement negotiations
What landlords should protect
Credit
Financial review of the assignee or subtenant.
Use
No change in use that conflicts with exclusives or the certificate of occupancy.
Liability
The original tenant and guarantors remain liable.
Profits
Collection of the landlord’s share.
Future transfers
Limits on further subletting or assignment.
Key terms
- Transfer request package
- The information the lease requires with a request: the proposed occupant, its financials, the transaction terms, and the intended use. A complete package lets the landlord evaluate the request and starts any response clock the lease sets.
- Sole discretion consent
- A lease that lets the landlord withhold consent in its sole discretion gives the most control. Under New York law, consent may generally be withheld arbitrarily unless the lease sets a reasonableness standard.
- Reasonableness factors
- Where consent cannot be unreasonably withheld, the lease can list factors the landlord may consider, such as financial strength, use, reputation, and whether the proposed occupant is an existing tenant or prospect. A list helps support a refusal.
- Recapture right
- The right to take back the space rather than consent. It is most valuable when market rents exceed the lease rent, and the lease should state how recapture works for partial space.
- Profit-sharing calculation
- The formula for the landlord’s share of the transfer premium. Landlords should define which costs the tenant may deduct and require supporting documentation.
- Assumption requirement
- A requirement that an assignee sign a written assumption of the lease. It makes the assignee liable by contract for the remainder of the term, not only while it is in possession.
- Continuing liability
- Language confirming that the original tenant remains liable after a transfer, including under later amendments and extensions. Without it, an assignor may argue it is not bound by changes it did not approve.
- Guarantor reaffirmation
- A guarantor’s written confirmation that its guaranty continues after the transfer. It avoids disputes about whether the transfer released the guarantor.
- Existing tenant and prospect exclusion
- A right to refuse a transfer to an existing tenant in the building, or to a party the landlord is negotiating with. It keeps tenants from competing with the landlord for the same occupants.
- Deemed transfer
- A clause treating changes of control, mergers, and certain equity sales as transfers requiring consent. It keeps a tenant from transferring the lease indirectly.
- Assignment of sublease rents
- A provision allowing the landlord, after a tenant default, to collect rent directly from subtenants. Collection should not be treated as acceptance of the subtenant or as a waiver of the default.
- Subtenant attornment
- The subtenant’s agreement to recognize the landlord, at the landlord’s election, if the main lease ends. The landlord keeps the option without the obligation.
- Limited recognition
- If a landlord agrees to recognize a subtenant, it can limit recognition to subtenants of large blocks of space, on terms at least as favorable to the landlord as the main lease. Recognition binds the landlord to the subtenant directly.
- Cost reimbursement
- The tenant’s obligation to pay the landlord’s legal and administrative costs of reviewing a request, whether or not consent is given.
- Limitation on tenant remedies
- A clause providing that if the landlord wrongly withholds consent, the tenant’s only remedy is a declaratory judgment or an order compelling consent, without money damages.
- No waiver
- Language stating that consent to one transfer is not consent to any other. Each future transfer still requires its own consent.
Questions we hear most
Should I recapture or consent?
Can I require a new guaranty from an assignee?
Do I have to respond to a transfer request within a set time?
Could I owe damages if I refuse consent?
Can I collect rent directly from a subtenant?
What if my tenant sublets without my consent?
Should I agree to a recognition agreement with a subtenant?
Can I refuse a transfer to one of my existing tenants?
If the assignee defaults, can I pursue the original tenant?
What diligence should I do on a proposed assignee?
Does a change in my tenant’s ownership need my consent?
Should I require the tenant to pay my legal fees for reviewing a request?
Get in touch
Tell us about the space, the parties, and the timing. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.
- Phone(212) 300-3191
- Emailinquiries@madisonlawfirm.com
- Office579 Fifth Avenue, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10017 - HoursMonday – Friday, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
After-hours by appointment
Send an inquiry
Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.