Published

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your situation, consult a lawyer.

Can a provider sue to collect an unpaid No Surprises Act IDR award?

Not under the No Surprises Act itself, in New York’s federal courts. On September 17, 2026, the Second Circuit held in East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery v. Cigna that the Act gives providers no private right of action to enforce federal IDR awards. Plans must still pay within 30 days, but enforcement runs through regulators. The court did not decide ERISA or state-law claims.

What the court decided

East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery (ECAPS), an out-of-network practice that performs breast reconstruction, won more than $3 million in federal IDR awards against Cigna. Cigna did not pay, and ECAPS sued in the Southern District of New York, seeking a declaration that Cigna had violated the No Surprises Act and owed the awarded amounts. The district court dismissed the case in August 2025.

The Second Circuit affirmed on September 17, 2026, in an opinion by Judge Park for a panel that also included Judges Leval and Rakoff. The court held that the No Surprises Act does not create a private right of action to enforce IDR payment awards, and that enforcement belongs to the administrative agencies and the states. It also rejected ECAPS’s reliance on the Declaratory Judgment Act, which supplies a form of relief but not an independent right to sue.

Why the court reached that result

The question was whether Congress clearly intended to let providers sue. The court found that it did not, for three main reasons reported in the opinion and in later briefs and commentary:

  • The No Surprises Act makes IDR determinations reviewable only on the narrow grounds in section 10(a) of the Federal Arbitration Act, the vacatur provision. It does not incorporate the Act’s companion provision that lets a court confirm an award and enter judgment on it. The court read that omission as a sign that Congress did not intend court enforcement.
  • The statute’s “shall pay” language gives a provider a right to be paid, and the award is “binding,” but neither feature says who may enforce the obligation or how.
  • Congress assigned enforcement to the Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor, and the Treasury, and to state insurance regulators. The court reasoned that what matters is that Congress authorized agency enforcement, not how actively the agencies use it.

Guardian Flight and the wider picture

The Fifth Circuit reached the same conclusion in Guardian Flight, L.L.C. v. Health Care Service Corp. in June 2025, and the Supreme Court denied review in January 2026. With two circuits now aligned, a provider in New York federal court should assume that a direct No Surprises Act claim to collect an award will be dismissed.

Some trial courts outside the Second Circuit have gone the other way. A federal court in Maryland found a narrow right to convert a binding IDR determination into a judgment in March 2026, and decisions from the District of Connecticut had recognized a private right before ECAPS. Those Connecticut decisions are now in tension with binding circuit law. A separate Second Circuit appeal, Agag v. Cigna, which arises from a Connecticut ruling that treated confirmation of IDR determinations as a limited proceeding, was pending as of early November 2026.

We have not confirmed from the appellate docket whether ECAPS sought rehearing. If it did not, a petition for certiorari would generally be due within 90 days after the judgment. We will update this article if either step is taken.

What the decision left open

  • ERISA theories. The Second Circuit did not address them. The Fifth Circuit rejected derivative ERISA claims in Guardian Flight on standing grounds, because patients protected by the Act have no out-of-network liability to assert.
  • State-law claims. The court did not decide whether a provider may sue on contract, implied contract, unjust enrichment, or promissory estoppel theories. Plans can be expected to argue that the Act’s administrative scheme, or ERISA, displaces those claims, so each depends heavily on the facts, including any written assurance by the plan that it would pay.
  • Confirmation proceedings. Commentators read the decision as addressing the claim before it, a direct statutory suit, without squarely deciding whether every proceeding to confirm an IDR determination is barred. The pending Agag appeal may answer that question.

What providers can do now

Under 45 C.F.R. § 149.510, the amount owed under a federal IDR determination, less the initial payment and patient cost sharing, must be paid directly to the provider within 30 calendar days after the determination. Build your process around that date.

  • Calendar the 30-day deadline for every award and record the day payment is late.
  • Report nonpayment through CMS’s provider complaint portal or the No Surprises Help Desk at 1-800-985-3059. CMS states that complaints may cover entities not complying with the federal IDR process.
  • For self-funded employer plans, also raise nonpayment with the Department of Labor’s Employee Benefits Security Administration; for insured plans, with the state insurance regulator.
  • Preserve the full record: open-negotiation notices, IDR submissions, the determination, payment-status messages, and every post-award communication, including any statement that the plan would honor the award.
  • Review pending federal suits so they do not rest only on a direct No Surprises Act claim, and evaluate state-law theories with ERISA preemption in mind.
  • Weigh whether marginal disputes are worth filing when collection depends on regulators. Batching and fee rules under the 2026 federal operations rule bear on that calculation.

Choosing the forum matters more now

The coverage behind each claim decides the forum. Disputes under fully insured, state-regulated New York plans generally go to New York IDR under Financial Services Law Article 6, administered by the Department of Financial Services. Self-funded employer plans go to federal IDR. Since August 26, 2026, Empire Plan disputes go to New York IDR under their own criteria, and since May 28, 2026, Medicaid managed care disputes are excluded from New York IDR altogether.

New York determinations stand on a different footing. Article 6 makes them binding and admissible in any court proceeding, and the Second Circuit’s reasoning rested on the text and enforcement structure of the federal statute, not on Article 6. As of this writing we are not aware of a reported appellate decision on how a New York IDR determination is enforced in court, so that route also carries uncertainty.

We represent physicians, practices, and facilities in New York and federal IDR, in pursuing unpaid awards through regulators and in court, and in out-of-network underpayment litigation.

Not legal advice. This article is general information about New York law as of the date above. It is not legal advice, may not reflect later changes, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.