Commercial lease guaranties.

A guaranty puts an individual’s or a parent company’s assets behind the lease. Its scope decides how much is at stake.

We negotiate guaranties for landlords and guarantors, and enforce and defend them when tenants default.

A full guaranty covers all of the tenant’s obligations for the whole term. A limited guaranty caps liability by amount or time. A good guy guaranty generally ends the guarantor’s liability for future rent if the tenant gives notice, pays rent through the surrender date, and vacates in good condition.

Personal guaranties are enforceable. New York City’s COVID-era Guaranty Law, which barred enforcement for certain obligations from March 2020 through June 2021, was held unconstitutional by a federal court in 2023.

Our capabilities include:

  • Full, limited, and good guy guaranties
  • Burn-off and cap structures
  • Corporate and parent guaranties
  • Surrender procedures under good guy guaranties
  • Guaranty enforcement actions
  • Guarantor defenses

For landlords and tenants

Types of guaranties

  • Full guaranty

    Covers everything the tenant owes for the whole term.

  • Limited guaranty

    Capped by dollar amount or number of months of rent.

  • Good guy guaranty

    Ends future liability after proper notice, rent paid through surrender, and vacating.

  • Burn-off

    Liability that decreases over time without default.

  • Corporate guaranty

    A parent or affiliate stands behind the tenant.

Key terms

Guarantor
The person or company that promises to answer for the tenant’s obligations. A guarantor is not a tenant and has no right to occupy the space.
Guaranty of payment
A guaranty under which the landlord may pursue the guarantor as soon as the tenant fails to pay, without first suing the tenant. Most landlord forms use it.
Guaranty of collection
A guaranty under which the landlord generally must first try to collect from the tenant before pursuing the guarantor. It offers the guarantor more protection and is less common in leases.
Guaranty of performance
A guaranty that covers the tenant’s non-monetary obligations, such as maintenance, insurance, and surrender. It can expose the guarantor to more than unpaid rent.
Absolute and unconditional
Language providing that the guarantor’s obligation does not depend on any condition or on the landlord’s pursuit of other remedies. New York courts generally enforce it as written.
Waiver of defenses
A clause in which the guarantor gives up defenses it might otherwise raise, such as the landlord’s failure to pursue the tenant or to preserve collateral. New York courts generally enforce broad waivers in a guaranty signed by sophisticated parties.
Consent to modification
The guarantor’s advance agreement that lease amendments, extensions, and assignments do not release it. Without consent, a material change to the lease that the guarantor did not approve can release it.
Strict construction
The traditional New York rule that a guarantor is bound only by the terms it agreed to and that its obligation cannot be extended by implication. It is why the precise wording of a guaranty matters.
Continuing guaranty
A guaranty that covers obligations arising over the whole term, including after renewals and assignments if it so provides. It typically cannot be revoked by the guarantor alone.
Joint and several liability
When more than one guarantor signs, each can be held liable for the full amount. The landlord may pursue any one of them for the whole debt.
Liability cap
A limit on the guarantor’s liability, stated in dollars or months of rent. Whether the cap includes legal fees, interest, and holdover damages should be stated expressly.
Surrender date
In a good guy guaranty, the date on which the tenant vacates and delivers possession after proper notice. Liability for rent accruing after this date generally ends if all conditions are met.
Reinstatement
A clause reviving the guaranty if a payment the landlord received is later recovered in the tenant’s bankruptcy. It protects the landlord against preference claims.
Waiver of subrogation
The guarantor’s agreement not to pursue the tenant for amounts it paid until the landlord is paid in full. It keeps the guarantor from competing with the landlord for the tenant’s assets.
CPLR 3213
The New York procedure for a motion for summary judgment in lieu of complaint, available for instruments for the payment of money only. Unconditional guaranties of payment are often enforced this way.
Jury waiver and forum clause
Provisions waiving a jury trial and consenting to suit in New York courts. They are standard in landlord forms and affect where and how a claim is decided.

Questions we hear most

Is my personal guaranty enforceable?

Generally yes. The New York City Guaranty Law that limited enforcement for March 2020 through June 2021 was struck down in 2023.

What does a good guy guaranty require?

Typically advance written notice, payment of rent through the surrender date, and vacating the premises broom-clean with keys returned. The exact conditions are in the guaranty.

Does a guaranty have to be in writing?

Yes. A promise to answer for another’s debt must be in writing under New York’s statute of frauds.

How is a guarantor different from a co-tenant?

A co-tenant signs the lease and is directly liable as a tenant, with the right to occupy. A guarantor signs a separate guaranty promising to pay if the tenant does not, with no right to the space.

Why does the landlord want a guaranty from my company’s owner?

Many tenants are newly formed entities with limited assets, and an LLC or corporation generally shields its owners from the entity’s debts. A guaranty gives the landlord recourse to the owner.

How long does a guaranty last?

As long as its terms say. A full guaranty generally lasts for the lease term and any covered renewals, while a good guy guaranty, burn-off, or cap can shorten or limit it.

Does my guaranty cover lease renewals and extensions?

It depends on the guaranty. Many landlord forms cover renewals, extensions, and amendments in advance, while negotiated guaranties may exclude them unless the guarantor consents.

Can the landlord sue me without suing the tenant first?

Under a guaranty of payment, generally yes. Under a guaranty of collection, the landlord generally must first try to collect from the tenant.

If the tenant files for bankruptcy, am I still liable?

Generally yes. The automatic stay in bankruptcy protects the tenant, but it does not ordinarily protect a guarantor.

Can my spouse be asked to sign the guaranty?

Some landlords ask, especially when assets are held jointly. A guarantor’s spouse is not liable unless he or she signs, so the request is negotiable.

Does a guaranty cover the landlord’s attorney’s fees?

If the guaranty or the guaranteed lease provides for them. Many landlord forms make the guarantor responsible for enforcement costs.

What happens to the guaranty if the lease is assigned?

Many guaranties continue to cover the lease after assignment. A guarantor who wants a release must negotiate it, either in the guaranty or at the time of assignment.

Is a good guy guaranty the same as a limited guaranty?

Not exactly. A limited guaranty caps liability by amount or time, while a good guy guaranty ends liability for future rent once the tenant satisfies specific surrender conditions. Some guaranties combine both.

What is a corporate guaranty?

A guaranty given by a parent company or affiliate rather than an individual. The landlord’s protection depends on the strength of the guarantor and any restrictions on transferring its assets.
Contact

Get in touch

Tell us about the space, the parties, and the timing. Initial consultations are complimentary, and we provide a clear scope and fee quote at the outset.

Send an inquiry

Tell us about the matter and we will respond within one business day.

All inquiries are confidential. Initial consultation is complimentary. We will respond within one business day.

Skip to main content